The Shimabara Rebellion and the Siege That Closed Japan

The shogunate’s soldiers who broke into Hara Castle in April 1638 found a prisoner in the rebels’ own jail. He was Yamada Emonsaku, a painter who had learned Western-style painting from the Portuguese as a boy, and his fellow defenders had locked him up for trying to sell them out. A Saga soldier was about to cut him down when he produced the arrow-letters he had exchanged with the besiegers. They let him live.

Something between 27,000 and 37,000 men, women and children had gone into that castle, depending on whose count you trust. Officially, Emonsaku was the only defender the shogunate chose to spare. His wife and children had been killed inside the walls shortly before the final assault, and the deposition he gave his captors is still one of the main sources for what happened in the castle.

He is also said to have painted the rebels’ banner. It hangs today in a museum in Amakusa, a chalice and a host between two kneeling angels, with a Portuguese line across the top praising the Blessed Sacrament. I keep coming back to that pairing: the most famous object of Japan’s great Christian rising, and a man most of the rebels would have called a traitor. Neither side of the Shimabara Rebellion comes out of the record as heroes, and the banner is a good place to start understanding why.

Amakusa Shiro battle flag of 1637 with a chalice, host and two kneeling angels, Amakusa Christian Museum
The jinchū-ki, or camp banner, attributed to Yamada Emonsaku and now an Important Cultural Property at the Amakusa Christian Museum. The inscription reads, in old Portuguese, “Praised be the most holy Sacrament”. The stains and small holes are traditionally read as blood and arrow damage from the siege; nobody can prove it either way.

A Christian corner of Kyushu

To understand why this happened on the Shimabara Peninsula and nowhere else, you have to go back half a century. The Arima family, lords of the southern peninsula since the 15th century, had become one of the great Christian houses of the Sengoku wars. Arima Harunobu was baptised in 1580, and the same year the Jesuit visitor Alessandro Valignano, the man who brought Yasuke to Japan, opened a seminary under his protection at Arima.

Harunobu rebuilt Hara Castle, a 15th-century fort on a headland over the Ariake Sea, into a modern stone castle in the Toyotomi style. When its main works were finished in 1604, the Jesuit annual report recorded that the castle had been blessed. That blessing mattered thirty-three years later, when people who still remembered it chose where to make their stand.

Illustration of the Christian daimyo Arima Harunobu
Arima Harunobu as a 20th-century illustrator imagined him. Harunobu fell in the Okamoto Daihachi bribery affair of 1612 and was ordered to die; as a Christian he would not cut his own belly, and is said to have had a retainer behead him instead.

It is worth being clear about what “Christian” meant here. In Arima, as in Ōmura and Amakusa, conversion had often come from the top down, and the Christian lords had their own record of tearing down temples and shrines. Japanese reference works say bluntly that Arima’s subjects were converted under pressure. The faith took root anyway, deeply enough to survive two changes of lord and a generation of persecution.

Stone steps at Hinoe Castle ruins in Minamishimabara built from reused gravestones
Steps at Hinoe Castle, the Arima clan’s main seat, laid with reused gravestones, generally taken to be Buddhist stones pulled up under the Christian lords. It is a useful corrective to the idea that intolerance only ran one way on this peninsula. Photo: Kuma83, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The national climate turned in Harunobu’s lifetime. Oda Nobunaga had found the Jesuits useful; Toyotomi Hideyoshi issued an expulsion edict in 1587 and, ten years later, had the twenty-six martyrs crucified at Nagasaki. Then Tokugawa Ieyasu banned the religion in shogunal lands in 1612 and across the country in 1614. That year Harunobu’s son Naozumi, who had given up the faith, was moved to Nobeoka in Hyūga, and the peninsula he left behind was full of Christians with no Christian lord.

Across the water, Amakusa had a similar history. It had belonged to Konishi Yukinaga, Hideyoshi’s Christian general, until Konishi chose the losing side at Sekigahara in 1600. He was executed in Kyoto alongside Ishida Mitsunari, refusing seppuku for the same reason Harunobu would, and his retainers went back to the land as farmers and village heads. Some of them were still there, and still armed, in 1637.

The longer story of the mission, from Xavier’s landing in 1549 to the bans, is in my piece on Christianity in Japan. What matters here is that by the 1630s the Shimabara Peninsula and Amakusa were a population that remembered Christian lords, had lost them, and were now governed by men determined to make them forget.

Matsukura’s castle, and who paid for it

The man who replaced the Arima was Matsukura Shigemasa, a hard-bitten professional soldier who had served the Tsutsui, then Hideyoshi, then Ieyasu. He earned a small fief at Gojō in Yamato for his part at Sekigahara and, for his service in the winter and summer sieges of Osaka Castle, a promotion in 1616 to the Arima lands, assessed at 40,000 koku. Japanese encyclopaedias call him a bupen kōsha, a man of martial merit, which is a polite way of saying he was very good at one thing.

Wooden statue of Matsukura Shigemasa in the main hall of Koto-ji temple, Shimabara
Shigemasa’s wooden statue in the main hall of Kōtō-ji, the Shimabara temple he founded and where he is buried. He is enshrined with the respect due to a founder, which is more than most of his subjects would have given him. Photo: Lapis2013, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Shigemasa abandoned both Arima castles, Hinoe and Hara, under the shogunate’s one-castle-per-province rule, and built himself something far grander on the eastern shore. Shimabara Castle, with its five-storey keep and white walls, was regarded even at the time as out of proportion to a 40,000-koku domain. He also took on a share of the shogunate’s rebuilding of Edo Castle, which is how an ambitious outside lord bought favour in the 1620s.

