Taira no Kiyomori: The Villain Who Gave Miyajima Its Shrine

Some time around 1765 an anonymous Edo wit squeezed the death of Taira no Kiyomori into seventeen syllables: Kiyomori no isha wa hadaka de myaku wo tori. Kiyomori’s doctor takes his pulse stark naked. Nobody needed it explained. Everyone in Edo knew the Heike Monogatari (平家物語), and everyone knew that the great Taira lord had died in a fever so hot that water poured on his body turned to black smoke.

The joke shows how completely the storytellers won. Their Kiyomori is a furnace of pride who locked up an emperor, burned the temples of Nara and was cooked alive by his sins. The Kiyomori of the court diaries is more interesting: a warrior who outmanoeuvred the aristocrats at their own game, built a harbour at his own expense to bring Chinese ships to what is now Kobe, paid for the shrine that stands in the sea at Miyajima, and tried, for six chaotic months, to move the capital of Japan to the seaside.

Tsukioka Yoshitoshi print of Taira no Kiyomori burning with fever, attended by demons, 1883
Tsukioka Yoshitoshi’s print of Kiyomori in his fever, 1883. The demons come straight from the Heike Monogatari, in which Kiyomori’s wife dreams that the wardens of hell have come for her husband. Yoshitoshi made the flames the main event; the dying man is almost an afterthought.

He was the first warrior to run the country. Minamoto no Yoritomo usually gets that credit because his shogunate lasted, but Kiyomori got there a generation earlier, and from inside the court rather than from a camp in the east. This is his story, with a hard look at the epic that made him a villain, and it ends where you can still find him: on the water at Miyajima, in the back streets of Kobe and in the old Taira quarter of Kyoto.

A son of Ise, and possibly of an emperor

The Taira who mattered in the twelfth century were the Ise Taira, a branch of the clan descended from Emperor Kammu that served the retired emperors who really ran the late Heian era. Kiyomori’s grandfather Masamori made himself useful hunting pirates and rebels. His father Tadamori turned usefulness into rank and became the first of his line admitted to the palace hall, which the old nobility took as a personal insult.

Kiyomori was born on the 18th day of the first month of 1118, which one reference converts to 10 February. His mother was probably a lady from the household of the retired emperor Shirakawa who died in 1120. The Heike Monogatari has a better story: Shirakawa got his favourite, Gion Nyōgo, pregnant and handed her to Tadamori, so that Kiyomori was secretly an emperor’s son. A temple document found in Shiga in 1893 makes his mother Gion Nyōgo’s younger sister instead.

Taira no Kiyomori in court dress, from the 14th-century portrait scroll Tenshi Sekkan Miei
Kiyomori in the Tenshi Sekkan Miei, a 14th-century scroll of emperors, regents and ministers in the Imperial collection. It is the closest thing to a likeness that survives, and notice the company: a warrior’s son filed among the chancellors.

Historians doubt the royal paternity but take the rumour seriously, because it explains what happened next. At twelve by the Japanese count Kiyomori was given the junior fifth rank, and the courtier Nakamikado Munetada wrote in his diary that he was astonished. Sons of provincial warrior houses did not start that high.

He was not obviously destined for greatness. On the 15th day of the sixth month of 1147 his retainers brawled with the attendants of Gion shrine, the home of today’s Gion Matsuri, and an arrow struck the sanctuary. The shrine belonged to Enryaku-ji, the fighting monastery on Mount Hiei, whose monks marched on the capital demanding exile. The retired emperor Toba shielded the Taira and let Kiyomori off with a fine of thirty kin of copper.

Utagawa Yoshitora print of the tonsured Taira no Kiyomori representing Aki Province, 1866
Utagawa Yoshitora picked Kiyomori to stand for Aki Province in his 1866 series of heroes from the sixty-odd provinces, which is fair: Aki made him. The shaven head belongs to the later Kiyomori, the lay monk who still ran everything.

What made him was Aki. In 1146 he became governor of the province on the Inland Sea that is now western Hiroshima Prefecture, which gave the Taira a grip on the sea lanes carrying tax rice to the capital and Chinese goods up from Hakata. It also introduced him to the shrine of Itsukushima and its priest, Saeki Kagehiro. When Tadamori died in 1153, Kiyomori became head of the Ise Taira.

Hōgen, 1156: one morning’s work

The Fujiwara regents had once ruled through their daughters, but by the twelfth century power sat with whichever retired emperor headed the imperial family, and any dispute over who that was could turn violent. On the 2nd day of the seventh month of 1156 Toba died, and within a week his sons, the emperor Go-Shirakawa and the retired emperor Sutoku, were raising soldiers in the capital. Kiyomori’s uncle Tadamasa joined Sutoku; Kiyomori chose Go-Shirakawa, as did the Minamoto commander Minamoto no Yoshitomo, whose own father went the other way.

Before dawn on the 11th day the emperor’s men moved on Sutoku’s palace at Shirakawa, Kiyomori with more than 300 horsemen and Yoshitomo with about 200. For a few hours Yoshitomo’s brother Tametomo held them off with a bow so powerful that men he wounded were still talking about it decades later. Then Yoshitomo had the house next door set alight, the fire spread, and by eight in the morning it was over.

17th-century folding screen of battle scenes from the Hogen and Heiji rebellions in Kyoto
A 17th-century screen of the Hōgen and Heiji fighting, read right to left like a scroll. The gold clouds are a convention, and a convenient one: they hide the fact that the Hōgen battle happened in a few city blocks and lasted a morning.

