The valley in Kamakura where the regent Hōjō Tokiyori built Japan’s first full-scale Chinese-style Zen monastery used to be called Jigokudani, Hell Valley, because it was where the town executed people. When the new halls were dedicated in 1253, the abbot was a monk from Sichuan who spoke no Japanese, many of the senior monks were Chinese too, and the daily round of sermons, chanting and kitchen duty ran in the language of Song China. A Japanese monk named Mujū, who knew the place, wrote that walking into Kenchō-ji was like walking into a foreign country.
Hold on to that picture, because nearly everything written about Zen in English points the other way. In 1938 D. T. Suzuki, the man who did more than anyone to carry Zen to the West, published a book arguing that Zen had entered into almost every corner of Japanese culture, from swordsmanship to the tea room. Somewhere in the seven centuries between the Chinese-speaking monastery in Hell Valley and Suzuki’s lecture halls in New York, a foreign school of Buddhism became the thing foreigners think of as the essence of Japan.
I have sat zazen in Kenchō-ji’s abbot’s hall on a Friday afternoon with my knees on fire and a monk in front of me who could not have cared less about the essence of Japan. This is the history in between, from the monks who carried Zen (禅) across the East China Sea to the wartime record its own institutions later apologised for, and the temples where you can still go and sit.

In This Article
- Six centuries of false starts
- Eisai, the Tendai monk who came home with tea
- Dōgen, the nobleman who just sat
- Kamakura, where the abbots spoke Chinese
- The Five Mountains: Zen as a branch of government
- Outside the walls: Daitoku-ji, Myōshin-ji and the line that won
- Ikkyū, the abbot nobody could control
- What actually happens on the cushion
- Ingen’s ship and Hakuin’s one hand
- Gardens, ink and tea: how much of it was Zen?
- Zen and the sword, Zen and the state
- Where to sit, and what to look at, today
- Kenchō-ji, Kamakura
- Engaku-ji, Kamakura
- Jufuku-ji and Jōchi-ji, Kamakura
- Kennin-ji, Kyoto
- Nanzen-ji and Tenryū-ji, Kyoto
- Myōshin-ji and Shunkō-in, Kyoto
- Ryōan-ji and Daitoku-ji, Kyoto
- Manpuku-ji, Uji
- Eihei-ji, Fukui
- Further afield: Hakata, Hara and Ikkyū’s hermitage
Six centuries of false starts
Zen began in China as Chan, a school that traced itself to an Indian monk the Japanese call Daruma and claimed to pass the Buddha’s mind directly from teacher to student, outside the scriptures. By the Song dynasty it was the establishment form of Chinese Buddhism, and two of its lineages mattered most: the Linji, which the Japanese pronounce Rinzai, and the Caodong, which they pronounce Sōtō. The Song court had also ranked the greatest Chan monasteries into an official hierarchy of Five Mountains, which Japan would later copy.
Meditation itself reached Japan long before the school did. The monk Dōshō is credited with a meditation hall at Gangō-ji in Nara in the 7th century, and a Chinese monk called Daoxuan, who came over in 736, taught the teacher of Saichō, who folded a Chan strand into the curriculum of his monastery on Mount Hiei, Enryaku-ji. None of them founded a Zen school, because none of them was trying to.
The nearest miss was in the 9th century. The empress dowager Tachibana no Kachiko invited a Chan monk named Yikong (Gikū in Japanese) to teach at her temple, Danrin-ji, on the western edge of the capital. According to a later record he found so little interest in Heian Kyoto that he sailed home after a few years. Five hundred years later a shogun built a great Zen monastery on the ruins of Danrin-ji, so the empress got her Zen temple in the end.
Stranger still was the first Japanese to try founding a Zen school on his own, Dainichibō Nōnin, a Tendai monk who taught himself from books, gathered a following near Osaka that he called the Daruma school, and was mocked for having no teacher to vouch for him. So in 1189 he sent two disciples to China with a letter, and the master Zhuo’an Deguang, apparently touched, sent back a portrait of Daruma and a certificate. Enlightenment by post did wonders for his standing, but in 1194 the court banned his teaching anyway. Sources variously say he was murdered by his own nephew or died of illness, and Japanese scholars now lean towards the second.
Eisai, the Tendai monk who came home with tea
The man usually credited with bringing Rinzai Zen to Japan never stopped thinking of himself as a monk of Mount Hiei. Myōan Eisai (明菴栄西, the name is also read Yōsai) was born in Bitchū, the modern Okayama, in 1141, the great-grandson of a shrine priest, and was ordained on Hiei at fourteen. His first trip to China, in 1168, was spent mainly collecting Tendai texts. On his second, from 1187, the Song authorities refused him a permit to go on to India, so he trained under the Chan master Xu’an Huaichang on Mount Tiantai and at Tiantong, near Ningbo.

