The Iwakura Mission: Half a Government Sails West

Hamilton Fish asked to see the letter, and there wasn’t one. In March 1872 the American Secretary of State sat across a table in Washington from the most powerful men in Japan, who had come to talk about rewriting the treaties their country had signed under pressure from foreign warships, and he asked, reasonably, for the document that empowered them to sign anything. Iwakura Tomomi, Ōkubo Toshimichi, Kido Takayoshi and Itō Hirobumi had brought a letter from their emperor saying who they were. Nobody had thought to bring one saying what they could do.

So Ōkubo and Itō went home to fetch it. That meant a train back across the continent, a steamer across the Pacific, an audience in Tokyo and the whole journey again in reverse, about four months there and back, while the rest of the delegation waited in Washington. By the time the two men returned with the paper, the talks it was meant to authorise were already dead.

I like to begin with that story because it is the Iwakura Mission (岩倉使節団) in miniature: proud, underprepared, quick to learn and entirely willing to cross the world twice to put a mistake right. For a little under twenty-one months, from December 1871 to September 1873, roughly half of Japan’s new government toured twelve countries, with a forty-six-year-old court noble in a topknot at its head and a six-year-old girl among its passengers. What they saw shaped much of what Japan became in the Meiji era. And you can still follow them, from a museum above a Tokyo station to the thatched house in the hills north of Kyoto where the ambassador once hid.

Photograph of Kido Takayoshi, Yamaguchi Naoyoshi, Iwakura Tomomi, Ito Hirobumi and Okubo Toshimichi, 1872
The five envoys, from left: Kido Takayoshi, Yamaguchi Naoyoshi, Iwakura Tomomi, Itō Hirobumi and Ōkubo Toshimichi. One archive copy labels the picture London, but Iwakura’s topknot and silk give it away: he had his hair cut in Chicago in February 1872, so this has to be San Francisco, in the first weeks of the trip. Four men in frock coats and one in court dress is the argument of the whole mission in a single frame.

Why half a government went abroad

The treaties were the problem. When Perry’s Black Ships forced the Tokugawa shogunate out of two centuries of sakoku, the commercial treaties that followed in 1858, pushed through by Ii Naosuke with five Western powers, gave foreigners in the treaty ports their own consular courts and fixed Japan’s import duties at rates Japan could not change on its own. Every reformer in the country, from the old shogunal officials to the young men who had overthrown them in the Meiji Restoration, hated those clauses. By the early 1870s Japan had treaties of this kind with fifteen countries, and the 1858 agreements allowed for revision from 1 July 1872.

That date drove almost everything that followed.

Nor was the idea of a journey new. The shogunate had sent embassies of its own to the United States in 1860 and to Europe in 1862, and in 1869 a Dutch-American missionary teacher, Guido Verbeck, gave the young official Ōkuma Shigenobu a paper he called the Brief Sketch, suggesting that the new government send its leading men to look at the West for themselves. Itō pressed a similar plan. Ōkuma, for his part, meant to lead a small mission himself.

What happened next is murky, and Japanese historians still argue about it. Ōkuma’s small trip turned, in the early autumn of 1871, into a large one led by Iwakura, with Kido and Ōkubo as vice-ambassadors, and the usual reading is that the Satsuma and Chōshū men took it over to keep the treaty question in their own hands. There was a second motive. Kido and Ōkubo, the leading men of Chōshū and Satsuma, were at odds over money and policy, and sending them off together for ten months was one way of shelving the quarrel.

The timing was bold. In August 1871 the government had abolished the domains at a stroke and replaced them with prefectures, the biggest administrative change since the Edo era began, and four months later its senior figures were leaving the country. The men who stayed behind, the “caretaker government” under Sanjō Sanetomi with Saigō Takamori, Itagaki Taisuke and Ōkuma, signed a twelve-article agreement promising to make no major reforms until the travellers came home. They broke it almost at once.

Conscription, a national school system, the land-tax reform and a new calendar were all decided while the ambassadors were away. The calendar alone is why the dates of this trip are such a mess. The mission left Yokohama on the 12th day of the 11th month of Meiji 4, which was 23 December 1871 in the West, and while it was in Europe Japan dropped the lunar calendar altogether, so that Meiji 5 simply stopped on the 2nd day of its 12th month and the next morning was 1 January 1873. Japanese reference books, counting the old-style months, usually call the trip a year and ten months; by the Western calendar it was about twenty and a half.

Portrait of Iwakura Tomomi, leader of the Iwakura Mission
Iwakura Tomomi as Minister of the Right, the post he was given a few weeks before he sailed. A court noble of modest family, he had spent five years in disgrace outside Kyoto for being too friendly with the shogunate, and then helped bring it down. He set off for America dressed much like this, and changed his mind in Chicago.

Who went: ambassadors, scribes and five girls

Nobody agrees on how many went, which tells you how fluid the party was. Japanese sources usually give 107 people in all; others count forty-six envoys and officials at departure, or forty-eight, or about fifty, with another forty-odd to sixty students depending on who is counted, and several officials joined later or went home early. The core was small: Iwakura, forty-six, ambassador extraordinary and plenipotentiary, with four vice-ambassadors, Kido, thirty-eight, Ōkubo, forty-one, Itō, thirty, and Yamaguchi Naoyoshi of Saga, thirty-two. Japanese reference books add a year to each of those ages, because they count the old way.