The sentences shocked the court more than the fighting. No one had been lawfully executed since the Kusuko affair of 810, and now the winners were ordered to kill their own kin: Kiyomori beheaded his uncle and his uncle’s sons at Rokuhara, and Yoshitomo had to execute his father. The monk-historian Jien, in his Gukanshō, marked these days as the moment Japan became musa no yo, the age of warriors. Kiyomori came out of it as governor of Harima, the richest provincial post open to him; Yoshitomo came out with less, and a grievance.

Heiji, 1159: the pilgrim who came back

The real power after Hōgen was Shinzei, a scholar-monk and Go-Shirakawa’s closest adviser, and he leaned on the Taira. His rival Fujiwara no Nobuyori found his muscle in the resentful Yoshitomo, and they waited for Kiyomori to leave town. In the twelfth month of 1159 Kiyomori set off on pilgrimage to Kumano, deep in the Kii mountains, and late on the 9th day of that month Nobuyori and Yoshitomo attacked the Sanjō palace, seized Go-Shirakawa and burned the buildings. Shinzei fled and was hunted down.

The burning of the Sanjo palace in 1159, from the 13th-century Heiji Monogatari picture scroll
The night attack on the Sanjō palace, from the Heiji picture scroll painted about a century later. This scroll left Japan in the Meiji era and is in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, so the most famous fire in Japanese painting needs a plane ticket.

The date causes a small muddle. The attack fell in the first year of Heiji, which Japanese accounts give as 1159, but that day fell in January 1160 by the Western calendar, so English-language books often call it the Heiji rebellion of 1160. Same night.

Kiyomori heard the news in Kii and is said to have thought of running for Kyushu. Local men, the warrior Yuasa Muneshige and the Kumano superintendent Tankai, lent him troops and talked him into going back. He reached the capital on the 17th day, sent Nobuyori polite assurances, and let the conspirators fall out.

In the small hours of the 26th day the young emperor Nijō slipped out of the palace, in women’s clothes according to both the war tale and Jien, and made for Kiyomori’s mansion at Rokuhara. Once the emperor was under his roof, Kiyomori was the government and the men in the palace were rebels.

Armed warriors and fleeing courtiers in the palace, from the Rokuhara scroll of the Heiji Monogatari Emaki
Armed men in the palace and courtiers running for it, from the Rokuhara scroll of the same tale, a National Treasure in the Tokyo National Museum. Look at the bows: in 1159 a warrior was first of all a mounted archer.

Kiyomori drew Yoshitomo’s men out of the palace, so that the fighting would not burn it, and beat them by the river. Yoshitomo fled east and was murdered in Owari by a retainer who wanted the reward. The historian Motoki Yasuo credits Kiyomori with an urban, coordinated style of fighting that did very little damage to the city; the war tales, which wanted dashing single combat, called him good at politics and bad at war.

Then came the decision all of Japanese history has second-guessed. Yoshitomo’s son Yoritomo, thirteen by the Japanese count, was captured early in 1160, and Kiyomori’s stepmother Ike no Zenni begged for his life; the war tale says he reminded her of her own dead son. Kiyomori exiled him to Izu. He also spared the three small sons of Yoshitomo’s concubine Tokiwa, the youngest of whom grew up to be Minamoto no Yoshitsune.

Painted votive plaque of Tokiwa Gozen with her children in the snow, Itsukushima Shrine Treasure Hall
Tokiwa Gozen fleeing through the snow with her sons, on a votive plaque in the treasure hall at Itsukushima, the Taira’s own shrine. Later tales claim she bought the boys’ lives by becoming Kiyomori’s mistress, the sort of story the storytellers loved and the record barely supports.

It was mercy, or prudence, or a favour to his stepmother, and it was the biggest mistake of his life. I have never been able to hold it against him. Nobody in 1160 could have known that the boy in Izu would become Minamoto no Yoritomo.

A warrior among the ministers

In 1160 Kiyomori became a councillor of state, the first man from a warrior house to sit among the kugyō, the score of nobles who deliberated on government. Over the next seven years he did what the villain story leaves out: he served both of the men who wanted to rule, the young emperor Nijō and his father Go-Shirakawa, who loathed each other. His wife Tokiko had been Nijō’s wet nurse, and her younger sister Shigeko was Go-Shirakawa’s favourite consort, so Kiyomori was family on both sides.

13th-century portrait of Retired Emperor Go-Shirakawa in priest's robes, Myoho-in, Kyoto
Go-Shirakawa in monk’s robes, a 13th-century portrait at Myōhō-in, the Kyoto temple that also owns Sanjūsangendō. He outlived Kiyomori and the whole Taira clan, and Yoritomo is supposed to have called him the greatest tengu in Japan. It was not a compliment.

The best gift of those years is still standing. In 1164 Kiyomori built Go-Shirakawa a temple hall on the eastern edge of the city, the Rengeō-in, about 120 metres long and filled with a thousand standing images of the thousand-armed Kannon. Everyone calls it Sanjūsangendō (三十三間堂), the hall of thirty-three bays.

Rows of Kannon statues inside the hall of Sanjusangendo (Rengeo-in), Kyoto, photographed about 1915
The ranks of Kannon inside Sanjūsangendō, photographed around 1915. Kiyomori’s hall burned in 1249 and the present one dates from 1266, but about 124 of the statues were carried out of the fire. Nobody can tell you which by looking.

