Ii Naosuke: The Tea Master Edo Called the Red Demon

Half the souvenir fans in Kyoto carry the four characters 一期一会, ichigo ichie, “one time, one meeting”, and the man who made them famous is the one much of Japan once called the Red Demon. Ii Naosuke put the phrase at the head of his tea manual, where it tells a host to treat each gathering as one that will never come again, and to act accordingly. He wrote it in a small house beside a castle moat, during fifteen years in which nobody expected anything of him at all.

Then he was handed the government of Japan. In the two years he held it he signed the treaty that opened the country’s ports, chose a twelve-year-old as shogun over the most admired young man in the realm, and sent a hundred people to prison, exile or the execution ground. On a snowy morning in the spring of 1860 a band of eighteen men cut his head off within sight of the shogun’s castle, and the regime spent the next two months pretending he was ill.

I can think of few stranger arcs in Japanese history: a tea master who became a hanging judge, and a villain who became, a generation later, a statue above Yokohama. All of it can still be traced on the ground, from the house where he waited in Hikone to the gate where he died and the temple where he lies, a short walk from thousands of beckoning cats.

Painted portrait of Ii Naosuke in court robes and black cap by Kano Eigaku
Naosuke as Kanō Eigaku painted him, dated 1860, the year of his death, with a waka in his own hand written above. The calm face is a convention of the genre. The record suggests a man who claimed to need four hours’ sleep a night and worried about almost everything.

The fourteenth son and the buried tree

Naosuke was born in the Keyaki Goten, the Ii family’s lakeside villa below Hikone Castle, on the 29th day of the 10th month of Bunka 12, which works out as 29 November 1815. English-language accounts often give the year as 1814; the Japanese biographies and reference works are unanimous on 1815. He was the fourteenth son of Ii Naonaka, who had already retired as lord of Hikone, and of a concubine called Otomi, the daughter of an Edo merchant.

The Ii family’s founder in the Tokugawa age was Ii Naomasa, one of the four great generals of Tokugawa Ieyasu, and they held the largest domain of any fudai (hereditary vassal) lord, 350,000 koku including lands held in trust. They also supplied more of the shogunate’s tairō (大老), great elders, than any other house; the post was filled only in emergencies and outranked the senior councillors. A fourteenth son of such a house had roughly the prospects of a spare tyre.

Stone post marking the birthplace of Ii Naosuke at the Keyaki Goten in Hikone
The marker for Naosuke’s birthplace at the Keyaki Goten, the villa now known as Rakuraku-en. His father was fifty and already retired when he was born, which may explain why the boy grew up indulged and was then, at seventeen, abruptly not.

The house rule was simple. A lord’s younger sons were adopted into other daimyo families, adopted into retainers’ families, or sent into the priesthood, and while they waited they lived on an allowance. His mother died when he was five. When his father died in 1831, Naosuke, then seventeen, left the castle for a modest residence on the middle moat with an allowance of 300 bales of rice a year, which is to say the income of a middling retainer.

He named the house the Umoregi-no-ya (埋木舎), the House of the Buried Tree. An umoregi is wood that has lain so long underground that it will never put out a flower, and Naosuke applied the image to himself without self-pity. In a short essay on the name he wrote that he neither turned his back on the world nor craved it: he would stay buried, like the tree, and do what a man ought to do.

Wooden gatehouse and white wall of the Umoregi-no-ya residence beside Hikone Castle's middle moat
The gate of the Umoregi-no-ya on the middle moat, a few minutes’ walk from the castle’s Sawaguchi entrance. Naosuke’s grandfather had lived here too before he inherited the domain at twenty-five, a precedent nobody in 1831 would have thought worth mentioning.

What he ought to do turned out to be nearly everything. He studied Sōtō Zen with enough seriousness to be called “a famous monk with hair”. He trained in spear, archery, gunnery and horsemanship, and in iai, the art of drawing the sword, he went far enough to found his own school, the Shinshin-shinryū. He wrote waka, painted, carved noh masks, and wrote kyōgen comedies; two of them, Oni ga Yado and Susugi-gawa, are still performed.

Above all he practised tea. He trained in the Sekishū school, the warrior-class tradition descended from Katagiri Sekishū, took the tea name Sōkan, and eventually set up his own branch within it. People in Hikone called him Chakapon: cha for tea, ka for poems and pon for the sound of the hand-drum. It was not entirely a compliment.

Two attempts to get him out of the house failed. In 1834 he went to Edo as a candidate for adoption and came home unchosen, while a younger brother was taken; in 1843 a Nagahama temple asked for him as its heir priest, and the domain said no.

In 1842 a stranger arrived. Nagano Yoshitoki, better known as Nagano Shuzen, was a scholar of kokugaku (国学), the “national learning” that looked for Japan’s true character in its oldest poetry and chronicles, and nobody has ever established where he came from or what he did before the age of twenty-five. He called on Naosuke one evening and left at dawn, and did the same the next night and the night after. Naosuke became his pupil, and later his patron, and the partnership would end with Nagano’s head on the block.

Portrait of the kokugaku scholar Nagano Shuzen (Nagano Yoshitoki) seated in formal dress
Nagano Shuzen, the scholar who talked with Naosuke for three nights in 1842 and stayed in his life for eighteen years. The historian Yoshida Tsunekichi noticed that every place he lived before Hikone had some connection with the Kii Tokugawa, and left the thought hanging.