Reconstructed keep of Shimabara Castle in Shimabara, Nagasaki, in 2025
Shimabara Castle’s keep is a 1964 concrete reconstruction, but the scale is true to the original: this is a castle for a lord with ten times the land Shigemasa actually held. The bill for it went to the farmers of the southern peninsula. Photo: Uraniwa, CC BY 4.0.

He paid for it the only way he could. The Matsukura ran their own land survey, and the one his son completed in 1631 put the domain’s yield at 2.34 times its official assessment; one Japanese account describes it as taxing a real 40,000 koku as if it were 100,000. Head taxes and house taxes appear in the Nabeshima records and in the diary of the Dutch head of trade, though how many of the more lurid levies in later accounts were real, and how many were added by people looking for a villain, is a fair question.

Shigemasa was also a persecutor of real energy. From 1627 he sent Christians up to the volcanic springs of Unzen, where officials poured the scalding water over those who refused to recant. In 1630 he went further and petitioned the shogunate to let him attack Luzon in the Philippines, the Spanish base from which missionaries slipped into Japan, and sent two retainers disguised as merchants to scout Manila.

Steaming volcanic vents at Unzen Jigoku hot springs, Unzen, Nagasaki
Unzen Jigoku, “Unzen Hell”, the fumarole field above Shimabara where Christians were tortured between 1627 and the early 1630s. Today it is a boardwalk loop with stalls selling eggs boiled in the vents, and a small cross by the path marks what happened here. Photo: 663highland, CC BY 2.5.

He died suddenly in the eleventh month of 1630, before the Luzon scheme went anywhere; there were rumours that the Nagasaki magistrate Takenaka Shigeyoshi had poisoned him. His son Katsuie inherited the domain, the debts and the policies, and by every account squeezed harder. Then the weather turned. Drought and bad harvests ran from the mid-1630s into 1637, and the demands did not ease.

One story from the autumn of 1637 is told in nearly every Japanese account of the outbreak. The pregnant wife of Yozaemon, headman of Kuchinotsu village, was taken hostage for her village’s unpaid rice and kept in a water cell; after several days she died there with her newborn child. I give it as the chroniclers give it, from a Kuroda family record, and I would not swear to every detail. I am fairly sure the people of Kuchinotsu believed it.

Amakusa, and a tax on half a harvest

Amakusa, across the strait, was not Matsukura’s at all. After Sekigahara it went to Terazawa Hirotaka, lord of Karatsu on the far side of Hizen, who held it as a detached territory and assessed it at 42,000 koku: 37,000 from fields and 5,000 from mulberry, tea, salt and fishing. According to later reckonings, the islands really produced about half that.

Taxing a harvest at double its real size will ruin a place faster than any religious policy, and it did. By the 1630s Hirotaka’s son Katataka was in charge, the islands were starving, and the men who organised the villages were often the former Konishi retainers who had turned farmer in 1600. Not far away, the fall of Katō Kiyomasa‘s son Tadahiro in 1632, which handed Kumamoto Castle to the Hosokawa, had turned loose another crop of masterless samurai from Higo.

Reconstructed Korai gate in the main bailey of Tomioka Castle, Reihoku, Amakusa
The rebuilt gate at Tomioka Castle, the Terazawa stronghold on the northwest tip of Amakusa. The rebels took its northern bailey in late 1637 and had the garrison close to the end; what saved the castle was the news, reaching the attackers first, that relief armies were on the way. Photo: Naokijp, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Taxes, famine or faith?

Historians have argued about the cause ever since, and the argument started before the shooting stopped. Contemporary records such as the Hosokawa house chronicle put the blame squarely on over-taxation. Matsukura Katsuie, not surprisingly, insisted it was a Christian riot, and the shogunate found that version useful, because it turned a scandal about misrule into a reason to tighten the ban.

For two centuries that framing stuck: the Shimabara Rebellion was a war of religion. Twentieth-century Japanese historians largely turned it round into a peasant uprising with a Christian banner, and that is still the view most reference works lead with. The Catholic Church has never counted the dead of Hara Castle as martyrs, precisely because they died fighting.

The most interesting thing I have read on this comes from the historian Nakamura Tadashi, writing in a Heibonsha encyclopaedia. He points out that the reports neighbouring domains gathered in the first weeks already contained three theories: a rising of lapsed Christians returning to the faith, a revolt against misrule, and a third that the Christian banner was a deliberate tactic, raised to draw shogunal envoys down from Edo so the peasants could expose their lord over his head. More recently Kanda Chisato has argued the religious side back into the centre, as a movement of people who had once recanted and were now “rising up” to return.

I don’t think you have to choose. A Japanese encyclopaedia figure that has stayed with me: of the 27,671 people of the Shimabara domain, 86 per cent joined the rising. Nobody gets 86 per cent of a population behind them on one grievance. But the same sources say plainly that villages which refused were forced in, and that the northern half of the peninsula, the kitame, held the rebels off from behind the cliffs of the Chijiwa fault and stayed out of it.

Row of headless stone Jizo statues in Shimabara, Nagasaki
Headless stone Jizō statues in Shimabara. Local tradition blames the rebels of 1637, who burned temples and shrines as they went; the story is hard to prove for any particular statue, but attacks on Buddhist sites during the rising are reported in the accounts of the time.