In the second month of 1167 he was appointed daijō-daijin, chancellor of the realm, skipping the ministries of the left and right on the way. No warrior had held it before, and the nobility wrote about it in the tone you would use for a flood. He resigned after about three months, which was normal: the office was an honour to collect, not a desk to sit at. Meanwhile his eldest son Shigemori was given policing powers over most of the country, as plain a statement of the succession as the court allowed.

Kamakura-period portrait traditionally identified as Taira no Shigemori, Jingo-ji, Kyoto
The great portrait at Jingo-ji in Kyoto that tradition calls Taira no Shigemori, the dutiful son the Heike Monogatari sets against his father. Since the 1990s some art historians have argued that it shows Ashikaga Takauji, founder of the Muromachi shogunate, in which case the gentlest Taira in literature has been wearing a usurper’s face.

Early in 1168 Kiyomori fell seriously ill. The courtier Kujō Kanezane recorded the complaint as sunbaku, a word for assorted intestinal miseries; Kiyomori’s own diagnosis, which I cherish, was a tapeworm. Thinking he was dying, he shaved his head and became a lay monk named Jōkai. Sources variously place the tonsure in the second month, when the diaries have him sick, or on the 11th day of the eleventh month, the Heike Monogatari‘s date and the tradition at Nofuku-ji in Kobe.

The shaved head changed nothing; it freed him from ceremony while he kept his grip on everything else. The clan’s prosperity produced the most quoted line in the Heike Monogatari, and it was his brother-in-law Taira no Tokitada, not Kiyomori, who supposedly said that anyone not of this clan was not a person at all. By the 1170s the Taira held, on the Heike‘s count, more than thirty of the sixty-six provinces, and Kiyomori’s daughter Tokuko had married the emperor Takakura, in 1171 by most accounts (some reference works say 1172).

Emperor Takakura in court dress, from the portrait scroll Tenshi Sekkan Miei
Emperor Takakura, Kiyomori’s son-in-law, from the same 14th-century scroll. He was Go-Shirakawa’s son by Kiyomori’s sister-in-law, so the Taira had him from both sides. He died early in 1181, less than two months before his father-in-law.

Song ships at Ōwada

The other Kiyomori, the one I like best, lived by the sea. In 1162 he acquired an estate on the coast where Kobe now stands, and with it control of the anchorage of Ōwada no tomari (大輪田泊), sheltered from the west by the sandspit now called Wadamisaki but open to the south-east, where storms kept wrecking the ships inside. His answer was an artificial island. Work began in the second month of 1162, was washed away by a storm in the eighth, and restarted the next year, all paid for with Taira money.

The island was called Kyōgashima (経が島), the sutra island, after a legend: the engineers wanted to bury a living person in the foundations to appease the sea, and Kiyomori had stones inscribed with sutras sunk instead. Kobe has embroidered it since, with a seventeen-year-old page called Matsuō-maru who volunteered to take the victims’ place. Sources variously date the island’s completion from 1173 to 1175, and no one knows exactly where it lay.

Sketch map of the old port town of Hyogo-tsu in Kobe, site of the medieval Owada anchorage
The old port town of Hyōgo, the medieval successor to Ōwada, from the city’s own history. Kiyomori’s harbour lies somewhere under these streets and the reclaimed land beyond; the modern port grew up a few kilometres east. Map: Kobe City, CC BY 4.0.

He built a villa in the hills above, at Fukuhara, in what is now the Hirano district of Hyōgo-ku, and after 1168 he lived there more than in the capital. It is a little bowl open to the south, sheltered from the winter wind and looking straight down on the harbour. Part of it was called the Yukimi Gosho, the snow-viewing palace, which tells you he was not roughing it.

Stone marker for the site of Taira no Kiyomori's Yukimi Gosho villa in Hirano, Hyogo-ku, Kobe
The Yukimi Gosho stone, put up after foundation stones and pottery turned up in the playground of Minatoyama elementary school in 1908. The school closed in 2015 and the building now houses a small aquarium and a brewery, a reuse I suspect Kiyomori would have approved of. Photo: Nnn at Japanese Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 3.0.

The point was China. Japan had stopped sending embassies to the Chinese court in 894, but Southern Song merchant junks still came to Hakata in Kyushu. Kiyomori wanted them to come all the way up the Inland Sea to his own harbour, a short ride from the capital, and in 1170 one did.

In the ninth month of 1170 he brought Go-Shirakawa to Fukuhara to meet a Song visitor in person. Kanezane wrote that nothing like it had happened since the reign of Daigo in the early tenth century and that it must be the work of a heavenly demon. In 1172 the prefect of Mingzhou, the port now called Ningbo, sent letters and gifts to Go-Shirakawa and Kiyomori; the nobles wanted them refused, and Kiyomori answered anyway.

Sixteen Chinese copper coins of the Southern Song dynasty, the kind imported into Japan
Southern Song copper coins. Japan had stopped minting its own money in the tenth century, and the Taira trade brought these in by the shipload. When an epidemic swept the capital in 1179, people blamed the coins and called it the money sickness. Photo: As6022014, CC BY 3.0.