In these years Naosuke also met Murayama Taka, a former Gion geisha from Taga, a few kilometres from Hikone, six years older than he was and the mother of a small son. They were lovers until his position made it impossible. A letter he wrote to her in his late twenties, grieving that the domain would not let him see her, turned up in a Kyoto collection as recently as 2011.

Rough stone carved with the name of Murayama Taka in the grounds of Tenneiji, Hikone
Murayama Taka’s memorial stone at Tenneiji in Hikone. She became Nagano’s lover and the shogunate’s eyes in Kyoto during the purge, and in 1862 loyalists tied her up and exposed her alive on the riverbank at Sanjō. She died a nun in 1876, which is more than most people in this story managed.

The tea manual

The book is the Chanoyu Ichie-shū (茶湯一会集), begun when Naosuke was about thirty-one and revised for fifteen years until a fair copy was finished around 1858. The idea is older; Sen no Rikyū’s pupil Yamanoue Sōji had told hosts to treat a gathering as if it came once in a lifetime, and the phrase itself, or something very close to it, is sometimes traced to his record. But the four-character form most people quote today is the one at the top of Naosuke’s text, and it appears only in his final copy, not in the drafts.

The manual ends with an idea he called dokuza kannen (独座観念), sitting alone in contemplation. When the guests have gone, the host should not rush to tidy up. He should go back into the tea room, sit alone before the kettle, and think about the people who have just left and the fact that this meeting will not be repeated.

If you know the tea ceremony mainly as etiquette, this is worth sitting with. Naosuke was writing against the parlour tea of his own day and trying to get back to the seriousness of Rikyū, and it reads like the work of a man who has had a great deal of time alone.

Heir after all

Of Naosuke’s thirteen elder brothers, some died young and the rest were adopted out, and in 1846 the heir, his brother Naomoto, died without a son. The lord, Naoaki, adopted Naosuke as his successor, and at thirty the buried tree was dug up and sent to Edo.

The two did not like each other. In 1847, when Naosuke needed court robes for a shogunal memorial service, Naoaki refused him new ones and then forbade him to borrow his dead brother’s, and Naosuke stayed home with a diplomatic fever.

When Naoaki died in 1850, Naosuke became lord of Hikone at thirty-six by Japanese reckoning. Counting conventions differ: some lists make him the thirteenth head of the house, others the fifteenth or sixteenth lord of the domain, depending on how you count a lord who served twice. He sacked his brother’s chief councillor, filled the offices with his own people, many of them Nagano’s pupils, and handed out 150,000 ryō to retainers and townspeople in his late brother’s name.

He also toured his villages, nine times in six years, covering almost the whole domain. When he first came home as lord in 1851 he wrote a poem ashamed that his people were turning out to welcome him before he had done anything to deserve it. One man who admired that poem enough to copy it into a letter to his brother was a young scholar from Chōshū called Yoshida Shōin. Remember the name.

Great elder: the succession and the treaty

In the summer of 1853 Commodore Perry’s Black Ships anchored off Uraga, and the senior councillor Abe Masahiro did something unheard of: he asked the daimyo what to do. Naosuke’s first answer argued for keeping the country closed. His second, less than three weeks later, argued that the old policy was reckless and that Japan should trade, build ships and send them abroad.

That memorandum is the basis of his reputation as the man who opened Japan, but it also says that once Japan had a navy it could return to seclusion when the time was right. The historian Ishii Takashi argued that Naosuke was a seclusionist all along and that his “opening” was a tactic. I think that is half right: he wanted the country safe and the shogunate in charge, and would sign whatever achieved both.

His real enemy was Tokugawa Nariaki, the former lord of Mito, a shogunal relative and loud advocate of expelling the foreigners, whom Abe had made his adviser on coastal defence. To Naosuke, senior among the hereditary vassals who sat in the Tamari-no-ma chamber of Edo Castle, this was intolerable: the shogun’s business belonged to the shogun’s vassals, not to relatives with opinions.

Portrait of Tokugawa Nariaki, former lord of Mito, in formal dress
Tokugawa Nariaki, former lord of Mito. Nariaki loved beef, and the Ii had for years sent him Ōmi beef pickled in miso as a gift. Naosuke stopped the deliveries when he became lord, and Edo wits later claimed the whole feud started there.

Two questions ran together. The first was a treaty. Townsend Harris, the American consul at Shimoda, had been pressing since 1856 for a commercial treaty, and in late 1857 he was received by the shogun and gave his officials a two-hour lecture on free trade and the fate of China. The shogunate’s negotiators, Inoue Kiyonao and Iwase Tadanari, agreed a text with him in early 1858.

Photograph of the American consul general Townsend Harris in a dark coat
Townsend Harris, a New York china merchant who had helped found a free college before he ever saw Japan. He spent his first year at Shimoda largely ignored and without news from Washington, which goes some way to explaining his tone in 1858.

The second was the succession. The shogun, Iesada, was sickly and childless, and two candidates were put forward. The Hitotsubashi party, led by Nariaki and backed by Matsudaira Shungaku of Fukui and Shimazu Nariakira of Satsuma, wanted Nariaki’s own son, the twenty-one-year-old Hitotsubashi Yoshinobu, famous for his ability. The Nanki party of hereditary vassals, with Naosuke at its head, wanted Iesada’s cousin, the twelve-year-old lord of Kii, Tokugawa Yoshitomi, on the principle that blood came first.