The boy from Ōyano

At the centre of all this was a teenager. He is known as Amakusa Shirō, but that is a battle name; he was Masuda Shirō Tokisada, son of Masuda Jinbei Yoshitsugu, a former Konishi retainer who had settled as a farmer at Ebe in Uto district of Higo. His baptismal name was Jerónimo, later changed to Francisco, and his birth is usually given as 1621, with a question mark.

Almost everything solid about him comes from his mother, who was arrested at Ebe after the outbreak and questioned. She said that he had started his lessons at nine and travelled to Nagasaki more than once to study, and the picture is of a well-off, unusually educated boy. Kotobank, summing up the record, says that hardly anything else about him can be stated with confidence.

Tsukioka Yoshitoshi woodblock print of Amakusa Shiro from Keisei suikoden, 1874
Tsukioka Yoshitoshi’s Shirō from an 1874 series of warrior prints: full armour, a heavy sword, a scowl. The real Shirō was a boy of about sixteen who almost certainly never commanded troops in battle, but by the Meiji era the legend had long since outgrown the person.

Around him grew a legend that the organisers of the rising did nothing to discourage. A prophecy circulated, attributed to a missionary expelled a generation earlier, that after twenty-five years a heavenly child would appear, the eastern and western skies would burn, and dead trees would flower. Shirō was said to have restored a blind girl’s sight, walked on the sea and produced a dove from his hand, miracles so close to the Gospels that they are best read as advertising.

There was even a whisper, recorded in a Satsuma book, that he was a secret son of Toyotomi Hideyori, who on this telling had escaped the fall of Osaka in 1615 and fled south; the evidence offered was that Shirō’s gourd standard looked like Hideyoshi’s. Historians give it no credit. The useful point is that the rising’s leaders needed a figure the villages would follow to the death, and they found, or built, one.

1876 Toyohara Kunichika print of the actor Onoe Kikugoro as Amakusa Shiro Tokisada
Toyohara Kunichika’s 1876 portrait of Onoe Kikugorō as “Amakusa Shirō Tokisada”. Under the Tokugawa the rebellion could only be staged in disguise, as sorcery plays about magicians and toads; within a few years of the ban on Christianity being lifted in 1873, Shirō walked on stage under his own name.

The best eyewitness description comes from an unlikely source: a Kurume merchant who happened to be in Hondo during the fighting there and whose account was copied into a Hosokawa report. He saw Shirō land by boat and mount a horse, dressed in white silk and hakama, with a small cross set at his forehead and a gohei, a Shinto wand of folded paper, in his hand. A Christian messiah holding a Shinto wand is a good summary of how improvised all of this was.

Did he lead? The leadership council named in the records was made up of grown men: former Arima and Konishi retainers, a village headman of Amakusa, and Shirō’s own father. Most Japanese historians now see Shirō as the banner rather than the general, though a figurehead who held some 27,000 people together through a winter siege was not nothing.

Yushima island in the Ariake Sea seen from the Hinoe Castle ruins, Minamishimabara
Yushima, the small island in the Ariake Sea between Shimabara and Amakusa, seen from Hinoe Castle. Its other name is Dangōjima, “conference island”, because the conspirators are said to have met there to plan the rising and choose Shirō as their leader. Photo: shikabane taro, CC BY 3.0.

The rising, December 1637

The trigger came in Arima village on the 25th day of the tenth month of Kan’ei 14. Japanese sources convert that to 11 December 1637; English-language accounts often give 17 December, and I would follow the Japanese conversion. A crowd of villagers, led by Arima’s Christians, went to the local magistrate’s office to argue, and killed the magistrate, Hayashi Hyōzaemon.

Within a day the southern peninsula was up. A Matsukura force fought the rebels at Fukae and fell back, the rebels burned the town around Shimabara Castle and laid siege to the castle itself, and the domain’s attempt to arm loyal villagers backfired when many of them took the weapons and joined the other side. Katsuie was in Edo, doing his alternate attendance, and the neighbouring domains would not move without orders from the shogunate.

Days later Amakusa rose too. At the end of December, at the battle of Hondo, the rebels killed the Terazawa castle warden Miyake Tōbei, who by an odd turn of history was the son of Akechi Hidemitsu, son-in-law of Akechi Mitsuhide, the man who killed Nobunaga. They went on to besiege Tomioka Castle and took its northern bailey before word of approaching relief armies made them break off.

There was talk among the rebels of crossing the Himi Pass and marching on Nagasaki, where the Portuguese traded. They did not. Instead the Amakusa people crossed the Ariake Sea to join the Shimabara rebels, and together they occupied the one fortified place on the southern peninsula that the Matsukura had not bothered to finish destroying: Hara Castle.

Seventeenth-century Japanese map of the siege of Hara Castle with besieging camps
A 17th-century map of the siege, with the castle on its headland and the besieging domains’ camps crowding the landward side. The sea on three sides was the defenders’ protection and, once the shogunate’s ships closed in, their prison.

Hara Castle

Hara was officially a ruin, but it was not much of one. Excavations since the 1990s have shown that when the rebels arrived the stone walls, gates and much else from Harunobu’s rebuild were still standing. The main bailey sat on a bluff about 30 metres above the sea, the ditches filled with seawater at high tide, and the rebels dug a new dry moat to make the inner castle into an island.