The average age of the officials was about thirty. The envoys were Satsuma, Chōshū and court, the men who had won the Boshin War; Kido was the Chōshū leader whom Sakamoto Ryōma had helped bring into alliance with Satsuma in 1866. Many of the secretaries, though, were former shogunal officials, chosen because they had been abroad before and could manage English, French or Dutch. I find that mix more interesting than the famous names: the winners of a civil war travelling with the losers’ diplomats, because nobody else knew how to talk to a foreign minister.

Each ministry sent its own specialists, the rijikan, to study courts, schools, armies, mints and factories, each with a small staff. Among the justice ministry men who followed later was Kawaji Toshiyoshi, who would build Japan’s police on the French model; keep the name in mind. The chronicler was Kume Kunitake (久米邦武), a thirty-two-year-old scholar from Saga who had served the old daimyo Nabeshima Kansō, and whom Iwakura picked as his personal recorder shortly before sailing.

Portrait of the historian Kume Kunitake in later life
Kume Kunitake in old age, in a portrait dated December 1926. He went on the mission as a junior secretary with a notebook, came home and spent five years writing it up, largely on his own. He lived to ninety-one, long enough to see his record almost forgotten, and not long enough to see it revived.

Five girls and a ten-year scholarship

Then there were the students, around fifty young men and five girls. The girls were the idea of Kuroda Kiyotaka, the same Kuroda who had directed the final campaign against Goryōkaku two years earlier and was now deputy head of the Kaitakushi, the office colonising Hokkaido and the Ainu lands. He had come back from America convinced that Japan needed educated mothers. The terms were extraordinary: ten years abroad, every cost paid and $800 a year on top, and almost nobody applied.

The five who went were all daughters of the losing side. Ueda Teiko and Yoshimasu Ryōko, both about fourteen, were daughters of shogunal retainers; Nagai Shigeko, eight or ten depending on the source, was the adopted daughter of another; Yamakawa Sutematsu, eleven, came from a senior family of Aizu, the domain the new government had besieged and broken in 1868. The youngest was Tsuda Umeko (津田梅子), daughter of a former shogunal interpreter, who was six.

Japanese reference books variously make her seven, eight or nine. She was born on 31 December 1864, the third day of the twelfth month by the old calendar, so when she sailed she was six by Western counting and eight by the traditional Japanese one, in which you are one at birth and a year older every New Year. When an age or a date in this story looks off by one, the calendar is usually to blame.

Before they left, the five were received by the empress, the first daughters of samurai families ever given that honour. Yamakawa’s mother gave her a new name for the journey. She had been called Saki; now she was Sutematsu, from suteru, to throw away, and matsu, to wait: I have given you up, and I will wait for you to come back.

Sutematsu had been eight during the siege of Tsuruga Castle, and was wounded in the neck when a shell burst in the room where her family was eating; her sister-in-law died of her burns. The guns outside were commanded on the first day by a young Satsuma officer named Ōyama Iwao. By one Japanese account he left Yokohama for Geneva the day after she sailed for America, and in 1883 she married him.

The five Japanese girl students of the Iwakura Mission with Mrs DeLong in San Francisco, January 1872
The five girls in San Francisco in January 1872 with Mrs DeLong, wife of the American minister who travelled with the mission. From left: Yamakawa Sutematsu, Ueda Teiko, Tsuda Umeko, Mrs DeLong, Yoshimasu Ryōko and Nagai Shigeko. Tsuda is the small one, and she is already looking at the camera as if it owes her something.
Tsuda Umeko as a small girl in a white Western dress and hat, early 1870s
Tsuda Umeko soon after arriving in America, already in a white dress and a hat. Nine months after landing she wrote and illustrated an account of the voyage in English, and the little book survives at Tsuda University. When she came home in 1882 she had forgotten most of her Japanese.

America: a speech, a snowdrift and a missing letter

The mission sailed from Yokohama on 23 December 1871 aboard the America, a Pacific Mail paddle steamer of about 4,500 tons with, by the mission’s own count, thirty first-class cabins and sixteen second-class. The American minister to Japan, Charles DeLong, came along with his wife. The ship had less than a year to live: on 24 August 1872 she caught fire in Yokohama harbour and burned with heavy loss of life. By then her most famous passengers were in Liverpool.

They landed in San Francisco on 15 January 1872 to a welcome that convinced several of them the treaties would be easy. At a banquet on 23 January, before some three hundred guests, Itō made the speech; he had been smuggled to London as a student in 1863 and had the best English of the five envoys. The passage still quoted in Japan, where it is called the Hinomaru speech, promised that the red disc on the flag would no longer look like a seal on a closed country but would be what it was meant to be, the rising sun, moving onward among the nations of the world.

Itō and Ōkubo also signed, in California, the Meiji government’s first contract with an American company, an agreement with the Bank of California connected with the new gold coinage, and the document with both their signatures survives. Ōkubo had his photograph taken in a frock coat. Iwakura did not.

