Ginkaku-ji: A Shogun’s Retreat From the Ruins of Kyoto

On the 10th day of the second month of 1489, a party of gardeners sent from Kyoto by the retired shogun arrived at Kōfuku-ji in Nara to look at the temple’s rocks. They did not get far. The scholar monks of the temple, already sore at being told to supply trees and labourers for a villa they would never see, set on the gardeners and chased them all the way back to the capital, and the abbot of Kōfuku-ji’s Daijō-in wrote the whole thing down in his diary.

The retired shogun was Ashikaga Yoshimasa, and his answer, within the fortnight, was to confiscate an estate belonging to the cloister the monks claimed to be acting for. He was fifty-three, he had presided over the destruction of his own capital in the Ōnin War, and he had largely given up on governing. What he had not given up on was the garden. Stones were being prised out of temple grounds across Kyoto for it, monks who served him were complaining about it in private, and the gardeners doing the work belonged to an outcast caste that the same monks regarded as polluted.

That garden, and the two buildings that survive in it, are what you visit today as Ginkaku-ji (銀閣寺), the Temple of the Silver Pavilion, properly Jishō-ji. There is no silver on the pavilion and there never was.

The famous cone of white sand is two centuries younger than Yoshimasa. And the most important thing in the precinct is a room of four and a half mats that you can see only a few weeks a year, which turns out to be the ancestor of almost every Japanese room you have ever sat in. I think it is the best place in Kyoto to understand how a political catastrophe produced a way of living, and this is the story of the shogun who built it, the men who made it, and how to see it without the crowd.

The raked Ginshadan sand garden, the Kogetsudai sand cone and the two-storey Kannon-den (Silver Pavilion) at Ginkaku-ji, Kyoto
The view that greets you once you are through the inner gate: the raked Ginshadan, the flat-topped cone of the Kōgetsudai and, behind them, the Kannon-den, the building everyone calls the Silver Pavilion. The pavilion is from 1489. Both heaps of sand are Edo-period additions, and in Yoshimasa’s day this ground was probably part of the pond.

The shogun who wanted to be somewhere else

Yoshimasa was born on the 2nd day of the first month of 1436, the son of the sixth shogun, Ashikaga Yoshinori, a man so frightening that his contemporaries called him the terror of all the people. When Yoshinori was murdered at a banquet in 1441 and Yoshimasa’s elder brother died two years later, the boy was made head of the house at eight and formally appointed shogun in 1449. The great lords who ran the shogunate had just watched what an energetic shogun could do, and the novelist Nagai Michiko argued that they brought Yoshimasa up “neither to die nor to live”, an ornament rather than a ruler.

Hanging-scroll portrait of the shogun Ashikaga Yoshimasa seated in black court robes, attributed to Tosa Mitsunobu
Yoshimasa in the portrait attributed to Tosa Mitsunobu, the court painter who worked for his household. The folding screen behind him is painted with landscapes in ink, which is to say the shogun chose to be shown surrounded by the art he cared about. It is the nearest thing to a likeness you will find, and it shows a man in his prime who does not look as if he wanted the job.

He tried, at first. In the 1450s he ruled through his own favourites, restored his father’s ceremonies, rebuilt the imperial palace and repaired the shogunate’s finances well enough that historians now rank the early part of his reign with his grandfather Yoshimitsu’s for solvency. Then everything went wrong at once: famine in 1461, a feud inside every great house that supplied his ministers, and a succession muddle of his own making when he adopted his brother Yoshimi as heir in 1464 and his wife Hino Tomiko gave birth to a son the following year. I will not retell what happened next; my piece on the Ōnin War covers the ten years in which Kyoto burned, and how little the quarrel over the heir really had to do with it.

The part of the story that belongs here is how Yoshimasa behaved. In 1465, two years before the war, he was already planning a retirement villa in the eastern hills on the site of a sub-temple of Nanzen-ji, so that he could guide his heir from a distance as his grandfather Yoshimitsu had from his palace at Kitayama. The war cancelled it.

In the twelfth month of 1473 he handed the title of shogun to his eight-year-old son Yoshihisa and kept the real authority, and when the boy grew up and began to sign documents, some historians think the signature was still his father’s. Twice, in 1480 and 1481, Yoshihisa cut off his topknot in protest and threatened to become a monk.