They repaired the palisades with planks from the boats they had come in, and filled the castle with rice, powder and guns taken from Matsukura storehouses. Shirō is said to have entered on the 3rd day of the twelfth month. How many people were inside is one of those load-bearing numbers on which the sources do not agree: 37,000 in the traditional count, 27,000 in others, with perhaps 14,000 fighters and the rest women, children and the old.

Seventeenth-century Yanagawa map of the siege of Hara Castle showing domain camps and the castle on its headland
The siege map held at the Yanagawa Ancient Documents Museum, an Important Cultural Property and long regarded as the most accurate of the many plans of the siege. It traces the investment from early 1638 through the final assault, with each domain’s camp in place; the Tachibana appear beside the Hosokawa below the third bailey.

The archaeology has its own small revelations. West of the main bailey, excavators found rows of square pit-houses, each two or three metres across, laid out in a regular pattern and probably assigned by family and village. None of them had a hearth or a cooking fire, in the middle of winter, which suggests the leadership enforced the kind of fire discipline you would expect of a daimyo‘s army.

That detail, more than any battle scene, makes me take the defenders seriously as an organisation. These were not a mob. They were villages, moved whole into a fortress and run by men who had served in real armies.

Itakura’s New Year

The shogunate’s first commander was Itakura Shigemasa, captain of one of Iemitsu’s guard units, sent with the inspector Ishigaya Sadakiyo. He was a sound man with one fatal problem: his own domain at Fukōzu was worth 15,000 koku, and he was supposed to give orders to the lords of Saga, Kurume and Yanagawa, some of whom held twenty times that. The Jōzan kidan, an 18th-century collection of anecdotes, has the shogun’s sword instructor Yagyū Munenori warning in advance that the Kyushu lords would never obey him.

Late Edo period portrait of Itakura Shigemasa, first shogunate commander at Hara Castle
Itakura Shigemasa in a late Edo portrait from his family’s collection. His death is the reason the rebellion is remembered as a disaster for the shogunate before it became a massacre.

Munenori was right. Itakura’s assaults in the twelfth month, late January and early February 1638 by Western reckoning, were beaten back with heavy losses. Then he heard that a second envoy, the senior councillor Matsudaira Nobutsuna, was on his way to take over, and he resolved to finish the job before Nobutsuna arrived.

On the first day of Kan’ei 15, 14 February 1638, he threw everything at the walls with no real plan. The attack cost the shogunate’s side something like 4,000 casualties, and Itakura himself was shot dead leading it. A New Year’s Day assault by a man in a hurry to save face is the kind of thing that ends careers; this one ended a life and turned a regional revolt into a national embarrassment.

Clever Izu and the long wait

Matsudaira Nobutsuna arrived on the 4th of the first month. He was known as Chie Izu, “clever Izu”, from his court title of Izu no kami, and he behaved exactly as the nickname suggests. He stopped attacking, built proper siege lines and sent for more troops, until the force around the castle passed 120,000 men by most counts, the largest army assembled in Japan since the summer siege of Osaka in 1615.

Early twentieth-century illustration of Matsudaira Nobutsuna by Arai Kanpo
Matsudaira Nobutsuna in an early 20th-century illustration by Arai Kanpō for a children’s history, showing an episode from his youth in the shogun’s household. That Meiji schoolchildren were given his boyhood as a model says a good deal about how Japan chose to remember the man who starved out Hara Castle.

The army he commanded was a museum of the previous century. Almost every lord in Kyushu was there in person: Nabeshima Katsushige of Saga with 35,000 men, Hosokawa Tadatoshi of Kumamoto with 23,500, Kuroda Tadayuki of Fukuoka with 18,000, and smaller contingents from Kurume, Yanagawa, Kokura and Nobeoka, where the former Christian Arima Naozumi now found himself besieging his family’s old castle. Satsuma sent 1,000 men under Yamada Arinaga, who as a young man had cut his way out of Sekigahara with Shimazu Yoshihiro.

Some of the veterans were very old indeed. Tachibana Muneshige, who had fought Hideyoshi’s Korean war and lost his domain for backing the wrong side in 1600, was past seventy; Mizuno Katsunari, who had fought at Sekigahara and Osaka, was older still. Men who had last pulled on armour for the Osaka campaigns of 1614 and 1615 found it again, and for many of them this was the last fight of the age of warring states.

Portrait of Tachibana Muneshige in his later years
Tachibana Muneshige in a portrait of his later years. By 1638 he was the grand old man of Kyushu warfare, and Japanese accounts credit him, with Mizuno Katsunari, with backing Nobutsuna’s decision to starve the castle rather than storm it again.

Another man in the lines was Miyamoto Musashi, then in his fifties. Sources variously put him with the Hosokawa, as most English-language accounts do, or with the Ogasawara of Nakatsu as guardian to their young lord, which is where the Japanese lists place him; his adopted son Iori was a senior commander in the Kokura contingent. In a letter written afterwards to Arima Naozumi, Musashi admitted that a stone thrown from the walls had hit him in the shin and he could barely stand, which is one of the very few documented moments in the military career of a man still ranked among Japan’s greatest samurai.

Nobutsuna also called on the Dutch. At the request of the Nagasaki authorities, the head of the Dutch trading post at Hirado, Nicolaes Couckebacker, landed five ship’s guns for a shore battery and brought the ship De Ryp round to bombard the castle from the sea. It did little damage, the rebels sent out a message asking whether there were no brave men left in Japan that the shogun had to borrow foreigners, and the Japanese lords, Hosokawa Tadatoshi among them, objected loudly enough that the bombardment was called off.