In 1191 Huaichang gave him the seal of transmission in the Huanglong branch of the Rinzai line, and he came home through Kyushu, founding temples around Hakata and planting tea seeds he had brought from China on the slopes of Sefuri. My piece on the Japanese tea ceremony covers what those seeds became. The detail I enjoy is that, according to the shogunate’s chronicle, Eisai sent the shogun Minamoto no Sanetomo a bowl of tea and his tea treatise, the Kissa yōjōki, when Sanetomo was in bed with a hangover in the second month of 1214. Sanetomo was reportedly delighted.
The teaching did not travel as easily as the tea. In 1194 the monks of Hiei and of Kōfuku-ji in Nara persuaded the court to ban the new Zen movements, Eisai’s and Nōnin’s alike. Eisai answered in 1198 with a long treatise, the Kōzen gokokuron (興禅護国論), “Promoting Zen to protect the nation”, which argued that Zen discipline was the root of all Buddhism, that Saichō himself had taught it, and that a state which honoured monks who kept the precepts would be guarded by the heavens. He also took care to call Nōnin a fraud whose sitting was all posture.

Kyoto was hostile, so Eisai went to Kamakura, where the new warrior government was looking for clergy of its own. In 1200 he led the first-anniversary rites for Minamoto no Yoritomo, and Yoritomo’s widow Hōjō Masako built Jufuku-ji for him. Two years later the second shogun, Minamoto no Yoriie, gave him land in Kyoto for Kennin-ji, founded in 1202 and named after the era. It taught Zen, Tendai and Shingon ritual side by side, exactly what you would expect from a man trying not to provoke Hiei.
In 1206 he became chief fund-raiser for the rebuilding of Tōdai-ji, burned in the Genpei War, which shows how far the establishment had come round to him. He died on the 5th day of the seventh month of 1215; sources long disagreed over whether in Kamakura or Kyoto, until a note on the back of a monastic diary settled it for Kennin-ji. My own view is that Eisai was a Tendai reformer who saw Zen as a cure for a tired establishment.
Dōgen, the nobleman who just sat
The second founder was a very different man. Dōgen (道元) was born in Kyoto on the 2nd day of the first month of 1200 into the Koga, a branch of the Minamoto who served at court, and Japanese scholars still argue over which of two Koga nobles was his father. Orphaned young, he took the tonsure on Hiei at thirteen and, the biographies say, came down troubled by a question: if all beings already have the Buddha nature, why practise? In 1217 he joined Eisai’s disciple Myōzen at Kennin-ji.

In 1223 master and pupil sailed for China together. My favourite thing Dōgen wrote is about his first weeks there. An elderly monastery cook came aboard his moored ship to buy Japanese mushrooms, and when Dōgen asked why a senior monk wasted himself on kitchen work instead of meditation, the cook laughed and said the young man did not yet understand what practice was.
Myōzen died in China in 1225. That same year Dōgen found his teacher, Rujing, abbot of Tiantong in the Caodong line, who insisted on long hours of seated meditation and nothing else. One night, the story goes, Rujing scolded a dozing monk with the words that body and mind must drop away, and Dōgen, sitting nearby, understood. He came home in 1227 with Myōzen’s ashes and a single conviction: that shikantaza (只管打坐), “just sitting”, was not a means to enlightenment but the enlightened act itself.

His first temple, Kōshō-ji at Fukakusa south of Kyoto, opened in 1233 and filled with students who alarmed Hiei, including in 1241 a whole band of Nōnin’s old followers. In 1243 he accepted a warrior patron’s invitation to move to the mountains of Echizen, the modern Fukui. The temple he founded there in 1244 as Daibutsu-ji was renamed Eihei-ji, “temple of eternal peace”, in 1246. He went to Kamakura for about half a year at the invitation of Hōjō Tokiyori, came back, and died in Kyoto on the 28th day of the eighth month of 1253.

Dōgen disliked being called the founder of a “Zen school”; he thought he was teaching the Buddha’s way, full stop. His Shōbōgenzō was little read outside his order until the philosopher Watsuji Tetsurō wrote about him in 1926. What made Sōtō large was a later abbot, Keizan, who founded Sōji-ji on the Noto peninsula in 1321 and adapted the order to rural patrons with funerals, memorial rites and local gods. Sōtō is now the biggest Zen denomination by far, with about 14,400 temples in the Agency for Cultural Affairs’ latest yearbook against some 5,600 for all the Rinzai branches together.
Kamakura, where the abbots spoke Chinese
The patron who made Zen fashionable in Kamakura was Hōjō Tokiyori, regent of the shogunate from 1246, who wanted the real thing straight from China rather than Eisai’s blend. That year a Chinese monk named Lanxi Daolong (蘭渓道隆, Rankei Dōryū in Japanese) arrived in Kyushu with a few disciples, aged thirty-three. Tokiyori brought him to Kamakura and in 1253 dedicated Kenchō-ji, with a monastic code copied from the Song monasteries down to the kitchen. The warrior government that paid for it is in my overview of the Kamakura era.