Japan sent gold, sulphur, swords, lacquer and fans, and got back silk, ceramics, incense, medicines, books and copper coins. In 1179 Kiyomori bought a printed copy of the vast Song encyclopedia Taiping Yulan, had it copied for himself and gave the printed original to Takakura, which says something about the man the war tales refuse to describe. Four centuries before the Portuguese reached Nagasaki, and long before the Dutch were penned up on Dejima, a Japanese ruler was pulling foreign trade towards the capital on purpose.

The sea route west has its own legend. At Ondo no Seto, the narrow channel between the mainland and Kurahashi Island near Kure, Kiyomori is said to have cut a passage for ships bound for Itsukushima. When the sun began to set before the work was done, he climbed a rock, unfolded a golden fan and ordered it back, and it came; the job was finished, the story says, on the 10th day of the seventh month of 1165.

Tsukioka Yoshitoshi print of Taira no Kiyomori waving a fan to call back the setting sun
Yoshitoshi’s Kiyomori calls back the sun, from the Yoshitoshi Musha Burui series of the 1880s. In folklore this was where his luck turned: a man who orders the sun about has gone too far, and the fever of 1181 was the bill.

No record from his lifetime mentions it, and when the poet-general Imagawa Sadayo sailed through in 1389 he described the strait without a word about Kiyomori. The memorial pagoda at Ondo that bears his name is a Muromachi-period stone. The Taira probably did improve the passage, since the estates on both banks belonged to Kiyomori’s brother Yorimori, but I would not bet on the fan.

Aerial photograph of the Ondo no Seto strait and its bridges between Honshu and Kurahashi Island, Kure
Ondo no Seto from the air, with its two road bridges. The channel is about 90 metres wide at the narrowest point and the tide runs hard through it; the bridges are built high because ships still use it. Photo: Geospatial Information Authority of Japan, Attribution.

A shrine in the sea

Itsukushima, the island everyone now calls Miyajima, was sacred long before the Taira; the whole island was treated as divine, and births and burials were kept off it. Kiyomori’s devotion began when he governed Aki, and it was sincere and good business at once, since the shrine’s three sea goddesses protected the route his fortune depended on. Around 1168 the priest Saeki Kagehiro, with Taira money behind him, rebuilt the shrine on the scale you see today: halls joined by long roofed corridors, built on piles over the tidal flat so that at high tide the whole thing floats.

Vermilion corridors and halls of Itsukushima Shrine above the tidal flat, Miyajima
The corridors at low tide, when you can see the whole thing stands on legs. The floorboards are laid with gaps so that storm surges push up through the floor instead of lifting it off. Photo: Jakub Hałun, CC BY 4.0.

None of the buildings you walk through is Kiyomori’s. The shrine burned in 1207 and 1223 and the main halls were rebuilt around 1241; the inner sanctuary was rebuilt again in 1571 because blood had polluted it when two rebel brothers were killed inside during Mōri Motonari’s wars. Architectural historians generally agree that the rebuilders kept the late-Heian plan, so what you see is a medieval copy of Kiyomori’s shrine. I think of it as the best-preserved Taira building that is not actually a Taira building.

The great gate in the sea is younger still. The present torii, by the usual count the eighth since Kiyomori, went up in 1875 and stands 16.6 metres high without being fixed to the seabed. Its crossbeam is packed with about seven tonnes of fist-sized stones, and the whole gate, some 60 tonnes, stays up under its own weight.

The great torii of Itsukushima Shrine standing on the sand at low tide, Miyajima
The torii on dry sand at low tide, about 200 metres out from the shrine. Check the tide tables and you can have it both ways in one day: walk out to the pillars in the afternoon, and come back after dark to see it standing in the water. Photo: DXR, CC BY-SA 4.0.

His finest gift to the shrine is not a building. In the ninth month of 1164 he dedicated the first part of a set of sutras copied out by his family, completed by 1167 and now called the Heike Nōkyō (平家納経). There are thirty-three scrolls: the Lotus Sutra in thirty, the Amida and Heart sutras, and a dedication in Kiyomori’s own hand, in which he wrote that they had exhausted goodness and exhausted beauty. For once a donor was not exaggerating.

Decorated frontispiece of one scroll of the Heike Nokyo sutras, dedicated at Itsukushima Shrine in 1164
A frontispiece from the Heike Nōkyō, on paper scattered with gold and silver leaf. Thirty-two members of the clan, Kiyomori, Shigemori and Yorimori among them, each took responsibility for a scroll, and art historians treat the set as the high point of decorated sutras in Japan.
Frontispiece of the Devadatta chapter of the Heike Nokyo, a palace in clouds above the sea
The frontispiece of the Devadatta chapter, in which the dragon king’s daughter attains enlightenment. A palace floats in clouds above a gold-flecked sea: an odd picture to give a sea shrine, and an apt one.

The scrolls outlived their donors comfortably. In 1602 Fukushima Masanori, the new lord of Hiroshima, paid for repairs, and three frontispieces were repainted in a manner experts attribute to the young Tawaraya Sōtatsu. In the 1920s the restorer Tanaka Shinbi spent five and a half years making replicas; he was working with the originals in Tokyo when the Great Kantō Earthquake struck in 1923, and is said to have clutched them to his chest until the shaking stopped. His copies are what the treasure hall shows today, and the originals, a National Treasure since 1954, come out only for special exhibitions.

Opening of Taira no Kiyomori's dedication scroll in the Heike Nokyo, with a deer on the frontispiece
The opening of Kiyomori’s dedication, from a 1933 reproduction. The deer on the frontispiece is a nice touch: Miyajima’s deer were already the goddesses’ messengers, and they still wander the shrine precinct, eating maps.