Okubo Toshimichi in Western dress, photographed in San Francisco in early 1872
Ōkubo in San Francisco in early 1872, photographed at the Yosemite Art Gallery studio on Montgomery Street. In Kagoshima he had been the hardest man in Satsuma politics; here he looks like a provincial bank manager, which, for the purposes of the contract he signed in California, he briefly was.

The mission left San Francisco by chartered train on 31 January and ran into one of the worst winters the railway had seen. Snow buried the line in the mountains to the east, and the party, which had meant to pass Salt Lake City by, was stranded there from 3 February, when it left the main line at Ogden, until the 22nd. Kume wrote of being confined for seventeen days, a Japanese biography of Tsuda says eighteen, and American historians count nineteen; it depends where you start.

They made the best of it. They called on Brigham Young and the mayor, Daniel Wells; Itō struck up a friendship with the business manager of the Deseret News; and on 11 February Kume sat through a sermon by Orson Pratt at the Mormon meeting house and decided it was much like any other Protestant service. By the 21st, with melting snow flooding the rivers and washing out the track, he recorded that there was nothing left in the city to see.

Cabinet photograph of Brigham Young by Fox and Symons, Salt Lake City, around 1870
Brigham Young around 1870, in a signed cabinet card from the Salt Lake studio of Fox and Symons. He was seventy when the snowbound Japanese called. In 2002, during the Winter Olympics, Utah unveiled a plaque to the visit, intended for the old Union Pacific station on South Temple, near where the party stepped down into the snow.

Chicago, still rebuilding after the great fire of the previous October, was where two changes happened. The five girls, who had crossed the continent in their kimono, finally got Western clothes after going to Iwakura themselves to ask. And Iwakura, who had kept his topknot as a matter of national pride and appeared in American newspaper drawings in court robes and hakama, was talked into cutting it off by his son Tomosada, a student in America, who told him it made Japan look primitive. He wore Western clothes from then on.

The five Japanese girl students of the Iwakura Mission in Western dresses and hats, 1872
The five in Western dresses and feathered hats, the eldest standing. Some archives place this photograph in Washington; Japanese accounts say the girls were photographed in Chicago in their new clothes. Either way it was taken within weeks of the picture in kimono, and the two side by side are the shortest history of the period I know.

They reached Washington on 29 February, and on 4 March President Grant received them in the East Room of the White House. The Americans could not have been friendlier, which is partly why the ambassadors decided to try for a new treaty on the spot. It was not in their instructions. They had been sent to present the emperor’s letters and make preliminary soundings, not to negotiate.

Wood engraving of the Iwakura Mission presented to President Grant in the East Room of the White House, 1872
The presentation to President Grant and his Cabinet in the East Room, a wood engraving after a sketch by James E. Taylor for Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper. The envoys wore Japanese court dress and tall black caps for the occasion, whatever they wore the rest of the week. The papers covered the visit like a royal tour, and the Japanese drew the wrong conclusion from it.

Then came Hamilton Fish, the question of full powers and Ōkubo and Itō’s long trip home. While they were away, the British chargé d’affaires in Tokyo, Francis Adams, and the German minister, Max von Brandt, came through Washington on their way to Europe and spent four days with Iwakura and Kido. Von Brandt explained the most-favoured-nation clause: whatever Japan conceded to the Americans in a new treaty, every other treaty power would get automatically, without giving anything back. Iwakura, by the Japanese accounts, had known nothing of it and was astonished.

That was the end of the American treaty. A separate deal with Washington would have handed the Europeans American concessions for nothing, and the other treaty powers were already irritated at being bypassed. By the time Ōkubo and Itō came back with the emperor’s letter of full powers there was nothing left to sign, and in early August the mission sailed from Boston, eight months after landing in a country it had planned to cross in a few weeks.

Plate of Iwakura Tomomi and the vice-ambassadors from Charles Lanman's The Japanese in America, 1872
The envoys again, as Charles Lanman printed them in The Japanese in America, published in New York in 1872 while the mission was still on the road, which, with Iwakura’s topknot, rules out London as the place the photograph was taken. Lanman, secretary to the Japanese legation, compiled the book in a hurry. He also took Tsuda Umeko into his house in Georgetown and kept her there for ten years.

Not all of the American stay was wasted. The specialists toured schools, colleges, factories and prisons from Washington to New York and Boston, and the girls were placed with families. Tsuda went to Lanman and his wife Adeline in Georgetown; she was meant to stay a year and stayed ten, and the Lanmans wrote that if her scholarship were ever stopped they would keep and educate her at their own expense. Ueda and Yoshimasu went home that October, one ill and one with failing eyesight.

Portrait of Mori Arinori, Japan's envoy in Washington, from Charles Lanman's book of 1872
Mori Arinori, Japan’s envoy in Washington, from Lanman’s book. He was twenty-four, had studied in London, and had just written a pamphlet arguing that Japan should grant religious freedom. In 1889, on the morning the Meiji constitution was proclaimed, a man who believed he had insulted the Ise Shrine stabbed him, and he died the next day.