Nineteenth-century Japanese screen of a Dutch ship, thought to show the De Ryp at the Shimabara Rebellion
A 19th-century screen sold at a Dublin auction as probably showing the De Ryp off Hara Castle. I would treat the identification as a guess; it is a Dutch ship, flying Dutch colours, painted long after the event. The real De Ryp’s guns did the walls very little harm.

Nobutsuna’s own defence of the bombardment is revealing. He said the point had been to break the defenders’ hope that Portuguese help would come, which suggests that the shogunate believed, or wanted to believe, that the rising had foreign backers. The historian Hattori Hideo has pushed the idea further: the rebels looked to Catholic Portugal, the shogunate leaned on Protestant Holland, and the closing of the country to the Portuguese that followed was, in effect, the result of a military alliance.

1644 portrait of Hosokawa Tadatoshi, lord of Kumamoto
Hosokawa Tadatoshi, lord of Kumamoto Castle since the fall of the Katō in 1632, in a portrait of 1644. His mother was the Christian convert Hosokawa Gracia; at Hara Castle he besieged her co-religionists, complained about the Dutch, and wrote a stream of letters home that are among the best sources for the siege.

The irony around Tadatoshi is hard to ignore. His father was Hosokawa Tadaoki, one of Ieyasu’s sharpest allies, and his mother was Hosokawa Gracia, the most famous Christian woman of her age, who died in Osaka in 1600 rather than be taken hostage. Thirty-eight years later her son’s men were among the first into the castle where the last open Christian community in Japan was making its stand.

Meanwhile the shogunate worked on the inside. Arrow-letters went over the walls promising pardon to anyone who had been forced to join and was not a Christian, Shirō’s captured mother and sisters were made to write letters urging surrender, and one account has a party of Kōga men slipping into the castle and reporting that food was nearly gone. Nobody knows how many people quietly climbed down the sea cliffs and gave themselves up; one theory puts it at more than ten thousand, but there is no record to prove it.

The 27th and 28th of the second month

By early April the defenders were eating seaweed from the shore below the cliffs. A night sally failed, and what the shogunate learned from its prisoners settled the matter. At a council on the 24th of the second month Toda Ujikane argued for waiting and Mizuno Katsunari for attack, and Nobutsuna, conscious that every week of siege was a week of humiliation for the shogunate, chose attack.

Rain put the assault off to the 28th. On the 27th, 11 April 1638, Nabeshima Katsushige’s Saga troops jumped the gun and went in a day early, and the rest of the army followed them over the walls rather than be left out of the credit. Most Japanese sources give the fall as the 27th and 28th; some English-language accounts stretch the fighting to 15 April, and one Kotobank entry gives the 28th and 29th.

Saito Shuho 1837 folding screen of the final assault on Hara Castle, Akizuki Museum
The Shimabara Jinzu screen painted by Saitō Shūho in 1837 for the Kuroda lords of Akizuki, to mark the 200th anniversary of the siege. It shows the final assault on the 27th and 28th, the castle wreathed in smoke and every domain’s banners correctly placed. Two hundred years on, this was still a family triumph to be celebrated on a screen.

The castle fell over those two days. Shirō died in the main bailey, probably in the building the records call “Shirō’s house”, which the Hosokawa set alight with fire arrows. Nobody on the shogunate’s side knew what he looked like, so heads of boys his age were brought in one after another until his mother, shown them, broke down at one taken by a Hosokawa soldier whose name the records spell several ways, Jinno Sazaemon among them.

In 2024 a letter from Hosokawa Tadatoshi to the daimyo Kinoshita Nobutoshi, written in the days after the fall, turned up at the Amakusa Christian Museum. It says, matter-of-factly, that the Hosokawa men burned Shirō’s house and killed him as he came out. Shirō’s head was displayed outside the castle gate and then sent to Nagasaki, where it was exposed in front of the Portuguese trading post, a message that hardly needed translating.

Woodblock illustration of the siege of Hara Castle from the Shimabara-ki, 1640
The storming of Hara Castle in the Shimabara-ki, a printed account published in 1640, barely two years after the event. The rebellion was in print, as popular reading, long before anyone wrote its history.

The rest was killing, carried on after the fighting had ended. The shogunate’s verdict was that everyone inside should die, and its records say that apart from Yamada Emonsaku they did, old and young, women and children. Nobutsuna’s son Terutsuna, writing in his diary, recorded with something close to bewilderment that even girls seemed glad to be cut down, and put it down to their religion.

I take his account seriously and his explanation less so. Some of the dead no doubt chose martyrdom; others had been forced into the castle and had nowhere left to go. The shogunate’s side lost heavily too, though how heavily depends on whom you read: one Japanese record gives 1,130 dead and 6,960 wounded, another 2,800 and 7,700, and the Dutch head of trade wrote down 5,712 dead.

Grassy main bailey of the Hara Castle ruins in Minamishimabara, Nagasaki
Farmland around the castle, seen from the ruins. In the spring of 1638 all of this was camps, siege lines and gun positions; afterwards the shogunate had the castle’s walls pulled down and the dead buried within its grounds. Photo: shikabane taro, CC BY 3.0.