To get the treaty past the court, the chief councillor Hotta Masayoshi went to Kyoto in person. Emperor Kōmei, who had never met a foreigner and did not intend to, refused his sanction, and Hotta came back in the spring of 1858 with nothing. When he proposed Matsudaira Shungaku as great elder, Iesada is reported to have answered that by family standing and by character, the only possible great elder was Kamon-no-kami, which was Naosuke’s court title.

Handwritten draft of the oath Ii Naosuke wrote on becoming great elder in 1858
Naosuke’s own copy of the oath he wrote on taking office as great elder, dated the 23rd day of the 4th month of 1858. One shogunal clerk recalled that he started laying out his views on coastal defence before the tatami had time to warm, and that everyone in the room was startled.

Within two months of taking office he had to make the decision his name has been attached to ever since, and the record of how he made it is more interesting than the legend.

The signature that was not his

Naosuke did not want to sign without the emperor’s consent. In the middle of the 6th month word came that the Arrow War in China had paused, and Harris sailed up to Kanagawa to warn that a British and French fleet, flushed with victory, would soon arrive to demand far worse terms; the only defence was to sign with America first. At the council on the 18th day of the 6th month, only Naosuke and one junior councillor argued for waiting.

Inoue and Iwase, who wanted to sign immediately, were sent to ask Harris for a delay, and before they left they asked Naosuke what to do if he refused. He told them that if it could not be avoided, it could not be helped, but that they were to put it off as long as possible. The two negotiators heard only the first half. They went aboard the USS Powhatan the next day, 29 July 1858, and signed.

Bound Japanese text of the 1858 Treaty of Amity and Commerce between Japan and the United States
The Japanese text of the Treaty of Amity and Commerce. It opened Kanagawa, Nagasaki, Hakodate, Niigata and Hyōgo, gave Americans extraterritoriality and fixed the tariffs by treaty. The general import duty was 20 per cent, close to what European states charged each other; the crippling 5 per cent rates came with a revision forced on Japan in 1866. Photo: World Imaging, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Naosuke told his aides he would resign. His secretary Utsugi Kageyoshi talked him out of it, on the grounds that resigning would hand the government to the Hitotsubashi party. What he wrote instead, in the record kept by his office, is the sentence that defines him: that the conduct of the realm had been entrusted to the shogunate, that whoever governed had to act as circumstances demanded, and that for the grave crime of not waiting for imperial consent, he was resolved to bear the guilt alone.

I believe him. The decision was made by others in a hurry, on a phrase he probably regretted, and he took it as his own. That is worth remembering when you get to the next part, because the man who wrote that sentence is the same man who, within months, was signing death warrants for people who had said much less.

Within days he dismissed Hotta and Matsudaira Tadakata, the councillors closest to the negotiations. Treaties with the Netherlands, Russia, Britain and France followed within three months on almost identical terms. Together they ended the policy that a later age would call sakoku, and the trade they let in would rearrange Nagasaki, which lost its two centuries of monopoly, and create Yokohama almost from nothing.

The boy shogun

On the 24th day of the 6th month Nariaki, his son the lord of Mito, the lord of Owari and Matsudaira Shungaku forced their way into Edo Castle unbidden to denounce the treaty as a crime against the throne and demand Yoshinobu as heir. Shungaku had called at Naosuke’s mansion first and, when Naosuke tried to leave for the castle, grabbed his sleeve. Naosuke pulled free, went to the castle, bowed low to every accusation and conceded nothing.

The next day the shogunate announced that Yoshitomi was the heir. On the 5th day of the 7th month the four lords were ordered into retirement or confinement for their unscheduled visit, and on the 6th the shogun Iesada died. Yoshitomi took the name Iemochi and was proclaimed the fourteenth shogun at the end of the year.

Oil portrait of the young shogun Tokugawa Iemochi by Kawamura Kiyoo
Tokugawa Iemochi, painted after his death by Kawamura Kiyoo. Naosuke chose him because he was the closest in blood and, his critics said, because a twelve-year-old would do as he was told. Iemochi died at twenty in 1866, in Osaka Castle, in the middle of a war the shogunate was losing.

Yoshinobu himself, the losing candidate, judged Naosuke in old age as a man “short on talent and strategy, but decisive”. That seems fair, but Naosuke was not choosing between a strong shogun and a weak one. He was choosing between a shogunate run by its hereditary vassals and one run by a coalition of great lords and a court that had discovered it could say no.

The Ansei Purge

The court said no again in the 8th month of 1858. Emperor Kōmei, furious at the treaty, sent a secret edict to the domain of Mito with instructions to circulate it among the other lords, criticising the shogunate and calling on the daimyo to unite. It was the first time since the founding of the Tokugawa order that the court had bypassed the shogun to give orders to a domain directly.

To Naosuke this was not a policy dispute. It was a conspiracy, organised by Mito and its friends, to use the emperor’s name to overthrow the government, and he set out to destroy it.

In Satsuma the Hitotsubashi party’s strongest lord, Shimazu Nariakira, had already been planning to march to Kyoto with his troops (sources give either 2,500 or 5,000 men), but he died suddenly in the summer of 1858. His agent in Kyoto, a big young samurai called Saigō Takamori, fled home with the wanted monk Gesshō, and in Kagoshima Bay the two threw themselves into the sea together. Saigō survived; Gesshō did not.