Britain and the forty-year gap

The Cunard steamer Olympus landed the mission at Liverpool on 17 August 1872. They had timed it badly. Queen Victoria was in Scotland and in no hurry to come south, Parliament had risen for the summer, and so instead of a short diplomatic stay the ambassadors spent four months touring the most industrial country on earth while they waited for an audience.

It was the best accident of the trip. After weeks in London, where they saw the British Museum, rode the new Underground and heard concerts at the Royal Albert Hall, and a visit to the dockyard at Portsmouth, the party went north: to Manchester and Liverpool, Glasgow and the Clyde shipyards, Edinburgh and the Highlands, then Newcastle, Bradford, Halifax and Sheffield, Chatsworth, Birmingham, Worcester, the Potteries and Chester. Kume’s account of Britain fills twenty of the hundred chapters of his record, as much as America.

In Glasgow they stayed with Lord Blantyre at Erskine House and walked the yards on the Clyde. In Newcastle they met William Armstrong, watched guns being bored at Elswick and went down Gosforth Colliery; orders for ships and armaments followed. In Yorkshire, with the British minister Harry Parkes as their guide, they saw the mill towns that Titus Salt and John Crossley had built around their works at Saltaire and Halifax, with schools, almshouses and parks for the workers.

Salts Mill seen from beside the Leeds and Liverpool Canal at Saltaire, West Yorkshire
Salts Mill at Saltaire, Titus Salt’s wool and alpaca works of 1853, beside the Leeds and Liverpool Canal. The mission saw it running in October 1872, along with the model village Salt built for his workers. The mill closed in 1986 and is now galleries and shops, and the village is a World Heritage Site. Photo: Foto43, CC BY 2.0.

Kume wrote it all down, from furnace temperatures to the price of coal, and drew a conclusion that I think is the most important single observation of the whole trip. Europe’s wealth, he noted, was recent: it dated from about 1800, and its real flowering only from the last forty years. Britain had not always been like this. The gap was not centuries but a generation, and a generation could be closed.

He also talked to old men about what their towns had been like before the railways, which is not what official recorders usually bother to do. Kido, who kept his own diary, was shaken by the slums and the opium users of London and by the poverty of the people whose labour made the wealth he had come to admire. He came home suspicious of unbridled capitalism in a way Ōkubo never was, and that difference would matter.

Kido Takayoshi in a frock coat, photographed in London in 1872
Kido Takayoshi in London in 1872, photographed by the Southwell Brothers. Of the five envoys he was the most troubled by what he saw, and the one whose relations with Ōkubo got steadily worse on the road. He was thirty-nine, and had less than five years to live.

Manchester gave them a civic banquet on 7 October, with toasts to the region’s mills and its municipal government. Iwakura’s farewell, as the city remembers it, was that the mission had found friendship at every turn and hoped one day to return the kindness in Japan. In 1997, for the 125th anniversary, a delegation of more than seventy industrialists from Osaka came to Manchester and sat down to the dinner again.

Plaque commemorating the Iwakura Mission's 1872 reception at the old Manchester Town Hall
The red plaque on the site of Manchester’s original town hall, put up for the 125th anniversary. It quotes Iwakura on leaving the city in October 1872 and gives the delegation as forty, which is about the size of the party that came north rather than the whole mission. The town hall itself was demolished long ago, and its colonnade now stands in Heaton Park.

Victoria finally received them at Windsor on 5 December. By then the mission had a scandal of its own. In November the London bank of the Bowles Brothers collapsed, taking with it the deposits of about forty Japanese, envoys and students among them, who had been talked into banking there by Minami Teisuke, a Chōshū man working for the firm and better remembered as one half of what may be Japan’s first legal international marriage. Of some £22,800 deposited, about £18,500 was lost.

Tokyo’s wits enjoyed that. One comic verse of the day ran, roughly, “the treaty botched and the money thrown away, what will the ambassador say to the world?” The joke does not survive translation, since it hangs on two puns, taishi (ambassador) for taishi (towards), and Iwakura for iwa, to say.

The continent: Bismarck’s dinner and the Urakami question

Paris came next, from 16 December, a city still repairing the damage of the Prussian siege and the Commune of the year before, and President Thiers received the mission on 26 December. Kume read the Commune as a warning about class war in a civilised country. Then came Belgium and the Netherlands, and on 9 March 1873 Berlin, capital of a German empire barely two years old.

Engraving of the Iwakura Mission received by President Adolphe Thiers in Paris, December 1872
President Thiers receiving the mission in Paris on 26 December 1872, in a French engraving. Thiers had crushed the Commune eighteen months earlier, and the burnt-out shell of the Tuileries Palace was still standing a short walk away when the Japanese arrived. It was not cleared until 1883.

On 15 March Bismarck gave the ambassadors dinner, and after it a lecture they never forgot. The nations of the world, he said in the version the Japanese recorded, dealt with one another in friendship and courtesy only on the surface; underneath, the strong ate the weak. He reminded them how poor and small Prussia had been in his youth. International law, he went on, was something great powers kept when it suited them and replaced with force when it did not, and a small country that trusted in it would be disappointed.

He added that Britain and France were busy swallowing colonies, that he understood Japan’s position because he had been born in a small state himself, and that Germany, which respected the rights of nations, was the natural friend for Japan to choose. It was a sales pitch as much as a confession. Moltke, the chief of the general staff, told them much the same about armies. I suspect it landed so hard because nobody in London or Washington had said it out loud.