Settling the accounts

Then the shogunate turned on its own. Matsukura Katsuie lost his domain within weeks and was handed over to the Mori of Tsuyama for safekeeping. A chronicle of the case says that the body of a peasant was found in a tub at his residence, and in the seventh month, late August 1638, he was beheaded at the Mori mansion in Edo.

He was the only daimyo of the entire Edo period to be executed by beheading rather than permitted seppuku, which was, in the language of that world, a sentence that cancelled his rank before it ended his life. Terazawa Katataka lost Amakusa, and some years later killed himself; his house died with him. Nabeshima Katsushige, for jumping the gun, was confined to his residence for half a year, and Itakura’s son, who had joined the final assault without orders, was punished as well.

The cost to the treasury was put at some 400,000 ryō. Nobutsuna came out of it stronger than ever, and the regime of Iemitsu with him. It is easy to read the beheading of Katsuie as justice; it was also a warning to every lord in Japan that the shogunate expected its farmers to be kept alive enough to pay.

The southern peninsula and much of Amakusa were all but empty. The shogunate ordered domains across western Japan to send settlers, and the mixed dialects of the southern Shimabara Peninsula still reflect where they came from; one popular story credits migrants from Shōdoshima, the island that supplied stone for Osaka Castle, with bringing the noodle-making that became Shimabara sōmen. On Amakusa the population was put at about 5,000 in 1643 and 16,000 by 1659.

Statue of Suzuki Shigenari, first magistrate of Amakusa after the rebellion
Suzuki Shigenari, who fought in the siege and became the first shogunal magistrate of Amakusa, remembered here with a statue. He brought in settlers, built temples, invited his brother, the Zen monk Suzuki Shōsan, to preach to the survivors, and pressed Edo to halve the islands’ impossible tax assessment. Photo: shikabane taro, CC BY 3.0.

Shigenari is the closest thing this story has to a decent official. In Amakusa he is remembered with a shrine, and a local tradition holds that he killed himself in Edo in 1653 to force the tax reduction through. The halving did come, under his successor, in 1659. Whether he really died for it I can’t say; the islanders decided long ago that he did.

Closing the door

The rebellion did not create Japan’s closed-country policy, but it hardened it. In the seventh month of 1639 the shogunate banned Portuguese ships from Japan altogether, on the grounds that Catholic priests could not be kept out as long as the Portuguese came. When a Portuguese embassy from Macao arrived in 1640 to plead for the trade, most of its members were executed.

The Dutch, who had helped at Hara, were rewarded with a cage. In 1640 the shogunate’s anti-Christian inspector Inoue Masashige came to Hirado and ordered the Dutch company’s new stone warehouses torn down, because one of them bore its date in the Christian calendar. The next year the Dutch were moved to Dejima, the fan-shaped artificial island in Nagasaki harbour built for the Portuguese, and there they stayed for over two centuries.

Reconstructed 1639 stone warehouse of the Dutch trading post at Hirado, Nagasaki
The Dutch warehouse at Hirado, rebuilt in 2011 to the 1639 design. The original was demolished on the shogunate’s orders within a year of being finished, partly because of the date “Anno 1639” on its gable. Photo: Houjyou-Minori, CC BY-SA 3.0.
Kawahara Keiga painting of Nagasaki harbour with the fan-shaped island of Dejima, 1830s
Nagasaki harbour in the 1830s, from the workshop of Kawahara Keiga, with Dejima as the small fan-shaped island at the foot of the town. This was the narrow door through which Europe reached Japan from 1641 to the 1850s, and it is a short walk from where Shirō’s head was displayed.

Inside the country, the same years built the machinery of surveillance that lasted until the 1870s. Inoue was made the first commissioner of religious inspection in 1640, every household was required to register at a Buddhist temple, and annual fumi-e ceremonies, in which people stepped on a brass image of Christ or the Virgin, spread from Nagasaki, where they had begun around 1629, across Kyushu. The plan to invade Luzon was quietly dropped; by one account, the shogunate had revised its estimate of what Manila would take from 10,000 men to 100,000 after watching farmers hold Hara Castle for three months.

Brass fumi-e plaque of Christ on the cross, Tokyo National Museum
A brass fumi-e of the crucifixion, one of the plaques used in the Nagasaki inspections and now in the Tokyo National Museum. The worn face is from feet, year after year. Photo: Tokyo National Museum, CC BY 4.0.

The Christians who survived did so by going underground, and their descendants kept the faith in secret for seven generations; that is the story of the Hidden Christians, whose villages, Hara Castle among them, became a World Heritage Site in 2018. In 1805 the shogunate questioned 5,200 people in four Amakusa villages on suspicion of secret Christianity and, faced with that many, settled for having them step on the images and sign pledges.

The rebellion was the last large-scale fighting in Japan until the wars of the 1860s, and it sits in the long middle of the Edo era as the moment the Tokugawa peace was tested and found to be enforced by starvation. It belongs among Japan’s most decisive battles less for what happened on the field than for what came after: a country that spent the next two centuries looking at the West through one small window in Nagasaki. If you want to see where that fits in the longer sweep of Japanese history, it marks the line where the age of the sword ends and the age of the register begins.

Where to see the Shimabara Rebellion today

The sites split across the strait, as the rebellion did: Hara Castle and Shimabara on the Nagasaki side, Hondo, Ōyano and Tomioka on Amakusa in Kumamoto Prefecture. You can link the two halves the way the Amakusa rebels did, by sea; the Shimatetsu ferry from Kuchinotsu, at the southern tip of the peninsula, crosses to Oniike on Amakusa in about half an hour. Without a car, allow two full days and accept that buses are infrequent.