Naosuke sent the councillor Manabe Akikatsu to Kyoto, with Nagano Shuzen already there briefing him, and the arrests began. The first was Umeda Unpin, a rōnin scholar Nagano had identified as the organiser of the secret edict. Then came retainers of the court nobles, Mito officials, and the scholars and activists the Japanese call shishi, men of high purpose, followed by their friends, their servants and in some cases their families.

The scope is what still shocks. Over the next year more than a hundred people were punished: an imperial prince, a former regent and several ministers at court, the lords of Mito, Owari, Fukui, Tosa and Uwajima, shogunal officials, rōnin, a Kyoto doctor whose daughter would later marry Sakamoto Ryōma, a village headman, a Kyoto painter, the wife and daughters of a man who had died before he could be arrested. Murayama Taka sent reports from Kyoto, and her son, Tada Tatewaki, helped with the arrests.

Silk portrait of Yoshida Shoin seated in plain robes
Yoshida Shōin, the Chōshū teacher who had praised Naosuke as a model lord, and who was executed on his orders at twenty-nine. His pupils included Takasugi Shinsaku, Itō Hirobumi and Yamagata Aritomo. Few policies have recruited their own gravediggers quite so efficiently.

Who it killed

The sentences were handed down in three batches in the 8th and 10th months of 1859. Ajima Tatewaki, a senior councillor of Mito, was ordered to commit seppuku. Ukai Kichizaemon, Mito’s agent in Kyoto, was beheaded; his son Kōkichi was beheaded and his head displayed. Kayane Iyonosuke of Mito, the scholar Iizumi Kinai, the Kyoto Confucianist Rai Mikisaburō, Hashimoto Sanai of Fukui and Yoshida Shōin of Chōshū were all beheaded.

Sources variously count seven or eight executions, depending on whether they include Ajima’s enforced suicide, and at least half a dozen more prisoners died in custody, Umeda Unpin among them. Others were sent to distant islands, banished, or confined to their houses for life. Nariaki was sentenced to permanent house arrest in Mito, and Yoshinobu was ordered to retire and stay indoors.

Portrait of the Fukui scholar Hashimoto Sanai by Sasaki Nagaatsu
Hashimoto Sanai, the brilliant young adviser to Matsudaira Shungaku, painted by his friend Sasaki Nagaatsu. He was twenty-five. In 2009 a descendant of the Ii family travelled to Fukui to attend a memorial for him, a reconciliation that took 150 years.

The case of Hashimoto is the one that hangs on Naosuke personally. According to Shungaku’s memoirs, the shogunate’s judicial council recommended exile or confinement for him and the others, and sent its findings to the great elder; a few days later the papers came back with a slip attached that said “death”. There is no proof that Naosuke wrote the slip. There is no other plausible candidate either.

He did not spare his own side. Iwase Tadanari, who had signed the treaty, and the veteran diplomat Kawaji Toshiakira were dismissed for backing Yoshinobu, councillors who argued for leniency were removed, and in the end even Manabe, who had done the dirty work in Kyoto, was sacked after a quarrel.

Old wooden shelter that once covered Hashimoto Sanai's grave at Eko-in, Minami-Senju
The old wooden shelter that once covered Hashimoto Sanai’s grave at Ekō-in in Minami-Senju, the temple beside the Kotsukappara execution ground. Shōin and Rai Mikisaburō were buried here too, and in the spring of 1860 so were five of the men who died after killing Naosuke. Edo was not a large city for grudges.

It was in these months that people began calling him Ii no Akaoni, the Red Demon of Ii, the red presumably borrowed from the family’s famous lacquered armour. It is the purge, not the treaty, that I hold against him. The treaty was a hard call under foreign guns, and he took responsibility for a decision he had tried to delay. The purge was a choice, made at leisure, and it turned a political quarrel into a blood feud that the shogunate would not survive.

The snowy morning at Sakuradamon

Naosuke wanted the secret edict back from Mito. In the first month of 1860 the shogunate set a deadline of the 25th day and hinted that if it was not returned, Nariaki would be charged with defying the throne and the Mito house abolished. In Mito itself, armed men blocked the highway to stop the edict leaving, and one samurai cut open his belly in the great hall of the castle.

A group of Mito samurai decided that the only way out was to kill the great elder. To spare their lord, they formally left the domain, becoming rōnin, and through the Satsuma men in Edo they linked up with two brothers, Arimura Yūsuke and Arimura Jizaemon. Satsuma had promised to march troops to Kyoto at the same moment; the promise was quietly withdrawn and nobody told the men in Edo.

Edo-period map of the Sakurada area marked with the route of Ii Naosuke's procession and the attack point
A modern annotation on an Edo-period map of the Sakurada district. The red line marks the last stretch of the procession’s route and the cross the point of attack, outside the residence of the Kitsuki domain, with the blue band of the moat above. Everything happened in a space you could cross in a minute.

They met in a Shinagawa inn on the evening of the 2nd day of the 3rd month for a farewell drink, eighteen men who would never again be in one room, and each sent in a formal request to be struck off his domain’s rolls. The next morning they walked up the Tōkaidō and gathered at Atago Shrine. Then they went to wait at the Sakurada gate. They carried a manifesto listing his crimes, among them letting foreigners build churches for the “evil religion” and ending the practice of making people trample on pictures of Christ, which tells you how fresh the memory of Christianity in Japan still was in Mito.