Engraved portrait of Otto von Bismarck published in 1873
Bismarck in an engraving published in 1873, the year he entertained the mission. Ōkubo wrote home about the great teachers he had met in Berlin, and a later generation decided he had modelled himself on the Iron Chancellor; read the letter and he lumps Bismarck in with Moltke and the rest. Itō was the real admirer, down to the cigars.
Copperplate illustration of the Brandenburg Gate in Berlin from the Bei-O Kairan Jikki, 1878
The Brandenburg Gate in a Japanese copperplate dated to 1878, the year Kume’s record came out with more than three hundred illustrations of this kind: careful, a little stiff, and for most Japanese readers of the day very likely the first accurate picture of a European capital they had ever seen.

Everywhere they went in Europe, one subject kept coming up. In 1867, in the last months of the shogunate, the authorities at Nagasaki had arrested the hidden Christians of Urakami, villagers who had kept their faith in secret for two and a half centuries and revealed themselves to a French priest two years before. The new government, which kept the old ban on Christianity and restated it on public notice boards in 1868, finished the job. More than three thousand people were exiled to domains across western Japan, and by the usual count 662 of them died there.

The story had followed the ambassadors from the start. A Nagasaki English-language paper had described Iwakura as a persecutor of Christians, and American newspapers picked the article up while the mission was in Washington. Itō and Yamaguchi argued for lifting the ban there and then; Iwakura refused. In Britain, France, Belgium and Germany, ministers, newspapers and petitioners raised it again and again, until the ambassadors concluded that the persecution was the biggest single obstacle to treaty revision.

They cabled home. On 24 February 1873 the government took down the notice boards banning Christianity, a fixture of Japanese towns since the 17th century, and on 14 March it ordered the exiles released. Note what it did not do: Christianity was never formally declared legal at home, the boards simply disappeared, foreign governments were told the ban was over, and religious freedom reached the statute book only with the constitution of 1889.

For a persecution that had begun in earnest with the Twenty-Six Martyrs of 1597, it was an oddly quiet ending. By one count 1,930 exiles went home to Urakami after five years away, some having been released earlier after giving in under pressure; sources give the numbers differently. The survivors called their exile tabi, the journey. In 1879 they began building a church of their own in Urakami.

Wooden notice board of 1682 offering rewards for informing on Christians, British Museum
A notice board of 1682, now in the British Museum, listing the rewards for informing on priests, believers and anyone who sheltered them. Boards like this stood at crossroads and bridges all over Edo-period Japan. The Meiji government put up its own in 1868, and the ambassadors’ cables from Europe got them taken down. Photo: Zunkir, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The tour rolled on: St Petersburg, where Kume compared Russia’s freed serfs with Japan’s farmers, Copenhagen and Stockholm in April, Italy in May, which Kume treated as the fountainhead of European civilisation, and Vienna in June, where the World’s Fair was the first at which the Meiji government exhibited officially. The small countries, Belgium, Denmark and Switzerland, impressed him in a different way. They kept their independence by being useful, armed and careful, which looked like a lesson Japan could use.

Illustration of the entrance to the Japanese section at the 1873 Vienna World's Fair
The entrance to the Japanese section in the main hall of the Vienna World’s Fair of 1873, from a Japanese album published in 1897. The government sent a Shinto shrine and garden, great porcelain vases and one of the golden shachihoko from the roof of Nagoya Castle. Europe’s appetite for Japanese things owes a good deal to this room.

By then the team was breaking up. An order from Tokyo recalling Ōkubo and Kido, dated 19 January, caught up with them in Berlin on 19 March. The two were no longer on good terms and would not travel home together: Ōkubo left on 28 March and was back in Yokohama by the end of May, while Kido carried on with the main party into Russia, broke away in April and reached Japan on 23 July. Iwakura, Itō and the rest went on through Italy, Austria and Switzerland, and sailed from Marseille on 20 July.

Home to a quarrel

The voyage home ran through Suez, Aden, Ceylon, Singapore, Saigon, Hong Kong and Shanghai, a string of European colonies and footholds that made a deeper impression than their brief stops would suggest. Kume, who had spent a year and a half admiring Europe, now watched Europeans running Asian ports while Asians did the carrying. Historians in Japan have argued ever since that this last leg did as much as any factory to shape the later slogan of leaving Asia to join Europe, and the contempt for Asian neighbours that came with it.

The Pacific Mail steamer Golden Age brought them into Yokohama on 13 September 1873, to find the government at war with itself. The caretakers had done a great deal: they had founded the school system, introduced conscription, launched the land-tax reform, opened the first railway between Shinbashi and Yokohama and made Ryukyu, the old kingdom of Shuri Castle, into a domain of Japan. They had also, against every promise, taken up the question of Korea.

Korea had refused to accept Japan’s letters announcing the new imperial government, objecting to wording that set the Japanese emperor above its own king, and the quarrel had festered since 1868. In the summer of 1873 Saigō proposed to go to Korea himself as envoy, unarmed.