The shrine’s great festival, the Kangensai, a night procession of boats with court musicians aboard, is said to have been started by Kiyomori to bring the music of the capital to his goddesses. In the third month of 1180 he went further and had the newly retired Takakura make his first pilgrimage to Itsukushima instead of to one of the great shrines near the capital. The court was appalled.

Utagawa Hiroshige print of the Itsukushima torii during the Kangensai boat festival, 1853
Hiroshige’s Miyajima, 1853, from his views of the sixty-odd provinces: the torii cropped hard on the left, the musicians’ boat lit with lanterns beneath it. Seven centuries on, Kiyomori’s festival was what the print-buying public of Edo wanted to see.

From Shishigatani to Fukuhara, 1177 to 1180

The alliance with Go-Shirakawa held as long as Shigeko lived, and she died in 1176. In the sixth month of 1177 one of Go-Shirakawa’s men reported a plot against the Taira, hatched at a villa at Shishigatani in the eastern hills. Kiyomori had the monk Saikō executed and the priest Shunkan exiled to the remote island of Kikai-ga-shima, but left Go-Shirakawa alone. Some historians doubt there was a plot at all.

The break came in 1179, over property. In the sixth month Kiyomori’s daughter Moriko died and Go-Shirakawa took over the regent’s estates she had managed; in the seventh Shigemori died at forty-two and Go-Shirakawa took back his province. Then the retired emperor promoted a boy of eight over Kiyomori’s son-in-law, signalling that the regency would pass to a family hostile to the Taira.

On the 14th day of the eleventh month of 1179 Kiyomori came up from Fukuhara with an army and dismissed thirty-nine nobles and officials, the regent among them. On the 20th day he had Go-Shirakawa confined at the Toba palace south of the city. Historians usually date the first warrior government to this coup rather than to the chancellorship.

Painted portrait of the child Emperor Antoku, grandson of Taira no Kiyomori
Emperor Antoku, Kiyomori’s grandson, in a portrait painted about four centuries after his death. He was enthroned before he was two and drowned at six in his grandmother’s arms, taking the sword of the three sacred treasures down with him.

In the second month of 1180 Takakura abdicated in favour of his infant son by Tokuko, the emperor Antoku. Kiyomori was now the emperor’s grandfather, exactly what the Fujiwara regents had been at their height, but he had locked up the head of the imperial house to get there. In the fourth month Go-Shirakawa’s son Prince Mochihito called for a rising against the Taira, joined by the veteran Minamoto no Yorimasa. They were caught at the Byōdō-in at Uji on the 26th day of the fifth month; Mochihito was killed, and Yorimasa’s death in the temple garden is often cited as the first famous case of seppuku.

Portrait of Prince Mochihito, son of Go-Shirakawa, who called the Minamoto to arms in 1180
Prince Mochihito, from a reproduction published in 1932. His revolt lasted a month and killed him, but his call to arms kept travelling after he was dead, and it reached a man in exile in Izu.

Kiyomori’s answer was to leave. On the 2nd day of the sixth month of 1180 he took the child emperor and both retired emperors to Fukuhara and announced that the capital would be there. Kanezane, who had heard of the plan a day or two before, called it the work of a tengu; when he asked whether he should follow, Kiyomori replied that there was nowhere to put him yet.

There was nowhere to put anyone. A grid city was planned at Wada beside the harbour, but the strip of flat land was too narrow, and alternative sites inland and further west were proposed and dropped. The court did not want to be there, the temples did not, and most of the Taira did not either; Kiyomori’s son Munemori, remembered as limp and obedient, is said to have argued with his father furiously.

The idea was not mad. A capital by the sea, near a trading port and away from the armed monasteries that had bullied Kyoto for two centuries, is not far from what the Tokugawa built at Edo four centuries later, and some Japanese historians have wondered whether Fukuhara might have become a Taira shogunate on the coast. It was not given time.

In the eighth month Yoritomo rose in Izu, and in the ninth his cousin Kiso Yoshinaka, whose army would later include Tomoe Gozen, rose in Shinano. On the 20th day of the tenth month a Taira army faced Yoritomo across the Fuji River and fell back without a fight; the war tales say a flock of waterbirds took off in the night and the Taira thought it was an attack. The Genpei War had begun, and on the 23rd day of the eleventh month the court went back to Kyoto, leaving Fukuhara’s half-built palaces empty.

On the 28th day of the twelfth month of 1180 Kiyomori’s son Shigehira led an army against Kōfuku-ji in Nara, which had sided with Mochihito. The fires spread in a strong wind, Kōfuku-ji and Tōdai-ji both burned, and the Great Buddha’s hall collapsed onto the Buddha. Thousands of people who had taken refuge in the buildings died, and Kiyomori became, for everyone who later told his story, an enemy of the Buddha.

The Great Buddha Hall of Todai-ji in Nara, rebuilt after the fires of 1180 and 1567
Tōdai-ji’s Great Buddha Hall today, the third on the site, finished in 1709 after a second burning in 1567. The hall the Taira burned was rebuilt with Yoritomo’s backing and rededicated in 1195 with the shogun in attendance, a political statement as much as a religious one. Photo: 663highland, CC BY 2.5.