Utagawa Yoshimori woodblock triptych of 1863 showing Ashikaga Yoshimasa's party among cherry blossoms at Yoshino
“Lord Higashiyama Yoshimasa’s Excursion to Yoshino”, a triptych by Utagawa Yoshimori published in the third month of 1863. Yoshimasa never made this trip as shown, and the Edo-period prints that put him among blossoms and banquets were as much about his reputation for idleness as his taste. The title calls him Higashiyama-dono, Lord of the Eastern Hills, the name his villa gave him.

Historians have argued about him ever since. Some Japanese historians are blunt: Momose Kesao called him weak-willed and changeable, and repeated the old report that he was cheerful on sunny days and sullen on cloudy ones. Akamatsu Toshihide was kinder, pointing out that no shogun was ever so hemmed in by the people around him. Donald Keene, who wrote the best book on him in English, subtitled it “The Creation of the Soul of Japan”, and he was not talking about the politics.

Hanging scroll mounting a tanzaku poem slip with a waka on the cherry blossoms of Yoshino written by Ashikaga Yoshimasa
A poem slip in Yoshimasa’s own hand, now in the National Palace Museum in Taipei: a waka on the cherry blossoms of Yoshino in full flower on a windless spring day. About 1,500 of his poems survive, and he compiled a poetry contest against himself. If you want to know why the cherry blossom carries so much weight in Japanese verse, the shoguns of his century are a good part of the answer.

By 1481 he was ready to leave. His relations with Tomiko and with his son had collapsed into open rivalry, and in 1485 the son’s guards and the father’s officials would come to blows. In 1481 he moved out to a mountain lodge at Nagatani in the northern hills, the following year he began to build in the eastern hills, and he never really came back.

Building on his brother’s ashes

The site he chose had a history he cannot have missed. It was the ground of Jōdo-ji, an old Tendai temple at the foot of the hills, and the abbot of Jōdo-ji before the war had been Yoshimasa’s own brother, the monk Gijin, who left his robes in 1464 to become Ashikaga Yoshimi and, three years later, a cause of the war. Jōdo-ji had burned in the fighting. The district east of the river is still called Jōdo-ji on the map.

Ground was broken on the 4th day of the second month of 1482, according to the diary of the courtier Konoe Masaie. English-language accounts sometimes give that date, converted to 21 February 1482, as the start of the Silver Pavilion itself, but it was the start of the whole villa, which the court called Higashiyama-dono; the pavilion was the last building to go up, seven years later. The first hall finished was the shogun’s living quarters, and Yoshimasa moved in on the 27th day of the sixth month of 1483, while the carpenters were still at work around him.

Reconstructed floor plan of the kaisho reception hall of Yoshimasa's Higashiyama-dono villa, showing named rooms, alcoves and shelves
A modern reconstruction of the kaisho, the reception hall where Yoshimasa entertained, which stood in the villa from 1487 and is long gone. Scholars have redrawn its plan at least five times from inventories of its decoration, and every version has named rooms with built-in alcoves, shelves and desk bays. That is the point: this was a house designed around the display of objects. Image: Ktmchi, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The money was harder to find than the land. Kyoto was ruined, the shogunate’s estates were in other people’s hands, and Yoshimasa ordered the provincial governors to pay. Some did: the lords of Mino, Harima and Tajima are on record, and Asakura Ujikage, whose father had famously changed sides in the war, is said to have come up from Echizen with three thousand men to work.

Profits from the ships sent to Ming China went into it as well, the same licensed trade that was meant to separate official traders from the wokou pirates. When all that fell short, Yoshimasa imposed special levies of cash and forced labour on the estates of Yamashiro province, which in practice meant on farmers. Hino Tomiko, the richest woman in Japan, is said not to have contributed anything at all.

The stones were a running scandal. In 1484 Yoshimasa’s men took rocks from Tōji-in so roughly that they damaged its walls and corridors; Tō-ji, the great temple in the south of the city, refused several times and had its stones carted off anyway. In the seventh month of 1486 the monk who ran Yoshimasa’s affairs at Shōkoku-ji was ordered to bring ten stones from land belonging to Rokuon-ji, the temple around his grandfather’s Golden Pavilion, and grumbled to a courtier that he wished he could get out of it. Then came the gardeners chased out of Nara.

The halls went up one by one. A meditation room called the Saishi-an was ready in 1485, and on the 15th day of the sixth month of that year Yoshimasa shaved his head and took the Buddhist name Kizan Dōkei. His private Buddhist chapel, the Tōgudō, followed in 1486, the reception hall and a pavilion over the spring in 1487, a boathouse and a bridge called the Dragon’s Back in 1488. Only then did the carpenters raise the building that would make the place famous.