Naosuke had been warned. A few days earlier the lord of Yoshii had visited him to urge him to resign and go home to Hikone until things calmed down, or at least to double his escort. He refused both. Increasing the guard, he is said to have reasoned, would only look as though the charges against him had rattled him.

Two pipes of tobacco

The 3rd day of the 3rd month was the Girls’ Festival, and every daimyo in Edo, which under alternate attendance meant half the lords in Japan, was due at the castle to offer congratulations. Townspeople lined the moat to watch, holding bukan, printed guides to the lords’ crests and retinues that turned the parade into a kind of trainspotting. The assassins stood among them with bukan of their own.

It was snowing heavily, unseasonable snow in the fourth week of March by the modern calendar, though by the time the fighting began it had thinned to sleet. The drum in the castle sounded at 8:00. At about 9:00 the gate of the Ii mansion opened and Naosuke’s palanquin came out with an escort of some sixty men, for a walk of perhaps 400 metres. Because of the snow his guards wore rain capes, and their swords were wrapped in cloth covers, hilt and scabbard both, to keep the wet off the lacquer and the binding.

Hand scroll sketch of the 1860 attack on Ii Naosuke's procession in the snow outside Sakuradamon
The fight drawn by Hasuda Ichigorō, one of the attackers, while he was held in custody, and handed in at his interrogation. It is a picture by a man who was there, and it shows a scrum in the snow, not a duel.

As the head of the procession passed the Kitsuki residence, a man stepped out as if to present a petition. When a Hikone officer moved to stop him, he cut the officer down. While the escort’s attention went forward, a shot was fired into the palanquin, and the rest of the attackers came in from both sides.

Japanese accounts usually give the shot to Kurosawa Chūzaburō, though some give it to others or describe several. English-language accounts often add that it came from a Japanese-made copy of the Colt revolver Perry had given the shogunate, which is a good story and possibly true. Whoever fired, the bullet went through Naosuke’s hip and thigh. The founder of the Shinshin-shinryū school of fast sword-drawing could not get out of his own palanquin.

Woodblock triptych by Tsukioka Yoshitoshi of swordsmen attacking a palanquin in falling snow
Tsukioka Yoshitoshi’s triptych of the attack, from the Meiji era, when the subject could finally be printed. When the playwright Kawatake Mokuami disguised it as a scene from the Soga brothers’ revenge in 1863, the shogunate shut the play down.

The hired bearers and footmen dropped everything and ran, and so, it has to be said, did a good many of the samurai. The ones who stayed found they could not draw. With the covers tied on, men fought with sheathed swords or grabbed at blades with bare hands and lost fingers and ears. Kawanishi Chūzaemon, the domain’s best swordsman and a two-sword fighter, calmly threw off his cape, untied his covers and killed one of the attackers, Inada Jūzō, before he was cut down himself.

With the palanquin abandoned in the snow, the attackers drove their swords through its walls. Arimura Jizaemon tore open the door, dragged Naosuke out by his topknot, and with the shriek of the Satsuma Jigen school took his head. Hata Yahei, a Mito man posted to watch and report, later said the whole thing took about as long as smoking two pipes of tobacco.

Woodblock print of the Satsuma samurai Arimura Jizaemon raising a sword
Arimura Jizaemon as a hero print imagined him, sword raised. The reality was messier. Arimura was twenty-three by Japanese count, already badly wounded, and dead within the hour.

The head

Arimura made off with the head on the point of his sword. Ogawara Hidenojō, a young Hikone retainer who had been cut down and left for dead, heard the victory shout, got up, chased him and slashed him across the back of the head before the others finished Ogawara off. Arimura got as far as the gate of the mansion of Endō Tanenori, a junior councillor whose small domain of Mikami lay in Ōmi, not far from Hikone, and killed himself there.

So the head of the great elder ended up with the Endō household, which refused five times to hand it over before the shogunate’s inspectors had seen it, until everyone agreed on a fiction. The head was formally returned as that of Kada Kurōta, a retainer of about the right age and build who had died in the fight, and the Ii doctor Okajima Genken sewed it back onto the body that evening.

Painting on silk of the 1860 fight around Ii Naosuke's palanquin outside the Sakurada gate
An anonymous painting on silk dated to 1860 itself: snow on the roofs and walls, umbrellas, men tumbling, a palanquin in the middle. Edo artists were forbidden to publish the scene, which did not stop them painting it.

On Naosuke’s side, eight men died besides their lord and others were badly hurt. Of the sixteen attackers who fought, one was killed on the spot, four, badly wounded, killed themselves, eight surrendered and three got away. Nearly all were executed or died in custody within two years, but Masuko Kinpachi and Kaigo Sakinosuke hid out the rest of the shogunate, and Kaigo ended up working for the Meiji police.

The survivors on the Hikone side fared worse. In 1862 the domain punished every man who had come back from that morning alive: the badly wounded were exiled to the domain’s lands at Sano and confined, the lightly wounded were ordered to commit seppuku, and the unhurt were beheaded and their houses abolished. The hired bearers who had run first were not punished at all, because they were not samurai. I can think of no clearer illustration of what bushidō actually meant in practice: the duty to die was a privilege of rank.

A dead man on sick leave

The regime wanted to stop Hikone taking revenge on Mito and to save the Ii house, which could be abolished if its lord died with his succession unsettled. So Naosuke did not die. That afternoon a notice in his name reported that he had been injured and gone home to rest. The young shogun sent ginseng, rock sugar and fresh fish to aid his recovery, and the other lords sent messengers to ask after his health, including, with remarkable nerve, the lord of Mito.