Lanxi was a disciplinarian who thought monks should sit, not write poems. When the Mongols began sending envoys, his nationality turned against him: suspected of spying for the Yuan, he was sent away to Kai province before being allowed back, and he died at Kenchō-ji in 1278.

His successor came out of a war zone. Wuxue Zuyuan (無学祖元, Mugaku Sogen) had been sheltering at a monastery in the Yandang mountains in 1275 when Mongol soldiers broke in and found him sitting in the hall. According to his own disciples he recited a verse, roughly: “Heaven and earth have no place to plant a single staff; how good to know that man and things are empty; I treasure the three-foot sword of the great Yuan, which cuts the spring wind in a flash of lightning.” The soldiers, the story says, left him alone.
In 1279 Tokiyori’s son Hōjō Tokimune, who had already turned away one Mongol fleet and was waiting for the next, sent to China for a new abbot, and Wuxue came. He took over Kenchō-ji, taught warriors with a patience the Japanese called “grandmother Zen”, and before the second invasion in 1281, according to Engaku-ji’s tradition, wrote out for Tokimune a piece of advice three characters long: do not fret. The Mongol invasions failed, and the chroniclers credited the gods and the winds.

In 1282 Tokimune founded Engaku-ji in the hills just north of Kenchō-ji to pray for the dead of the invasions, and made Wuxue its first abbot. He died in 1286. His disciple Kōhō Kennichi, a son of the emperor Go-Saga, trained the monk who would dominate the next century, and another disciple, Mugai Nyodai, became one of the first Japanese women recognised as a Zen teacher. Tokimune’s widow founded the convent of Tōkei-ji nearby, later famous as a refuge where a wife could escape a marriage; women in warrior households are the subject of my piece on samurai women.
The Five Mountains: Zen as a branch of government
By the end of the 13th century the Hōjō had begun ranking their Zen monasteries in imitation of the Song system, though nobody agrees on exactly when. One Japanese encyclopedia dates the first use of the term to 1253, when Kenchō-ji was called “first of the Five Mountains”; another tradition points to an order of 1299 raising Jōchi-ji to the rank. When the Kamakura shogunate fell in 1333, Emperor Go-Daigo drew up his own list, and then the Ashikaga shoguns, who overthrew him, drew up theirs.
The final form came in 1386 under Ashikaga Yoshimitsu, with Nanzen-ji set “above the Five Mountains” in a class of its own. Below it came five in Kyoto, Tenryū-ji, Shōkoku-ji, Kennin-ji, Tōfuku-ji and Manju-ji, and five in Kamakura, Kenchō-ji, Engaku-ji, Jufuku-ji, Jōchi-ji and Jōmyō-ji. Below them came ten second-rank monasteries and a long tail of provincial houses, and there was even a parallel ranking of convents.
The point of the system was control. The shogun appointed the abbots by letter, a shogunal office at Shōkoku-ji kept the registers, and by the 15th century the letters of appointment had become a source of income, with some monks paying for a title they never took up in person. In return the monks gave a warrior government what it lacked: men who could write classical Chinese, draft letters to the Ming emperor, manage trading voyages and bury the ruling house. The Muromachi era was run, to a surprising extent, by its monasteries’ graduates.
The man who built this world was Musō Soseki (夢窓疎石), born in Ise in 1275. As a young monk he failed to get his seal from the Chinese master Yishan Yining because, the story goes, he could not follow the old man’s Chinese. He took it in 1305 from Kōhō Kennichi instead, and spent twenty years running from patrons into mountain hermitages, which only made the patrons keener.

Go-Daigo summoned him to Nanzen-ji; when Ashikaga Takauji drove Go-Daigo from Kyoto, Musō simply became Takauji’s teacher, and when Go-Daigo died in exile in 1339 Musō persuaded the shogun to build a monastery for the soul of the emperor he had betrayed. That monastery was Tenryū-ji, on the site of the old Danrin-ji, and when its building money ran short Musō helped arrange a trading ship to Yuan China in 1342 to pay for it. Takauji’s side is in my piece on Ashikaga Takauji; Musō’s is that a holy man can serve every master and stay holy, which is either wisdom or a very good career plan.
The Five Mountains also became Japan’s academy of Chinese learning. Lanxi had disapproved of monks who wrote verse, but by the late 14th century poets such as Gidō Shūshin and Zekkai Chūshin were writing Chinese good enough to impress the Ming court, and the monasteries printed their own editions of Song and Yuan books. At Shōkoku-ji, Yoshimitsu’s own monastery next to his palace, a line of painter-monks turned the Chinese ink style into a Japanese one.