“Ata, ata”: the fever of 1181

Kiyomori spent the first weeks of 1181 doing what a competent general does when the country is coming apart: he put Munemori in command of the whole home region, levied troops and rice, and commissioned the lord of Mutsu, Fujiwara no Hidehira, against Yoritomo. On the 26th day of the second month the Taira commanders were ordered east. On the 27th Kiyomori fell ill.

Kanezane noted a head ailment, then that the lay monk was gravely ill, then much worse. Late on the 4th day of the intercalary second month of 1181 he died, sixty-four by the Japanese count. English reference works convert the date to 20 March 1181, and one Japanese reference work gives the 5th rather than the 4th day.

The poet Fujiwara no Teika heard the next day that the dying man had been in burning heat and agony. The chronicle Hyakurenshō says his body was as hot as fire, the reward for burning Tōdai-ji and Kōfuku-ji. The storytellers took that version and ran.

In the Heike Monogatari he cannot swallow a sip of water, anyone who comes near his bed has to back away from the heat, and all he can say is “ata, ata“, hot, hot. They lower him into a stone bath of cold spring water from Mount Hiei and the water boils; they pour water over him and it bursts into flame and black smoke before it touches his skin. One text ends with a line that loses most of its force in English: he writhed for seven days and died the death of heat.

What actually killed him has been argued over for nine hundred years by people who know they will never be proved wrong. The novelist Yoshikawa Eiji and the microbiologist Hayakawa Satoshi favour malaria; the novelist Kaionji Chōgorō read the head ailment as a brain haemorrhage; others have proposed pneumonia, meningitis and a streptococcal infection. Motoki Yasuo makes the best point: Kiyomori’s friend Fujiwara no Kunitsuna fell ill at the same time and died less than three weeks after him. It is not a judgement from heaven if your friend gets it too.

His last words come in two versions. In the diaries he sends word to Go-Shirakawa that the realm is to be left to Munemori, gets no reply, and repeats bitterly that there is to be no argument. In the Heike Monogatari he refuses a funeral and asks only that Yoritomo’s head be hung before his grave.

Even the place is disputed. The Kamakura shogunate’s chronicle, the Azuma Kagami, puts his death at his steward Morikuni’s house at Kujō on the Kamo riverbank; the historian Takahashi Masaaki has argued that Kujō is a slip for Hachijō, further north, across the river from Go-Shirakawa’s palace. That would explain the story I find hardest to forget: on the night of the funeral, says the Heike, the sound of singing, clapping and laughter came from the retired emperor’s palace. From Hachijō you could have heard it.

Four years later the clan was gone. Kiso Yoshinaka drove the Taira from the capital in 1183, and they burned their own houses at Rokuhara and Fukuhara as they left. Yoshitsune beat them at Ichi-no-tani and Yashima, and at Dan-no-ura, off Shimonoseki, the last of them went into the sea in the third month of 1185, Kiyomori’s widow Tokiko among them with Antoku in her arms. It was one of Japan’s most decisive battles, and the boy Kiyomori had spared founded the shogunate of the Kamakura era.

The villain the Heike needed

You have probably met the opening of the Heike Monogatari even if you did not know it: the bell of the Gion monastery tolls the impermanence of all things, and the proud do not endure. The book took shape in the early thirteenth century and travelled the country in the mouths of blind monks who chanted it to the lute. It is magnificent and deeply unfair, and the unfairness has a structure.

Manuscript page with the opening Gion Shoja lines of the Heike Monogatari
The opening lines of the Heike Monogatari in a manuscript at the National Diet Library. The Gion Shōja of the first line has nothing to do with Gion in Kyoto: it is the monastery in India where the Buddha preached.

The book needs the Taira to fall because they were proud, and it needs someone to embody the pride. The scholar Tomikura Tokujirō sorted Kiyomori’s offences into crimes against royal law, such as moving the capital and killing Prince Mochihito, and crimes against the Buddha, meaning Nara. The fever pays for the second list, and his widow dreams of a carriage of fire come to take him to the deepest hell.

The book also stocks his life with cruelties. He discards the dancer Giō for a younger rival, Hotoke Gozen, then summons her back to entertain her replacement. Skulls appear in his snowy garden at Fukuhara and roll together into one enormous skull with countless eyes. And in 1170, when the regent’s retinue insults his grandson’s carriage, he has the regent’s men waylaid and their topknots cut off.

Ink drawing by Teisai Hokuba of Taira no Kiyomori with the dancer Hotoke Gozen, about 1840
Kiyomori and Hotoke Gozen, an ink sketch by Teisai Hokuba from about 1840. In the story both women end up as nuns together in Saga, and it is Hotoke Gozen who leaves him. Edo artists never tired of the old monk in love.

Here is the problem. Jien’s Gukanshō, a far more sober history by Kanezane’s own brother, says it was Shigemori, the good son, who ordered the revenge on the regent’s men, and most historians now follow Jien. The Heike moved the outrage from son to father because it needed a saint and a sinner, and once you notice it doing that, you notice it everywhere.

Tsukioka Yoshitoshi triptych of Taira no Kiyomori seeing skulls in his snow-covered garden, 1882
Yoshitoshi’s 1882 triptych of the skulls in the snowy garden. What the prints leave out is the end of the episode: Kiyomori stared the giant skull down until it melted away like frost, which is not what a coward does.