His letters suggest he expected to be killed, which would give Japan a just cause to send the first Japanese army into Korea since Hideyoshi’s invasions of the 1590s. Whether he wanted that war or meant to head it off is still argued. In August the council agreed in principle, subject to Iwakura’s return.

The returning ambassadors had seen what a modern state cost, and they wanted no war yet. Iwakura and Ōkubo argued that Japan had to build itself up first, and Kido, who had once been keen on a Korean expedition himself, agreed. At the council of 14 and 15 October the two sides deadlocked, the chief minister Sanjō collapsed under the strain, and Iwakura took over as acting head of the government.

He then did something neat. On 23 October he laid both opinions before the emperor along with his own, and the next day Emperor Meiji accepted Iwakura’s view and the embassy to Korea was postponed indefinitely. Saigō resigned. Itagaki, Etō Shinpei, Gotō Shōjirō and Soejima Taneomi followed, and some six hundred officers and officials went with them.

Woodblock print by Suzuki Toshimoto of the 1873 council debate over Korea, with Saigo Takamori at the centre
The Korea debate as a Tokyo printmaker imagined it, with Saigō at the centre. Suzuki Toshimoto made the print in 1877, the year of the Satsuma Rebellion, when anything with Saigō in it sold. The council never met in a room like this, and Saigō, being Saigō, is the largest man in it.

The split shaped the next five years. In January 1874 swordsmen attacked Iwakura’s carriage at Kuichigai on his way home from the palace, and he survived by tumbling into the moat, where they lost sight of him in the dark; in February Etō raised the Saga Rebellion. In 1877 Saigō led the Satsuma men against the government, besieged Kumamoto Castle and died on the hill above Kagoshima that September. Kido died of illness in Kyoto in May 1877, in the middle of the war, and Ōkubo was cut down on his way to the palace a year later, at a spot you can still visit.

What the mission changed

The mission failed at the one thing it was supposed to do. No treaty was revised in 1872, or for twenty years after: extraterritoriality ended only with a new treaty signed with Britain in July 1894, a fortnight before the First Sino-Japanese War, and full tariff autonomy came in 1911, after the Russo-Japanese War. The lesson the ambassadors took home, the one Bismarck had spelled out over dinner, was that you did not argue your way out of an unequal treaty. You grew out of it.

Nearly everything else, it changed. Ōkubo came home and created the Home Ministry in November 1873 and ran the country through it, pushing state factories, roads and industry. Itō, who had seen the German states at close quarters, went back to Berlin and Vienna in 1882 to study constitutions properly, and the constitution of 1889 shows it. The army, the navy, the police, the post, the schools and the prisons all took something from the specialists’ notes, and a student on the mission, Kaneko Kentarō, would one day use his friendship with Theodore Roosevelt, a fellow Harvard man, to help end the war with Russia.

The specialists’ notes are a story in themselves. They were supposed to file reports, the Riji Kōtei, and some did: Tanaka Fujimaro’s fifteen volumes on Western education, drafted for him by Niijima Jō, who had been studying in America and was taken on as an interpreter, fed straight into policy. But in 1876 the government had to order twenty-four members to produce their overdue reports, complaining that otherwise nobody could tell who had worked and who had idled, and in the end only ten did. Many of the mission’s papers had already gone up in smoke when the palace burned on 5 May 1873, in the old western citadel of Edo Castle.

Contents page from the Riji Kotei, the specialist reports of the Iwakura Mission, on German education
A contents page from the Riji Kōtei, the specialists’ reports, from a volume on schooling: church and state in education, local school inspectors, school funds, compulsory attendance and half-day schools. It is the dull end of the mission, and the end that changed the most lives, since generations of Japanese children sat in classrooms shaped by pages like this. Photo: Fraxinus2, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Iwakura did not live to see the constitution. Throat cancer was diagnosed in 1883 by Erwin Bälz, the German professor of medicine at Tokyo, who told him so plainly, the first recorded case in Japan of a doctor telling a patient he had cancer. The emperor visited him more than once, and he died on 20 July 1883; his was the first state funeral of modern Japan.

Painting by Kita Renzo of Emperor Meiji visiting Iwakura Tomomi on his sickbed in 1883
Kita Renzō’s painting of the emperor at Iwakura’s bedside, made in 1927 for the Meiji Memorial Picture Gallery. The emperor’s last visit came the day before Iwakura died. The painter was seven at the time, and the summer light falling across the floor is his best guess.

The girls changed things more slowly. Nagai Shigeko studied music at Vassar and came home in 1881 to teach piano at the government’s new music institute, one of the first Western-trained musicians in the country. Yamakawa Sutematsu graduated from Vassar in June 1882 with high honours, the first Japanese woman to earn a bachelor’s degree; Tsuda finished school in Washington the same summer, and the two sailed home together that autumn to find the government had no work for them.

Sutematsu married Ōyama, the Satsuma gunner who had shelled Aizu, and put her English to work for the Red Cross and for Japan’s case in the American papers during two wars. Tsuda went back to America for three years at Bryn Mawr, taught at the Peeresses’ School, and in 1900 opened a small English school for women in Kōjimachi, the Joshi Eigaku Juku. It is now Tsuda University, and since 2024 her face has been on the ¥5,000 note.