Out in Setagaya, which belonged to Hikone, the wife of the domain’s local magistrate noted in her diary that the household was praying for their lord’s recovery. The government accepted his “resignation” at the end of the 3rd month and allowed his son to succeed, and his death was announced at the end of the intercalary 3rd month, almost two months after it happened. By then the era name had been changed to Man’en, after a fire at the castle and the killing at its gate.

Nobody in Edo was fooled. The blood-stained snow had been seen by every procession that came after, and by the afternoon crowds were picking through the slush at the gate. The comic verse of the town did the rest: one senryū punned on his title, Ii Kamon, as “a fine duck”, ii kamo, “caught not in a net but in a palanquin”. Another praised the patient so thrifty that he needed no pillow.

Tall stone memorial to Ii Naosuke at Myounji temple in Mito
The memorial to Naosuke at Myōun-ji in Mito, put up in 1968 by a descendant of a Mito samurai. It exists because of a legend that one of the escaping assassins carried the head home in a barrel of amazake. A skull was actually dug up under a Mito temple in 1967; the Ii family’s view is that the head never left Tokyo. Photo: 小石川人晃, CC BY-SA 4.0.

What followed

The assassination broke the shogunate’s authority in a single morning. Like the 47 Rōnin before them, the killers had carried a head through the streets of Edo, but this time the target was the government itself, and the government could not even admit what had happened. The wave of assassinations that followed, in Kyoto above all, gave the 1860s their character, and the regime fell less than eight years later.

Nariaki died that autumn, still under house arrest. In 1862 the Hitotsubashi party came back to power in the Bunkyū reforms, with Yoshinobu as the shogun’s guardian and Shungaku as head of the government, and they settled accounts. Hikone was stripped of 100,000 koku of its 300,000 and of the lands it held in trust, and of its hereditary duty to guard Kyoto.

Before the punishment came, the domain had tried to save itself by executing Nagano Shuzen and Utsugi Kageyoshi, beheaded and left unburied, a penalty heavier than seppuku. It did not save the domain.

The Kyoto duty went to Matsudaira Katamori of Aizu, as the new post of Protector of Kyoto, and it was Aizu that took the Shinsengumi under its wing. When the Mito radicals of the Tengu party rose in 1864 and marched west, Hikone men blocked the Nakasendō against them, and when they surrendered at Tsuruga, Hikone men volunteered to help with the 352 executions.

Old photograph of the original bronze statue of Ii Naosuke at Kamonyama in Yokohama
The first statue of Naosuke at Kamonyama in Yokohama, photographed in 1910, a year after it went up. The government’s surviving founders, Yamagata Aritomo, Itō Hirobumi, Matsukata Masayoshi and Inoue Kaoru among them, stayed away from the unveiling because the prospectus called him the benefactor who opened the country. Two of the four had been pupils of Yoshida Shōin.

In 1866 Hikone’s troops marched against Chōshū in the red armour of Naomasa’s day and were picked off by night, the lacquer being as visible in the dark as it had been at Sekigahara. Two years later, at Toba-Fushimi, Hikone switched sides to the new imperial government, and it was Hikone men who arrested the Shinsengumi commander Kondō Isami at Nagareyama. The house of the Red Demon ended up on the winning side of the Meiji Restoration, which is the kind of irony the Ii seem to attract.

How he has been judged

For the first generation of the Meiji era Naosuke was a villain who had defied the emperor, executed the heroes of the new state and sold the country to foreigners, and Hikone’s former retainers spent decades trying to change that. A biography by the journalist Shimada Saburō in 1888 recast him as the man who had seen what was coming, and in 1909, for the fiftieth anniversary of the opening of Yokohama, his old retainers put up the statue at Kamonyama.

1958 Japanese ten-yen stamp showing the Kamonyama statue of Ii Naosuke between ships
The 1958 stamp for the centenary of the treaty ports, with the Kamonyama statue between a sailing steamer and a modern harbour. By then the first statue had been melted down in 1943 for the war effort and recast in 1954, partly from the model of the bronze at Gōtoku-ji. The post office had come round to the retainers’ view.

The novelist Funahashi Seiichi made him a romantic hero in Hana no Shōgai, serialised in 1952 and 1953, with Murayama Taka as heroine. In 1963 it became the very first of NHK’s year-long historical dramas, which means that the longest-running costume drama franchise in Japanese television began with Ii Naosuke.

Hikone and Mito took longer. In 1968 the two cities, with Tsuruga acting as go-between, signed a friendship pact; Mito sent plum trees from its Kairakuen garden and Hikone sent swans from its castle moat. The mayor of Hikone at the time was Ii Naoyoshi, Naosuke’s great-grandson. As late as 2013 a Hikone mayoral candidate who descended from the Arimura family was attacked in campaign leaflets for his ancestry, so I would not call the matter closed.

Portrait of Ii Naosuke in court dress painted by his son Ii Naoyasu
Naosuke painted in the middle of the Meiji era by his fourth son, Ii Naoyasu, who was a boy of eight or nine when his father was killed and worked partly from memory. Naoyasu was adopted into a branch family but asked to be buried beside his father, and he was, at Gōtoku-ji in 1935. The portrait hangs in the temple’s Dharma hall.