The greatest of them left. Sesshū Tōyō trained at Shōkoku-ji, moved west to Yamaguchi under the Ōuchi lords, sailed to Ming China in 1467 and came back convinced that no Chinese painter could teach him what the mountains had. He was a Zen monk all his life, and I doubt he thought of his paintings as Zen art.

The system began to break with the Ōnin War of 1467, which burned most of the Kyoto monasteries, and it never really recovered. The shoguns’ Zen lived on in the villas of retired rulers: Kinkaku-ji and Ginkaku-ji are both, to this day, sub-temples of Shōkoku-ji. But by 1500 the energy had moved outside the walls.
Outside the walls: Daitoku-ji, Myōshin-ji and the line that won
The monasteries that refused the shogun’s ranking were called rinka (林下), “beneath the forest”, as opposed to the official sōrin, “the grove”. Their line began with Nanpo Shōmyō, who trained at Kenchō-ji, went to China in 1259 and came back in 1267 with the seal of a demanding master named Xutang Zhiyu. His student Shūhō Myōchō (宗峰妙超), known by his title Daitō Kokushi, is the hero of one of Zen’s best-loved stories.

Daitō founded Daitoku-ji in the north of Kyoto with the support of the retired emperor Hanazono and of Go-Daigo, who placed it at the very top of his Five Mountains. That was the trouble. When the Ashikaga won, a monastery so closely tied to the defeated emperor was dropped down the list, and in the 15th century Daitoku-ji left the system altogether. Daitō’s own disciple Kanzan Egen founded Myōshin-ji on the site of Hanazono’s detached palace, and his Zen was harsher still: no literature, no politics, sitting and kōans.

Japanese Zen calls this line “Ō-Tō-Kan” after the three masters’ titles, and history went its way. After the Ōnin War the rinka monasteries took money from Sakai merchants and provincial warlords, and a daimyo who wanted a memorial temple in Kyoto built a sub-temple at one of them. Daitoku-ji alone has Kōtō-in, founded by Hosokawa Tadaoki, and Sōken-in, built by Hideyoshi for Oda Nobunaga‘s funeral. Every living Rinzai lineage in Japan now descends through Ō-Tō-Kan, and the Five Mountains survive mainly as beautiful buildings.
Ikkyū, the abbot nobody could control
The most famous Daitoku-ji monk of them all spent most of his life refusing to live there. Ikkyū Sōjun (一休宗純) was born in Kyoto in 1394, and the story that his father was Emperor Go-Komatsu, by a lady of the court sent away before the birth, is old and well documented. Some Japanese reference works treat it as all but settled; others are more cautious.
He entered a Five Mountains temple as a child and walked out as a teenager, disgusted by monks fawning on power. When his first master died in 1414 he tried to drown himself in the river below Ishiyama-dera and was stopped by a man his mother had sent to watch him. His next teacher, Kasō Sōdon, lived in poverty at Katata on Lake Biwa and named him Ikkyū, “one pause”, after a verse about resting between this world and the next. One night in 1420, sitting in a boat on the lake, he heard a crow caw and was enlightened.

Kasō offered him a certificate of enlightenment, and Ikkyū refused it. Then he spent half a century behaving badly on principle, walking Kyoto with a wooden sword in a red scabbard (the monks of his day, he said, were like it: impressive sheathed, useless drawn) and carrying a skull on a pole through the New Year crowds. He drank, ate fish, visited brothels and wrote poems about all of it in his collection Kyōunshū, “Crazy cloud”.

He was also vicious about his own colleagues. His fellow disciple Yōsō Sōi, abbot of Daitoku-ji, made the temple prosperous by teaching merchants, and Ikkyū wrote a book of verses, the Jikaishū, accusing him of selling enlightenment like cloth. In about 1470, in his late seventies, he met Mori, a blind singer, at Sumiyoshi in Osaka, and lived with her until his death. In 1474 the emperor made him abbot of Daitoku-ji, the temple he had spent his life attacking, and he rebuilt it after the Ōnin War without ever living there.
He died at his hermitage, Shūon-an, south of Kyoto, on the 21st day of the eleventh month of 1481, aged eighty-seven, and his last words are said to have been “I don’t want to die”. Edo-period joke-books turned him into a clever child-monk, and a 1970s cartoon series made that little boy famous. The real Ikkyū would have written a poem about hating it.
What actually happens on the cushion
Strip away the anecdotes and Zen practice is plain and physical. You sit on a round cushion with your legs crossed in full or half lotus, back straight, hands in your lap in an oval with the thumbs touching, eyes half open and lowered. A period lasts as long as a stick of incense, forty minutes to an hour, and between periods you walk slowly round the hall, kinhin, to stop your legs dying.