Shimatetsu car ferry Amakusa on the Kuchinotsu to Oniike crossing
A Shimatetsu car ferry on the Kuchinotsu to Oniike run. Kuchinotsu was the headman Yozaemon’s village, and Emonsaku’s too; the crossing is the quickest way to feel how close Amakusa and Shimabara really are. Photo: Olegushka, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Hara Castle ruins, Minamishimabara

This is the site that matters, and it is a quiet, grassy headland with a few monuments and a great deal of sky. There is no admission charge and no gate; the ruins are a National Historic Site and part of the Hidden Christian World Heritage listing. The main bailey is a short climb from the car park at Hara Castle Onsen Masago, a roadside spa building with a shop and a bath that looks out to Unzen and Amakusa.

Cross monument in the main bailey of the Hara Castle ruins, Minamishimabara
The cross in the main bailey of Hara Castle. Below it are the excavated remains of the honmaru gates, and below those the cliff the defenders climbed down for seaweed in the last weeks of the siege. Photo: STA3816, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Up in the honmaru you will find a statue of Shirō at prayer by the Minamishimabara-born sculptor Kitamura Seibō, a white cross, and a gravestone for Shirō, believed to have been put up by his mother, that was found built into the stone wall of a farmhouse in Nishi-Arie and moved here. Look too for the Hokobi Jizō, raised in 1766 by a local priest and village headmen to the dead of both sides, and for the memorial to Itakura Shigemasa in the third bailey. There is also the grave of Saburi Kyūnojō, a retainer of the Ikeda of Tottori, who fell in the main bailey and, the story goes, scratched his own name and the date into a stone that became his gravestone.

Excavated stone gateway remains in the main bailey of Hara Castle, Minamishimabara
The excavated gateway to the main bailey. The 2000 dig found a koguchi, a fortified entrance court, of about 90 by 80 metres, one of the largest known in Japan, with gravel-paved paths; much of what you see here was smashed by the shogunate’s demolition teams in 1638 and left as found. Photo: Kuma83, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Excavation since 1992 has turned up human bones, lead bullets, medals, rosaries and dozens of small crosses, some of them cast from bullet lead. The site is, among other things, a mass grave, and the official guide asks you to keep to the paths and not to smoke in the main bailey. Every April a memorial festival is held in the main bailey.

View of Mount Unzen from the Hara Castle ruins across fields, Minamishimabara
Mount Unzen from the Hara Castle ruins. On a clear spring morning it is a lovely view, and it is worth remembering that the Christians who were taken up those slopes to the hot springs in the 1620s came from villages you can see from here. Photo: Houjyou-Minori, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Getting there: Shimatetsu buses run from Shimabara Station towards Kazusa and take about an hour to the Harajō-mae stop, from which the ruins are a 15-minute walk. By car it is around 80 minutes from the Isahaya interchange on the Nagasaki Expressway. Bring water and a hat in summer; there is very little shade on the headland.

Arima Christian Heritage Museum and Hinoe Castle

Do the museum first if you can. The Minamishimabara City Arima Christian Heritage Museum, in the sports park at Minami-Arima, is the guidance centre for both Hara and Hinoe castles, and it tells the story in two halves: the Arima clan’s Christian golden age, then the persecution and the rebellion. The cases hold finds from the Hara excavations, including crosses believed to have been cast from bullet lead, and a replica of the bones as they were found.

Hours are 9:00–18:00, and it is closed on Thursdays and from 29 December to 3 January; admission is ¥300 for adults, ¥200 for high-school students and ¥150 for younger children. Some listings give shorter hours and no Thursday closure, so check with the museum before you go if your day is tight. From the Minami-Arima branch office bus stop it is about 15 minutes on foot.

Main approach to the Hinoe Castle ruins, seat of the Arima clan, Minamishimabara
The main approach to Hinoe Castle, the Arima clan’s mountain seat a few kilometres inland from Hara. It is a steep, short climb with a small shrine on the summit and the gravestone steps on the way; very few people make it, which is a pity. Photo: Indiana jo, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Shimabara Castle and Kōtō-ji

Shimabara Castle is about ten minutes’ walk from Shimabara Station on the Shimabara Railway. Its 1964 keep has a floor of Christian material, including items connected to the persecution and the rebellion, and the grounds hold the Seibō Memorial Hall for Kitamura Seibō and a hall on the 1991 eruption of Unzen-Fugendake. It is open daily, 9:00–17:30 (last entry 17:00), and a combined ticket for the keep and both halls costs ¥700 for adults and ¥350 for school-age children.

Statue of Amakusa Shiro and the southeast turret in the main bailey of Shimabara Castle
The Amakusa Shirō statue in the main bailey of Shimabara Castle, in front of the southeast turret. There is a certain nerve in putting the rebel leader’s statue inside the castle his followers tried to take, and I rather admire it. Photo: そらみみ, CC BY-SA 4.0.

I think the castle is worth an hour for the Christian floor and the view from the top, less for the concrete keep itself. Afterwards, walk over to Kōtō-ji, a short way from the castle, the temple Matsukura Shigemasa founded, which holds his grave and his statue and, in the grounds, a large reclining Buddha. It is the one place on the peninsula where the man who started all this is remembered with incense.