My own view is that he was neither the villain of the Meiji textbooks nor the far-sighted statesman of the Kamonyama prospectus. He was a conservative of real ability who believed that the shogunate had the right and the duty to govern, accepted the treaties because the alternative was war, and then tried to suppress the political consequences with the methods of a jailer. The treaty survived him and so did the open ports. The purge made him a martyr’s executioner, and the men he executed won.

Where to see Ii Naosuke’s Japan today

The trail splits in two: Hikone, an easy day trip from Kyoto, for the buried tree and the lord, and Tokyo for the great elder and the grave, with Yokohama as a coda. Prices and hours below come from the venues’ own sites in late 2026; several Hikone prices rose this year, so check before you go.

Hikone Castle and the Hikone Castle Museum

Hikone Castle, the Ii seat, is one of Japan’s 12 original castles and worth seeing whatever your interest in Naosuke. It is fifteen minutes’ walk from JR Hikone Station, under an hour from Kyoto on the JR Biwako Line or a change from the Tōkaidō Shinkansen at Maibara. The castle is open 8:30–17:00 every day; a ticket costs ¥1,000 for adults and includes the Genkyū-en garden.

The white keep of Hikone Castle above autumn trees
Hikone’s keep in late November. Naosuke was born at the foot of this hill and waited fifteen years at the edge of its moat. In 1878 Emperor Meiji, the son of the emperor whose consent Naosuke never obtained, ordered the castle saved from demolition. Photo: Martin Falbisoner, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The Hikone Castle Museum, in a reconstruction of the domain palace at the foot of the hill, holds the Ii family’s collection and the domain archive behind much of this story. Admission is ¥700, or ¥1,500 for a combined ticket with the castle and garden. Hours run 9:00–17:00 in autumn and 9:00–16:30 from December to February, with last entry thirty minutes before closing; it also closes a few days most months and over the New Year.

The reconstructed palace buildings of the Hikone Castle Museum beside a stone wall
The Hikone Castle Museum, rebuilt on the excavated plan of the domain palace. Exhibits rotate every month or two, so you may find his tea utensils, his writings, or the wooden statue of him carved in Kyoto the year after his death. The red armour of the Ii troops is the museum’s signature. Photo: 663highland, CC BY 2.5.

Inside the grounds, the free Kaikoku Kinenkan, the Opening of the Country Memorial Hall, keeps the Japan 100 Castles stamp. The bronze statue of Naosuke stands in the park outside the Sawaguchi gate on the way to Genkyū-en, a lakeside stroll garden laid out by his ancestors with the keep borrowed as its centrepiece.

The Umoregi-no-ya

The house of the buried tree is ten minutes from the station and a few steps from the castle’s Sawaguchi gate, at 1-11 Osue-machi, facing the middle moat. It is open 9:00–17:00 with last entry at 16:30, closed on Mondays (Tuesday when Monday is a holiday) and shut completely from 20 December to the end of February. Adults have paid ¥500 since 1 March 2026.

Tatami rooms and veranda of the Umoregi-no-ya in Hikone seen across its small garden
The rooms of the Umoregi-no-ya, rebuilt piece by piece after heavy snow brought the house down in 1984, and reopened in 1991. Excavation during the work found six phases of rebuilding since the house went up around 1759, and turned up, among other things, its Edo-period lavatories. Photo: 663highland, CC BY 2.5.

It is smaller than you expect, a middling samurai house with a garden and a tiny tea room Naosuke called the Juro-an, and that is the point. The family of a domain official bought it in 1871 and still own it. Go in spring or autumn, sit on the veranda for a few minutes, and try to imagine fifteen years of being nobody in particular.

Tenneiji and the five hundred rakan

Tenneiji (天寧寺), on high ground east of the station, is about fifteen minutes on foot or a short bus ride to the Tenneiji-guchi stop. After the assassination, Hikone retainers packed the blood-soaked earth from the street at Sakurada into straw bales and brought it back here to bury, and a memorial tower was later raised over it. It also keeps the cushion from his palanquin, and the grave of Nagano Shuzen, put up in the Meiji era when Naosuke’s reputation had recovered enough for Nagano’s to follow.

Stone memorial tower to Ii Naosuke on a stepped base at Tenneiji temple, Hikone
The memorial tower to Naosuke at Tenneiji, raised over the earth brought home from Sakuradamon. The temple was founded by his father, who had a maid executed for an illicit pregnancy and then learned that the man responsible was his own eldest son. The Ii have never been short of guilt to commemorate.

The temple is open 9:00–17:00, and recent sources give admission as ¥500. The main draw for most people is the hall of 527 wooden rakan, carved for Naonaka by the Kyoto sculptor Komai Chōun. Look for Murayama Taka’s memorial stone in the grounds as well.

Rows of seated wooden rakan statues inside the rakan hall at Tenneiji, Hikone
Inside the rakan hall at Tenneiji. The saying in Hikone is that if you want to see the face of someone you have lost, you should search among the five hundred rakan, and that you will always find it. I looked for a long time and found an uncle.

Sakuradamon and the Ii mansion site

The Sakuradamon (桜田門) still stands on the southwest side of the Imperial Palace, a double gate with the largest enclosed courtyard of any surviving gate of Edo Castle, free and open at all hours. Take the Tokyo Metro Yūrakuchō Line to Sakuradamon Station; the gate is across the road. You will notice the headquarters of the Metropolitan Police opposite, which is why Tokyo slang uses “Sakuradamon” to mean the police.