The two main schools sit differently. In a Rinzai hall the monks sit on raised platforms facing each other across the room; in a Sōtō hall they face the wall, as Daruma is said to have done for nine years. Rinzai beginners are often told to count breaths to ten and start again; Sōtō teachers tell you to let thoughts come and go without chasing them, which sounds easier and is not. Dōgen liked the old Chinese story of a master who polished a tile and said he was making a mirror: sitting in order to become a Buddha misses the point.
Rinzai adds the kōan (公案), a word that first meant a public case in a Chinese law court and in Zen means an exchange from the records of the old masters set to a student as a problem, such as “Does a dog have Buddha nature? No.” Tradition counts 1,700 of them. The student takes his answer to a private interview with the teacher, sanzen or dokusan, and is usually dismissed with a ring of the bell within seconds.

Life in a training monastery is built round this sitting. The trainees, unsui or “clouds and water”, rise around 3:30 or 4:00, chant, sit, eat rice gruel in silence with a fixed ritual of bowls, clean the buildings, go out on alms rounds in straw hats, and sit again. The hardest week of the year is rōhatsu, the first eight days of the twelfth month, when Rinzai monks sit almost without sleep to commemorate the Buddha’s enlightenment. This is a small world, though: most of Japan’s twenty thousand Zen temples are parish temples run by married priests whose working life is funerals, and most of their parishioners have never sat zazen.
Ingen’s ship and Hakuin’s one hand
Under the Tokugawa shogunate, after the ban on Christianity, every household had to register with a Buddhist temple, which turned temples into parish registries and funerals into their bread and butter. The Daitoku-ji abbot Takuan Sōhō was exiled to the far north in 1629 for protesting when the shogunate overrode the emperor’s right to grant purple robes to Zen abbots.
Then, in the middle of the closed-country period, a boatload of Chinese monks arrived. Nagasaki’s Chinese merchants wanted a famous abbot from home, and after four invitations the Ming master Yinyuan Longqi (隠元隆琦, Ingen Ryūki) agreed to come. He landed at Nagasaki on the night of the 5th day of the seventh month of 1654, in his early sixties, with more than twenty disciples, on a ship provided by the Ming loyalist Zheng Chenggong.

Some Japanese monks flocked to him; others thought his Ming-style Zen, which mixed in the chanting of Amida’s name, was not Zen at all. The wary shogunate confined him to a temple near Osaka with two hundred followers at most. But in 1658 he met the shogun Tokugawa Ietsuna, and in 1661 he was given land at Uji, south of Kyoto, where he built a new monastery in pure Ming style and gave it the name of his old one in Fujian, Ōbaku-san Manpuku-ji. He never went home.

Ōbaku chants its sutras to this day in a version of Ming-dynasty Chinese, and Manpuku-ji still looks more like a temple in Fujian than anything else in Japan. It also brought the vegetarian fucha ryōri eaten Chinese-style at a shared table, the habit of brewing loose-leaf sencha, and, if you believe the name, the green beans the Japanese call ingen-mame. Its real effect was to shame the older schools into reform; it became a separate school only in 1876.
The reformer who counts most came from a post town on the Tōkaidō. Hakuin Ekaku (白隠慧鶴) was born at Hara, at the foot of Mount Fuji, in the twelfth month of 1685 by the Japanese calendar, which fell in January 1686 by the Western one. Terrified as a boy by a sermon on the hells, he took the tonsure at fifteen at the local temple, Shōin-ji, and went on the road. In 1708 in Echigo, working on the kōan of the dog, he had his first breakthrough and decided that no one in three hundred years had understood as much.

His next teacher, a hermit called Shōju Rōjin in the mountains of Shinano, called him a “cave-dwelling devil”, threw him off a veranda and set about showing him how little he knew; the decisive moment came, Hakuin said, when an old woman beat him with a broom in the village street. He then worked himself into “Zen sickness”, a physical and nervous collapse, and cured it, he said, with a visualisation taught him by a hermit named Hakuyūshi outside Kyoto: a lump of butter imagined melting slowly down through the body. Historians are unsure whether Hakuyūshi existed, but the method is still taught.
In 1716 he came home to Shōin-ji, which had fallen into ruin, and stayed there for most of the rest of his life. He reorganised the kōans into a graded curriculum, put at its entrance a new one of his own, “Two hands clap and there is a sound; what is the sound of one hand?”, wrote a song in praise of zazen that Rinzai monks still chant, and painted. Estimates of the number of his brush paintings run to ten thousand or more, nearly all given away to farmers and townspeople. The local saying was that Suruga had two things too good for it: Mount Fuji and Hakuin of Hara.