Yamakawa Sutematsu in formal court robes in 1882, the year she returned from America
Yamakawa Sutematsu in court robes, around the time she came home in 1882. The girl who had been under fire at Aizu returned with a Vassar degree, almost no written Japanese and, before long, a proposal from the man whose guns had shelled her family. She accepted him.
Portrait of Tsuda Umeko around 1900, when she founded the Joshi Eigaku Juku
Tsuda Umeko around 1900, the year she opened her school. She never married, and she taught women English at a time when official thinking about girls’ education stopped at “good wife, wise mother”. Tsuda University’s main campus is now at Kodaira in western Tokyo.

And then there is Kume’s book. The Tokumei Zenken Taishi Bei-Ō Kairan Jikki (特命全権大使米欧回覧実記), “A True Account of the Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary’s Tour of America and Europe”, came out in October 1878 in five volumes of a hundred chapters, with more than three hundred copperplates, and it is far better than an official report has any right to be. Kume measured, counted, compared and gave his own opinions freely. The government paid him a reward of ¥500, an enormous sum, and he spent part of it on land at Meguro and sent his son to study painting in France.

The first printing was 500 copies, and perhaps 3,000 sets were sold in five years before the book sank almost without trace; it came back only with the Iwanami paperback edition of 1977–82, and a full English translation followed in 2002. Kume himself got into trouble in 1892 for an essay arguing that Shinto was an ancient custom of heaven worship rather than a religion in the Western sense. The nationalists howled, he lost his chair at the Imperial University, and he moved to the college Ōkuma had founded, now Waseda, where he taught for another two decades.

Volumes of Kume Kunitake's Bei-O Kairan Jikki on display at the Saga Prefectural Museum
Volumes of the Bei-Ō Kairan Jikki in the Saga Prefectural Museum, one of them open at a copperplate. Saga claims Kume as its own, with reason: he grew up in the domain whose lord, Nabeshima Kansō, built a reverberatory furnace and cast iron cannon when the rest of Japan was still arguing about whether to let foreigners land.

If you want to see where all this sits in the longer story, my walk through 1,200 years of Japanese history sets the mission between the fall of the shogunate and Japan’s wars with China and Russia.

Where to find the Iwakura Mission today

The mission visited twelve countries, but in Japan you need only two cities and a morning in a third to follow it. Start in Tokyo with Kume and finish with Ōkubo. Kyoto has Iwakura’s house, and Yokohama has the quay they sailed from.

The Kume Museum of Art, Meguro

The museum Kume’s descendants opened in 1982 is on the eighth floor of the Kume Building, the curved brown block across the road from the bus stops outside the west exit of JR Meguro Station, one minute on foot; from the Tokyu Meguro, Namboku and Mita line platforms allow two. A statue of Kunitake waits in the lift hall. It is small, a few rooms in which Kume’s papers and the mission material share the space with the paintings of his son Keiichirō, who trained in Paris alongside Kuroda Seiki and became one of the founders of Western-style painting in Japan.

It opens 10:00–17:00 (last entry 16:30) and closes on Mondays (or the following day when Monday is a holiday), over New Year and between exhibitions. Admission is ¥500 for adults, ¥300 for high-school and university students and ¥200 for children. Check what is on before you go: the exhibition running until 10 December 2026 is Keiichirō’s collection of Japanese paintings, while the father-and-son show that puts Kunitake and the mission at the centre ran this summer and autumn.

I would go even in an off season for the Jikki, because the son’s paintings are good and the building stands in the neighbourhood where Kume spent his reward. But time it right and you get the notebooks, the copperplates and the record itself, which is the reason to come.

The Kume Building by Meguro Station, Tokyo, home of the Kume Museum of Art on the eighth floor
The Kume Building at the corner of Meguro-dōri and Mita-dōri, with the museum’s name in characters across the top. The museum is up on the eighth floor, above a trust bank and a cram school, and from the pavement you would never guess it was there.

Iwakura Tomomi’s retreat, Kyoto

In 1862, accused of selling out the court to the shogunate, Iwakura resigned, shaved his head and was banished from the city. From 1864 he lived in a carpenter’s house in the farming village of Iwakura, in the hills north of Kyoto, adding a new main house to it, and here he spent about three years plotting with the men of Satsuma and Chōshū until he was pardoned in 1867. Weeks later he helped stage the palace coup of January 1868 that stripped Tokugawa Yoshinobu of his office and lands.

The retreat has been a national historic site since 1932, and it is one of the best small places in Kyoto. You come in through the front gate into a garden with a pond and a red pine Iwakura is said to have planted, then round the plain thatched main house of about sixty square metres. Beyond it are the stone holding a lock of his hair, the stone for his wife Makiko beside it, and the Taigaku Bunko, a little concrete museum of 1928 by the architect Takeda Goichi.

Do not expect the mission’s documents. The main collection of Iwakura’s papers, more than a thousand items designated an Important Cultural Property, is at the Kyoto City Historical Archives, not here. There is a new reason to go all the same: Ōkubo’s tea room from his old Kyoto house, rediscovered by chance in 2019 when the building around it was being rebuilt, has been moved here under its Taishō-era name, Yūtai-an, and the site expects to open it to the public from November 2026. A room built for the tea ceremony by the coldest operator in Meiji politics now stands in his old ally’s garden, which seems about right.