Reclining Buddha statue at Koto-ji temple in Shimabara, Nagasaki
The reclining Buddha at Kōtō-ji, 8.6 metres long and said to be the largest of its kind in reinforced concrete in Japan. It is modern and slightly startling, and it lies a few steps from the grave of the lord who sent Christians to the hot springs. Photo: sk01, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Unzen Jigoku

Unzen is under an hour by bus from Shimabara and makes an easy half-day. The Jigoku, the steaming field of vents in the middle of the hot-spring town, is free to walk, and a memorial by the path remembers the Christians tortured there under Shigemasa. Go early, before the tour buses, when the steam hangs over the boardwalks and the place still looks a little like its name.

Amakusa Christian Museum and the Senninzuka, Hondo

The Amakusa Christian Museum in Hondo, the main town of Amakusa, is where you see the banner from the top of this article, though the original Important Cultural Property is fragile and only shown for limited periods, with a replica the rest of the time. Around it are about 160 pieces arranged in four zones, from the arrival of the Jesuits through the rebellion to the hidden Christians: fumi-e, a Maria Kannon, hidden crosses and a replica of the Shimabara Jinzu screen. It opens 8:30–17:00 (last entry 16:30), closed Tuesdays (the next weekday if Tuesday is a holiday) and 30 December to 1 January; admission is ¥300 for adults, ¥200 for high-school students and ¥150 for children.

Exterior of the Amakusa Christian Museum in Amakusa, Kumamoto
The Amakusa Christian Museum at Funenoo-machi in Hondo, on the edge of Junkyō Park. If the original banner matters to you, check the display dates before you travel; Amakusa is a long way to come for a replica. Photo: Ippukucho, CC BY 3.0.

Right beside the museum, Junkyō Park (“Martyrs’ Park”) covers the site of Hondo Castle and has a Christian cemetery and the Senninzuka, the “thousand-person mound”, over the dead of the battle of Hondo in 1637. Amakusa Airport is about ten minutes away by taxi, and Kyushu Sanko express buses run from Kumamoto to the Hondo bus centre in roughly two and a half hours.

Senninzuka memorial mound to the dead of the rebellion in Funenoo, Amakusa
The Senninzuka at Hondo, the grassed mound over the dead of the fighting at Hondo in 1637. Flowers are usually fresh, which tells you this is not only a tourist site. Photo: JoshBerglund19, CC BY 2.0.

Amakusa Shirō Museum, Ōyano

On Ōyano island, just across the first of the Amakusa Five Bridges from Misumi, the Amakusa Shirō Museum (renamed from the Amakusa Shirō Memorial Hall in 2018) is built around Shirō himself. It is a modern exhibition hall rather than a collection of relics, and among other things it displays a copy of the Shirō hattosho, a decree issued inside Hara Castle in his name on the first day of the second month of 1638 telling the defenders that their service was a response to God’s mercy and warning them not to desert.

Amakusa Shiro Museum, formerly Amakusa Shiro Memorial Hall, in Oyano, Kami-Amakusa
The Amakusa Shirō Museum in Ōyano, next to the Sanpāru roadside station. The church-like building is entirely modern; Shirō never saw anything like it, but the islands he came from are visible from the car park. Photo: STA3816, CC BY-SA 3.0.

It opens 9:00–17:00 (last entry 16:20), and admission is ¥600 for adults and ¥300 for junior-high age and under. The Kyushu Sanko “Amakusa” bus from Kumamoto stops at Sanpāru, a three-minute walk away. If you only have time for one museum on Amakusa, I would choose Hondo; if you are travelling with children, Ōyano.

Tomioka

At the far northwestern tip of Amakusa, in Reihoku, the ruins of Tomioka Castle sit on a hill over a sandspit, with a rebuilt gate and turret housing a small visitor centre. Below, at the edge of the sea, stands the Tomioka Kirishitan Kuyōhi, a memorial raised by Suzuki Shigenari in 1647. I could not confirm current opening times for the visitor centre, so check with the town before you go.

Tomioka Christian memorial stone erected in 1647 at Reihoku, Amakusa
The Tomioka memorial, a natural andesite slab 1.92 metres tall inscribed with a Buddhist dedication by Suzuki Shigenari in 1647, on the spot where the Amakusa rebels gathered before attacking Tomioka, and said to mark a mass grave of executed rebels. A shogunate official raising a Buddhist memorial to the Christians he helped defeat: the gesture is as mixed as everything else in this story. Photo: MChew, CC BY-SA 3.0.

The painter’s banner

Yamada Emonsaku went to Edo with Matsudaira Nobutsuna and lived in his household, and later, by most accounts, earned his keep as an informer against Christians. One story has Nobutsuna ordering him to paint a fire-watchman being executed for smoking on duty, to frighten the rest of the household. Others say that at the end of his life he went back to the faith and died in Nagasaki, or abroad; nobody knows.

I find it hard to judge him, and I am not sure I should. He went into the castle because his village did and because his wife and children were held as hostages, he tried to bargain his way out, and he lost his family for it. If the attribution is right, he also painted the only object from Hara Castle that people still travel to see.

So if you go to Hondo, find out first whether the original banner is on show, and stand in front of it for a minute. Then go across the water to Hara, climb up to the main bailey and look down at the sea the defenders lived on in the last weeks. Somewhere between the two is a painter who survived, and some tens of thousands of people who did not.

Scroll to Top