Every Rinzai lineage in Japan today runs through Hakuin and his heirs, and his kōan system is the one the training halls use. He died at Shōin-ji in the twelfth month of 1768, again January 1769 by the Western calendar. If you want a single person who turned medieval Chinese Zen into something Japanese, I would pick him over anyone in the Five Mountains.
Gardens, ink and tea: how much of it was Zen?
Abroad, “Zen” sells raked gravel, ink circles and green tea. The connections are real but looser and later than the gift shops suggest. The strongest case is Musō Soseki, who remodelled the gardens of Saihō-ji in 1339 and laid out the pond garden of Tenryū-ji; those are Zen gardens in the plain sense that a Zen master made them for a Zen monastery.

The dry gardens of sand and stone, karesansui, are trickier. The early ones, like Daisen-in’s at Daitoku-ji, belong to the age when riverbank outcaste gardeners were working for the shoguns at Ginkaku-ji. Ryōan-ji shows how little anyone knows: the temple dates its garden to about 1499, the earliest description, from the 1680s, mentions nine stones rather than fifteen, and two workmen’s names, Kotarō and a second ending in -jirō, are carved on one rock.
The Dutch garden historian Wybe Kuitert argues that reading these gardens as Zen philosophy is largely a modern habit. I agree, and I still think the Ryōan-ji veranda is the best place in Kyoto to sit for twenty minutes; the wider story is in Japanese gardens.
Ink painting was a Five Mountains art, but also a Chinese literati art and a professional trade. Tea came into the monasteries with Eisai and passed to merchants and warriors through Daitoku-ji, where Murata Jukō is said to have studied with Ikkyū (the connection is shaky) and where Sen no Rikyū trained, gave money and was eventually immortalised in a statue that cost him his life. Tea was never exclusively Zen, and some of its masters were merchants first and monks hardly at all.
The Noh theatre is the cautionary tale. It grew out of shrine and temple performance, not out of Zen, and the treatises of its great theorist Zeami are about acting and audiences, not kōans. Zeami does appear late in life in the records of a Sōtō temple in Nara as a lay patron with a Zen name, but his yūgen, mystery and depth, was the common property of his age. “Zen influence” is often a way of saying “Muromachi influence” with more incense.
Zen and the sword, Zen and the state
The warrior connection is older than the myth, and smaller. The Hōjō regents did patronise Zen, but they patronised the esoteric schools too, many warriors were devout Pure Land believers, and no single creed governed the class. The famous texts tying Zen to swordsmanship come from the peaceful 17th century.

The key one is the Fudōchi shinmyōroku (不動智神妙録), “The mysterious record of immovable wisdom”, which Takuan wrote for the shogun’s sword instructor Yagyū Munenori. It argues that a mind which stops on anything, the opponent’s blade, your own fear, your own technique, is a mind that will be cut, and that the swordsman needs the unattached mind of Zen. It is brilliant advice from one cultivated man to another in an age of peace.
How the samurai code itself was invented is in my piece on bushidō, and the swordsman most quoted on mind and blade, Miyamoto Musashi, drew his own conclusions.
The modern story begins in disaster. The Meiji Restoration separated Buddhism from Shinto by decree in 1868, a wave of anti-Buddhist violence followed, temple lands were confiscated, and in 1872 the government told monks they were free to eat meat and marry, which most of them eventually did. At Engaku-ji the abbot Imakita Kōsen opened kōan practice to educated laymen, and his successor Shaku Sōen spoke at the World’s Parliament of Religions in Chicago in 1893, in an English translation prepared by one of his lay students, Suzuki Teitarō.

Suzuki went to America in 1897 to work for a publisher in Illinois, came back in 1909, and spent the rest of a very long life explaining Zen in English, as D. T. Suzuki. His Zen Buddhism and its Influence on Japanese Culture of 1938, revised in 1959 as Zen and Japanese Culture, gave the samurai and the sword whole chapters and presented Zen as the hidden source of Japanese art and character. In the 1950s he taught at Columbia and was written up in Vogue and Time. Eugen Herrigel’s Zen in the Art of Archery of 1948 did the same for the bow, though the historian Yamada Shōji later showed that Herrigel’s teacher, Awa Kenzō, ran his own idiosyncratic school with little Zen in it.