Pavement beside the Sakurada moat running from the former Ii residence toward Sakuradamon
The view along the moat from the Ii mansion site toward Sakuradamon. Naosuke’s last journey ran roughly along this pavement, which is wider, drier and considerably safer now.

The Ii mansion stood on what is now the north part of the National Diet front garden, where the Parliamentary Museum stood until it closed for rebuilding in 2022. The Sakura-no-i, a famous well that stood outside the mansion’s main gate and gave water to people on their way to the castle, has been moved into the garden. Walk from there to the gate and you have walked the route; it is the best way to understand how short, and how public, the whole thing was.

The Korai gate of Sakuradamon with stone walls and the white watchtower gate behind
The outer gate of Sakuradamon, with the watchtower gate behind it at right angles, so that an attacker who forced the first would be shot at from above. It was built to stop armies; the men who killed the great elder never needed to go through it. Photo: 663highland, CC BY 2.5.

To follow the assassins, start at Atago Shrine near Kamiyachō, where a monument marks their meeting point, and walk north. The attack happened in the street outside the gate, not inside it, and there is no marker to look for. Combine the walk with the rest of Edo Castle, a pleasant stroll north along the moat.

Kawase Hasui woodblock print of Sakuradamon and its reflection in the moat at dusk
Sakuradamon in Kawase Hasui’s Twenty Views of Tokyo, published in 1928, the gate and its reflection still in the dusk. Hasui made it look as though nothing had ever happened here. You get the same reflection on a still day from the moat path opposite.

Gōtoku-ji, Setagaya

Gōtoku-ji (豪徳寺) has been the Ii family’s Edo temple since 1633, when Setagaya became Hikone territory under the second lord, Ii Naotaka. The family cemetery, with the graves of Naotaka, Naosuke and other lords and their wives, is a national historic site, and free to enter. The temple gates are open 6:00–17:00 and the office from 8:00 to 15:00. The nearest station is Miyanosaka on the Tōkyū Setagaya Line, five minutes’ walk; from Gōtokuji Station on the Odakyū Line allow fifteen.

Fenced stone grave of Ii Naosuke flanked by lanterns in the Ii family cemetery at Gotokuji
Naosuke’s grave in the Ii cemetery. The death date carved on it is the 28th day of the intercalary 3rd month of Man’en 1, nearly two months after he died, because the stone tells the official story. He chose his own posthumous name, Sōkan-in Ryūgyō Kakuō, while he was alive. A survey in 2012 found no burial chamber within three metres of the surface. Photo: Suikotei, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Behind his grave, slightly to the right, stands a memorial to the eight retainers who died with him. A former Hikone retainer, Enjō Kendō, kept watch over the grave for half a century after the assassination, and the family gave him a tea room to live in; a rebuilt version stands in the grounds. The red gate in the grounds was once a gatehouse of the Ii mansion in Edo.

Hundreds of white beckoning-cat figures offered at Gotokuji temple in Setagaya
The beckoning cats of Gōtoku-ji, thousands of them, left by people whose wishes came true. The legend is that a cat waved Ii Naotaka in out of a thunderstorm, and that he made the temple his family’s in gratitude. It is a much happier Ii story than Naosuke’s, and far more people come for it.

See the cats, but give the cemetery time too, and then ride the Setagaya Line three stops back towards Sangenjaya to Shōin-jinja-mae, where Yoshida Shōin’s pupils reburied him in 1863 and later built him a shrine; Itō Hirobumi and Yamagata Aritomo gave lanterns for it. The great elder and the man he executed lie fifteen minutes apart on the same suburban tram. The magistrate’s house where the Setagaya household prayed for a dead man’s recovery stands at Kamimachi, in between.

Kamonyama Park, Yokohama

Kamonyama Park in Yokohama, on a hill named for Naosuke’s title, Kamon-no-kami, is twelve minutes on foot from Sakuragichō Station. It is free, with around two hundred cherry trees, so in cherry blossom season you will share him with a great many picnickers. The statue looks out over the Yokohama waterfront, a port that would not exist without the treaty he took the blame for.

Bronze statue of Ii Naosuke on a tall stone base in Kamonyama Park, Yokohama
The 1954 recast of the Kamonyama statue, in the court robes of his rank, on the original 6.6-metre pedestal designed by Tsumaki Yorinaka. The Yokohama Noh Theatre now shares the hill, which Naosuke the kyōgen writer would have liked. Photo: Yoshi Canopus, CC BY-SA 4.0.

One time, one meeting

He belongs, I think, with the handful of samurai who changed the country without ever winning a battle. He governed for less than two years, at the end of the Edo era and of the Tokugawa shogunate, and the decision that made him famous was made by two officials who heard only half of what he said. The decision that made him hated was entirely his own. Both shaped the country that Emperor Meiji and the men of the Restoration inherited; my overview of Japan through the ages follows the whole sweep.

What stays with me is the end of the tea manual. The guests have gone, and the host goes back into the room and sits alone before the kettle, thinking about the people who have left and the meeting that will not come again. Naosuke wrote that in a house where nothing ever happened to him, and then lived a life in which every meeting turned out to matter, until one snowy morning outside a castle gate he had his last.

If you go to Hikone, go to the Umoregi-no-ya before the castle, while it is quiet. Sit on the veranda for a while. Do not hurry to tidy up.

Scroll to Top