Opening hours are 9:00–17:00 (last entry 16:30), closed on Wednesdays (or the next weekday when Wednesday is a holiday) and from 29 December to 3 January. Admission is ¥400, rising to ¥500 on busy days in late November, with ¥200 for secondary students and ¥100 for primary. Numbers are limited, so book a timed slot through the official website, where tickets are paid in advance and not refundable. Take the Karasuma subway line to Kokusaikaikan and Kyoto Bus 24 to the terminus at Iwakura Jissōin, then walk three minutes south, or walk twenty minutes from Iwakura Station on the Eizan line.

Thatched main house of Iwakura Tomomi's former retreat in Iwakura, Kyoto, under light snow
The thatched main house under a dusting of snow, with Iwakura’s pine on the left. Inside, a six-mat anteroom and a six-mat reception room with an alcove sit in a row, which is not much room in which to plan the end of a government. The city spent four years restoring it from 2008. Photo: 笹谷康之, CC BY-SA 4.0.
Stone monument holding a lock of Iwakura Tomomi's hair at his former retreat in Kyoto
The memorial stones behind the house, where a lock of Iwakura’s hair is enshrined beside his wife. He is buried in Tokyo, at Kaian-ji in Shinagawa; this is where he is remembered, in the village that happens to share his name and where he waited out the last years of the shogunate. Photo: 笹谷康之, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Zō-no-hana Park, Yokohama

The mission sailed from Yokohama, the port the shogunate had opened in 1859. The original landing stage, the East Pier, was given a curving breakwater in 1867 that people called the elephant’s trunk, zō-no-hana, and the city treats the spot as the place the ambassadors set out from. For the port’s 150th anniversary in 2009 the breakwater was rebuilt in its mid-Meiji shape and the waterfront became Zō-no-hana Park, with the rails and turntable of the old Meiji quay preserved in the paving.

In 2018, for the 150th anniversary of the Restoration, the city’s board of education put up a large panel here reproducing Yamaguchi Hōshun’s painting of the departure, Iwakura, Kido and Ōkubo leaving the harbour, with an explanation in Japanese and English. The original hangs in the Meiji Memorial Picture Gallery in the outer garden of Meiji Shrine, which is closed for conservation until the end of August 2027, so for now the panel is the closest you will get.

The park is free, and the Zō-no-hana Terrace, with its café, opens 10:00–18:00. It is three minutes’ walk from exit 1 of Nihon-ōdōri Station on the Minatomirai line. Go at dusk, when the towers of Minato Mirai light up across the water, and you can see what the mission’s grandchildren built with what it learned.

Zou-no-hana Park and its curved breakwater in Yokohama, with Minato Mirai beyond
Zō-no-hana Park, with the rebuilt breakwater curving out from the left and the towers of Minato Mirai beyond. In 1871 most of what you can see on the far side of the water was sea. The America lay out in the harbour, and the ambassadors went out to her by boat.

Kioizaka: Shimizudani Park, Tokyo

At about half past eight on the morning of 14 May 1878, Ōkubo’s carriage was on its way from his house to the temporary palace at Akasaka when six men stopped it at Shimizudani, at the foot of the Kioi slope. Five were former samurai from Ishikawa and one from Shimane, and they were furious that Saigō had been driven out over Korea. They killed Ōkubo and his coachman, Nakamura Tarō. The police chief who had brushed aside warnings of the plot, asking what anyone from Ishikawa could possibly do, was Kawaji Toshiyoshi, the same man who had followed the mission to Europe to study the French police.

The ground became Shimizudani Park in 1890, given to the city by the men who raised the memorial, and the stone still stands at its centre, 6.27 metres tall; sources date it to 1884 or to May 1888. It is a quiet place now, with a pond shaped like the character for heart, double cherries in April and office workers eating lunch in the shade of the Hotel New Otani. The park is free, always open, and three minutes’ walk from Akasaka-mitsuke or Nagatachō stations.

The tall stone memorial to Okubo Toshimichi in Shimizudani Park, Kioicho, Tokyo
The memorial to Ōkubo in Shimizudani Park, headed with his posthumous rank of Minister of the Right. It is taller than it looks in pictures, more than six metres, and was paid for by friends among the Meiji officials. His grave is in Aoyama Cemetery, a short taxi ride away. Photo: shikabane taro, CC BY 3.0.

The paper that would not have helped

I keep coming back to the missing letter because it explains why the mission mattered. Men who had won a civil war and were running a country of thirty-odd million could have sent an apology and gone home. Instead two of them crossed a continent and an ocean twice to fetch a piece of paper, and the rest stayed on to learn why they had needed it. By the time the paper arrived they had learned something more useful, which was that it would not have helped.

If you go to Meguro, stand for a minute in front of the Jikki, if it is on show, and look at the factories and parliaments that a scholar from Saga had engraved so that people who would never leave Japan could see what he had seen. Then take the train to Akasaka-mitsuke and walk down to the stone at Kioizaka. Between the two you have the whole story: the looking, and what it cost.

Scroll to Top