Then there is the war. In 1997 Brian Victoria, an American who had trained as a Sōtō priest, published Zen at War, drawing on the earlier work of the Rinzai priest and scholar Ichikawa Hakugen, who had himself supported the war and spent his later career examining why. It quoted Zen masters of the 1930s and 1940s presenting killing on orders as enlightened selflessness; the most notorious, Harada Sogaku, called marching and shooting at command the manifestation of the highest wisdom. Robert Sharf had already argued in 1993 that the Zen Suzuki sold to the West was shaped by Japanese nationalism, and in 2012 Victoria published newspaper articles of 1936 in which Suzuki sounded sympathetic to Hitler’s Germany.
The defence has been vigorous. Kemmyō Taira Satō, a former student of Suzuki’s, argued in 2008 that wherever Suzuki wrote directly about politics he opposed militarism, Kirita Kiyohide has made the same case from his letters, and others have found mistranslations in Victoria’s sources. The institutions did not wait for the scholars. The Sōtō order issued a formal statement of repentance for its wartime conduct in 1992, and after Victoria’s book letters of regret came from the head of the lay Sanbō Kyōdan, from a priest writing for the whole Tenryū-ji branch, and from the Myōshin-ji branch.
My own view is that the scholars are arguing about Suzuki while the record of the temples is not seriously disputed. Zen institutions in Japan between 1868 and 1945 did what nearly every religious body in the country did: they raised money for warplanes, sent chaplains, and supplied a vocabulary of selflessness that suited a state demanding self-sacrifice. What was peculiar to Zen was the export. A teaching that had arrived in Kamakura in Chinese went back out into the world in English as the soul of Japan, at the precise moment when Japan most wanted a soul to sell.
Where to sit, and what to look at, today
The best way to understand Zen in Japan is the least glamorous: go to a temple, sit on a cushion and do what you are told. Wear loose dark clothes, arrive early, switch off your phone and do not talk in the hall; bow with your hands together when you enter and when you sit. If you cannot manage cross-legged, say so at the door and you will usually be offered a stool. Nobody is impressed by suffering in silence.
Hours, prices and session times below come from the temples’ own sites; sessions are cancelled for ceremonies more often than you would think, so check the week you go. The long view of all the periods above is in Japan through the ages.
Kenchō-ji, Kamakura
The first of the Kamakura Five Mountains opens daily from 8:30 to 16:30, and admission is ¥500 for adults, cash only. Its public zazen session runs every Friday and Saturday from 15:30 to 16:30, usually in the Hōjō, the abbot’s hall; there is no booking and no fee beyond admission, but you must be in your place fifteen minutes before the start, and latecomers are turned away. Twice a year, normally on the first weekend of June and of December, there is a two-day retreat, announced about a month ahead on the temple’s site, which also has a page in English.
From Kita-Kamakura Station on the JR Yokosuka Line it is about fifteen minutes on foot along the main road, or five minutes on the bus towards Kamakura Station. Look for the 1255 bell, then walk the axis to the Hōjō and the pond garden behind it.
Engaku-ji, Kamakura
Engaku-ji’s main gate is a one-minute walk from Kita-Kamakura Station, and the temple opens from 8:30 to 16:30 (to 16:00 from December to February), with admission at ¥500. The dawn session in the Buddha hall starts at 6:00 every day except the 1st and 15th of the month and the New Year and early-October closures; meet beside the hall by 5:50, no booking, a donation in the box, and no groups. On every Saturday and on the first and third Sundays there is a session at the lay practice hall, the Kojirin, from 14:30 to 16:00 for ¥1,000 plus admission, and a booked beginners’ evening on the second Wednesday from 19:00.

On the second and fourth Sundays the abbot or another senior priest gives a sermon in the great hall at 9:30, followed by zazen at 11:00 for the first eighty people through the door. The novelist Natsume Sōseki sat here over the New Year of 1895 and put the experience, unflatteringly, into his novel The Gate.
Jufuku-ji and Jōchi-ji, Kamakura
Two of the other Kamakura Five Mountains are a short walk away and much quieter. Jufuku-ji, Masako’s foundation for Eisai, keeps its buildings closed, but the stone-paved approach under the trees is open, and in the hillside caves of the cemetery behind are the graves traditionally said to be those of Masako and her son Sanetomo. Jōchi-ji, a few minutes’ walk from Kita-Kamakura Station, has a Chinese-style bell gate and a small grotto with a stone figure of Hotei, the fat god of good fortune, whose belly people rub for luck.

Kennin-ji, Kyoto
Kyoto’s oldest Zen temple sits at the bottom of Gion, seven minutes on foot from Gion-Shijō Station on the Keihan Line. It opens from 10:00 to 17:00 (last entry 16:30), and admission is ¥800. The monthly sitting, called the Senkō-kai after Eisai’s posthumous title, takes place on the second Sunday from 7:30 to about 9:30: two twenty-minute periods, sutra chanting and usually a talk from the abbot, free and without booking, though not in August. In July there are three days of dawn sittings starting at 6:30.

Nanzen-ji and Tenryū-ji, Kyoto
The temple ranked above the Five Mountains sits at the foot of the eastern hills, a short walk from Keage Station on the Tōzai subway line. It opens from 8:40 to 17:00 from March to November and to 16:30 from December to February, and you pay separately for the abbot’s hall garden (¥600) and for the climb up the great gate (¥600). The brick aqueduct of 1890 through the precinct is an unlikely and rather fine neighbour.