A different Kiyomori turns up in the corners. A thirteenth-century book of moral tales, the Jikkinshō, remembers a young man who laughed off other people’s blunders, never shouted at a servant, and on cold nights let the boys who attended him sleep on the hem of his robe, slipping out in the morning so as not to wake them. Jien’s own verdict is the fairest I know: around the time of Heiji he was considerate to everyone and knew how to survive the cloistered court, and only when he had great power to defend did he turn to force.

The war tale Genpei Jōsuiki explains his rise with a fox. Out hunting, he aimed at a fox that turned into a woman and offered him anything for her life; she was Dakiniten, the fox-riding deity whose best-known home in Japan is Toyokawa Inari. He spared her and became her devotee, knowing that the fortune her rites bring does not pass to one’s descendants, which neatly explains why the clan’s luck ran out so fast.

Confucian-minded historians later put him among Japan’s three great villains, with the monk Dōkyō and Ashikaga Takauji, and the Edo print-makers turned the fever and the skulls into stock subjects. Warriors saw him differently: Oda Nobunaga styled himself a Taira, Tokugawa Ieyasu made sure he was a Minamoto before he became shogun, and a popular theory held that the two clans took turns ruling Japan.

The modern rehabilitation began with Yoshikawa Eiji’s novel Shin Heike Monogatari, serialised from 1950, and Mizoguchi Kenji’s 1955 film of its early chapters, which made the young Kiyomori a hero facing down the warrior monks. NHK gave him its 2012 historical drama, shot in a deliberately grimy style, and the governor of Hyōgo complained in public that it made Kiyomori look dirty. I suspect Kiyomori would have taken that as a compliment to the realism.

The case for him is simple. He was the first warrior to govern Japan, a generation before Yoritomo; he saw that the country’s wealth lay on the sea and in China; and his clan’s sutras are among the most beautiful things the Heian court ever made. He was also ruthless and nepotistic, which puts him in the company of most of the men on any list of Japan’s greatest samurai. The difference is that his enemies wrote the book.

Where to find Kiyomori today

Kiyomori’s Japan falls into three clusters along the Sanyō Shinkansen: Miyajima near Hiroshima, Hyōgo-ku in Kobe, and Rokuhara and Higashiyama in Kyoto. If you can only do one, do Miyajima, and do it at low tide.

Itsukushima Shrine, Miyajima

From Hiroshima Station take the JR Sanyō Line to Miyajimaguchi, about half an hour, and walk five minutes to the pier. JR West and Matsudai ferries cross in about ten minutes for ¥200 each way, plus the island’s ¥100 visitor tax on the outward trip, introduced in 2023. The JR ferry is covered by the Japan Rail Pass, and on many sailings it swings close to the torii.

Itsukushima Shrine and its stone lanterns on the dry shore at low tide, photographed in 1935
The shrine on the dry shore at low tide in 1935, photographed by a visiting Danish engineer. The lanterns, the pagoda on the hill and the long low roofs are all still there. The crowds are new.

The shrine is ten minutes’ walk from the island pier. It opens at 6:30 and closes at 18:00 from March to mid-October, at 17:30 from mid-October to the end of November and from early January to February, and at 17:00 in December. Admission is ¥300; the treasure hall (8:00–17:00) is another ¥300, or ¥500 for both on a combined ticket sold at the shrine entrance.

Do not skip the treasure hall, a 1934 concrete building lacquered to look like timber, the first in Japan to try the trick. Inside are Tanaka Shinbi’s Heike Nōkyō replicas and the painted votive plaques; the shrine also owns three National Treasure suits of the great armour the Taira wore, the kind described in my piece on samurai armour, and ceremonial tachi, the slung swords of the age before the katana, and what is on show rotates. Go early or late: by mid-morning the corridors are a slow queue, and the floorboard gaps catch heels.

Behind the shrine, the Senjōkaku, the great unfinished hall Toyotomi Hideyoshi began in 1587, costs ¥100 (8:30–16:30). Walk west along the shore past Daigan-ji to Nishi-matsubara and you reach Kiyomori Shrine (清盛神社), founded in 1954 to honour him. Almost nobody goes, which is a shame, because it is the one place on the island where the man and not the goddesses gets the thanks.

Kiyomori Shrine on Miyajima, founded in 1954 to honour Taira no Kiyomori
Kiyomori Shrine on the western shore, a short walk beyond the main shrine. The deer, for the record, treat him with no more respect than they treat you. Photo: Soramimi (そらみみ), CC BY-SA 4.0.

The Kangensai falls on the 17th day of the sixth lunar month, in July or early August; check the shrine’s site for the year’s date. With time to spare in Hiroshima, Ondo no Seto is a bus ride south of Kure. Go for the tide racing through the channel, not for Kiyomori.

Kobe: Nofuku-ji, Kiyomorizuka and Fukuhara

Kobe’s Kiyomori is in Hyōgo-ku, the old port district west of the centre, and it is not pretty, but it is real. Start at Nofuku-ji (能福寺), a Tendai temple that the Taira made their family prayer temple in 1180. The temple says his remains were buried here by his own wish, and its Heishōkoku-byō memorial was rebuilt in 1980 for the 800th anniversary of his death.

The Heishokoku-byo memorial to Taira no Kiyomori with its stone pagoda at Nofuku-ji, Hyogo-ku, Kobe
The Heishōkoku-byō, the memorial of the Taira chancellor, at Nofuku-ji. The Azuma Kagami says his bones went to a chapel at Yamada in Harima instead, so the claim to the body is contested, but this is where Kobe holds his memorial service every year. Photo: Jnn, CC BY-SA 3.0.