Tenryū-ji, Musō’s monastery for Go-Daigo, is a thirteen-minute walk from Saga-Arashiyama Station. The garden, which is the reason to come, opens from 8:30 to 17:00 for ¥500, and the abbot’s buildings cost ¥300 more. The cloud dragon painted on the lecture hall ceiling by Kayama Matazō is shown separately, mostly at weekends, for another ¥500. Come at opening time; by mid-morning the Arashiyama crowds arrive.

Myōshin-ji and Shunkō-in, Kyoto
Myōshin-ji’s lanes are open at all hours. The lecture hall, with its ceiling dragon by Kanō Tan’yū and a bronze bell cast in 698 that is the oldest dated bell in Japan, opens from 9:00 to 16:00 for ¥500, cash only. The headquarters runs regular sittings for the public, booked online, at ¥2,000 the first time and ¥1,000 after, in Japanese only.
For sitting in English, the place is Shunkō-in, a sub-temple founded in 1590 by Horio Yoshiharu, later the first lord of Matsue. The philosopher Hisamatsu Shin’ichi lived here during and after the war and talked Zen with D. T. Suzuki in its rooms, and the temple keeps a bronze bell from the Jesuit church in Kyoto, cast in 1577, which belongs to the story of Christianity in Japan. Its programmes are run in English by the vice-abbot and must be booked through the temple’s site; for the regular sitting you must first join at least two of its online sessions, and fees are shown when you book.

Ryōan-ji and Daitoku-ji, Kyoto
Ryōan-ji opens from 8:00 to 17:00 from March to November and 8:30 to 16:30 from December to February, and admission is ¥600. It is seven minutes on foot from Ryōanji Station on the little Keifuku Kitano Line, which is the pleasantest way to arrive. Go at 8:00, sit at the end of the veranda and try counting the stones. Then find the water basin behind the abbot’s hall whose four characters share a central square to read “I only know contentment”; the one by the path is a copy.

Daitoku-ji, in the north of the city near Kitaōji Station, is the Rinzai monastery for tea people, and I have written about its gates and sub-temples in my piece on the tea ceremony. For this story, find Daisen-in for its early dry garden, and look out for the special openings of Shinju-an, the sub-temple founded in Ikkyū’s memory, which holds his portraits and is open only a few days a year.
Manpuku-ji, Uji
Ingen’s monastery is five minutes from Ōbaku Station on either the JR Nara Line or the Keihan Uji Line, and opens from 9:00 to 17:00 (last entry 16:30) for ¥500. It is the one complete Ming-style Chinese monastery in Japan, with a laughing Maitreya in the gate hall and the wooden fish in the corridor. The fucha meal is served by reservation and is worth booking.

Eihei-ji, Fukui
Dōgen’s monastery sits in a cedar valley about thirty minutes by the direct Eiheiji Liner bus from Fukui Station; the slower route is the Echizen Railway to Eiheiji-guchi and a Keifuku bus up the valley. It opens from 8:30 to 16:30 (arrive by 16:00) and admission is ¥700. It is a working monastery, and you follow a set route through the halls in your socks while the monks go about their business around you.

You can sit with the monastery three times a day, at 10:00, 13:30 and 15:30, without booking; sign up at the reception at least five minutes before, and allow about fifty minutes. A donation is asked on top of admission. The overnight stay, the sanrō, runs only on dates the monastery publishes on its site and must be booked in advance: you arrive by 15:00, sit, eat in silence, sleep in a shared room separated by sex, rise at 4:00 for zazen and the morning service, and clean your room before you go. Anyone can also ask the day before to attend the morning service, for which the monastery suggests an incense offering of about ¥1,000.
Further afield: Hakata, Hara and Ikkyū’s hermitage
In Hakata, Shōfuku-ji is three minutes from Gion Station on the Fukuoka subway’s Airport Line; the grounds are free to walk, though the training halls are closed. At Hara, near Numazu, Shōin-ji is five minutes from Hara Station on the JR Tōkaidō Line, a small working temple where Hakuin is buried and where some of his paintings are kept; the town has marked a “Hakuin path” from the station.

Ikkyū’s hermitage, Shūon-an, usually called Ikkyū-ji, is in Kyōtanabe between Kyoto and Nara, reached by Keihan bus from Shin-Tanabe Station on the Kintetsu Kyoto Line. It opens from 9:00 to 17:00 for ¥600 and has a dry garden, a wooden statue of the old man said to carry his own hair, and his grave, kept by the Imperial Household Agency because of who his father may have been, so you pay your respects at the gate.

When I go back to Kenchō-ji, I arrive on a Friday a little after three. The monk who runs the session explains the posture in Japanese, very fast, and the foreigners in the hall who cannot follow watch the people beside them and copy, which is how Lanxi’s Japanese monks learned in a Chinese-speaking hall in Hell Valley in 1253. Sit, lower your eyes and count your breaths to ten, and you are doing exactly what the regent paid a foreigner to teach his warriors seven and a half centuries ago.