The temple is fifteen minutes’ walk east of JR Hyōgo Station, or ten from exit 1 of Chūō-ichiba-mae on the Kaigan subway line. Its own site lists no admission charge for the grounds, and the temple office keeps 10:00–16:00. You will not miss it, because it also has the Hyōgo Daibutsu, a bronze Buddha 11 metres high, 18 with its pedestal.

The original bronze Hyogo Daibutsu at Nofuku-ji in Kobe, photographed about 1890 by Adolf de Meyer
The first Hyōgo Daibutsu, photographed by Adolf de Meyer when it was brand new; a local merchant paid for it in 1891. It went to the war effort in 1944, and the present one, cast in 1991, has fragments of the original melted into it.

Look too for the memorial to Takizen Saburō, the Bizen samurai made to perform seppuku in 1868 before foreign witnesses after his men fired on foreigners in Kobe. About eight minutes’ walk south of Chūō-ichiba-mae is Kiyomorizuka (清盛塚) in Kirido-chō, a thirteen-storey stone pagoda 8.5 metres high beside the Sumiyoshi shrine. Long thought to be his grave, it was moved about ten metres in 1923 to widen the road for the tramline; the survey found no burial, and its inscription dates it to 1286.

The thirteen-storey stone pagoda of Kiyomorizuka in Kirido-cho, Hyogo-ku, Kobe
Kiyomorizuka, with the traffic of Hyōgo-ku going past. Beside it stand a bronze statue of Kiyomori and a mound for his nephew Tsunemasa, the lute player of the Taira, who died at Ichi-no-tani. Photo: Pastern, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Fukuhara itself is up the hill in Hirano. The Yukimi Gosho stone stands at the old Minatoyama school, now the Nature Studio complex, about 17 minutes on foot from Minatogawa station. In November 2026 the city announced that a dig at Shimosanjō-chō, near the Hirano bus stop, had found a stone-lined road it identifies as a main street of Fukuhara-kyō, the first excavated feature tied clearly to Kiyomori’s capital. Nine centuries on, his six-month city is finally coming out of the ground.

Kyoto: Rokuhara, Sanjūsangendō and Giō-ji

The Taira headquarters in Kyoto was Rokuhara (六波羅), on the east bank of the Kamo between Gojō and Shichijō. Kiyomori’s grandfather built a chapel here, his father a mansion, and under Kiyomori it became a Taira quarter, which the clan burned themselves when they fled in 1183. Its heart is Rokuharamitsu-ji (六波羅蜜寺), founded in 951 by the wandering monk Kūya, open 8:30–16:30.

The main hall of Rokuharamitsu-ji in the Rokuhara district of Higashiyama, Kyoto
Rokuharamitsu-ji squeezed between the houses of Higashiyama. The Taira mansions stood all round it; the temple is the only thing in the neighbourhood that was here before them and is still here now.

Pay the ¥700 for the Reiwa-kan treasure building (9:00–16:15, last entry 16:00). Inside is a Kamakura-period seated statue of a monk reading a sutra, an Important Cultural Property the temple identifies as Kiyomori, and next to it Kōshō’s famous Kūya, with six tiny Amida Buddhas coming out of his mouth on a wire, one for each syllable of his prayer. A memorial to Kiyomori stands in the grounds. The temple is seven minutes from Kiyomizu-Gojō station on the Keihan line, or from the Kiyomizu-michi stop on city bus 206.

Fifteen minutes’ walk south is Sanjūsangendō, Kiyomori’s gift to Go-Shirakawa, open 8:30–17:00 from April to mid-November and 9:00–16:00 from mid-November to March, last entry half an hour before closing, ¥600. Across the road, Go-Shirakawa’s own tomb lies behind Hōjū-ji, a few minutes from the man who locked him up and paid for his favourite hall.

On a spare afternoon in the west of the city, find Giō-ji (祇王寺) in Sagano, the little nunnery where, in the Heike, the dancer Giō retired with her mother and sister. The thatched hall holds wooden images of the women and of Kiyomori himself, with a small memorial pagoda to him among their graves. The temple’s own site was offline when I checked; entry has long been ¥300, but confirm on the day.

The thatched hall of Gio-ji in Sagano, Kyoto, the nunnery of the dancer Gio
Giō-ji in Sagano, all moss and maples. Kiyomori shares a hall with the woman he discarded, which seems about the right punishment, and the mildest one the Heike ever hands out.

For the long view of how a court of poets became a country of warriors, my walk through Japan through the ages puts Kiyomori at the hinge between the Heian court and seven centuries of warrior rule. The ideals later called bushido were written down long after him, but the world they describe starts here.

Low tide

The Edo wit who stripped Kiyomori’s doctor was laughing at the storytellers’ version, and it is a good joke. The man in the diaries is harder to laugh at. He came back from a pilgrimage into a coup and won it without burning the city, spared children he probably should have killed, put an island into the sea with his own money and opened the country’s door a crack to China.

Go to Miyajima on a day when the tide is out in the afternoon. Walk across the wet sand to the great gate, put your hand on the camphor pillar, then turn and look at the shrine he paid for, standing on its legs above the flats and waiting for the water to come back. It always does. That was the Heike‘s point, and Kiyomori, I suspect, would have argued with it.

Scroll to Top