He was not, whatever you may read, sitting in that building watching Kyoto burn. The war had been over for five years when the first post went in, and the pavilion was not standing until 1489. The story is too good to die: it is in guidebooks and on travel sites, usually with the shogun contemplating his garden while the city goes up in flames below. What he was actually doing was rather worse, from the point of view of the farmers paying for it: building a garden in the ruins, after the fact, at everyone else’s expense.

A chapel for Kannon on a stack of borrowed ideas

The two-storey Kannon-den (観音殿), Hall of Kannon, is a small building, about eight metres on its longest side, with a pyramid roof of thin wooden shingles and a bronze phoenix on top. It stands at the edge of the pond and faces east. Yoshimasa named the floors himself: the ground floor is the Shinkū-den, the Hall of the Empty Heart, and the upper floor the Chōon-kaku, the Tower of the Sound of Waves.

The two-storey Kannon-den of Ginkaku-ji, the Silver Pavilion, with its bronze phoenix, seen across the Kinkyochi pond in Kyoto
The Kannon-den across the Kinkyōchi pond in September. Its two floors are built in two different styles: below, a room with sliding paper screens like a house; above, a Zen Buddha hall with bell-shaped windows and a balustrade. The phoenix on top is a later addition. Old records and guidebook illustrations show a plain jewel finial up there until the late 18th century. Photo: 掬茶, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Both names were borrowed. Yoshimasa took Chōon from the middle floor of Yoshimitsu’s pavilion at Kitayama, and according to the temple’s own history he went to Rokuon-ji unannounced in 1487 to look at his grandfather’s building again while his own was being designed. The other model was older still: the two-storey reliquary hall, the Ruriden, that the Zen master Musō Soseki had built beside the pond at Saihō-ji in the west of the city in 1339. Yoshimitsu had copied it, and now Yoshimasa copied both of them.

Moss-covered ground and trees beside the Golden Pond at Saiho-ji, the moss temple in western Kyoto
Saihō-ji, the moss temple, on the western edge of Kyoto, which Musō Soseki laid out in 1339 and which both Ashikaga pavilions imitated. Yoshimasa visited it repeatedly and rebuilt its meditation hall. His Ruriden is long gone, and the moss is much younger than the garden: Japanese sources date the moss carpet to the end of the Edo period, after floods had wrecked the dry stonework. Photo: Ivanoff, CC BY-SA 3.0.

The ground floor was a room to live in. Half of it is a broad open veranda and an eight-mat Buddha room with a wooden floor; the other half a six-mat room and two small rooms with a staircase, which carry marks of later alteration. The upper floor is a single room with a wooden floor and a coffered ceiling, where a seated figure of Kannon faces east, of a type the Japanese call the Kannon in the cave. You cannot go in, but photographs of the statue are on display at the counter where the temple writes its seal stamps.

The shingled pyramid roof and upper floor of the Kannon-den at Ginkaku-ji seen from the hillside path above, with bamboo behind
The Kannon-den from the hillside path, the best place to see the roof: thin shingles of wood rather than the clay tiles of most Kyoto temples, re-laid about every thirty years. From here you can also see that the upper floor has doors only on its south and north sides. Photo: 掬茶, CC BY-SA 4.0.

That detail has bothered architectural historians for a century. The ground floor faces east, and so does the Kannon, but the upper floor has no door on its east side at all; its doors face south and north, so from the outside it reads as a building that faces south.

One explanation is that there was once water on the south side and you were meant to venerate the Kannon across it. Another, argued from marks of alteration on the timbers, is that the upper floor, or the whole building, was moved here from somewhere else. An excavation in 2009 found a Muromachi-period levelled surface and a row of stones directly beneath the pavilion, which suggests it has stood where it is since the start.

When was it finished? The Shōkoku-ji office diary, the Inryōken nichiroku, puts the raising of the ridgepole on the 23rd day of the second month of 1489; the temple’s own history says the third month, and its name board was ready on the 3rd day of the tenth month. By then Yoshimasa had suffered a stroke. He died on the 7th day of the first month of 1490 (27 January by the Western calendar, by the usual conversion), and several Japanese reference works, along with the official multilingual description prepared for visitors, say the pavilion was not completed until after his death.

Silver it never was

So why “silver”? The short answer is that it is a joke at Kinkaku-ji’s expense, and a late one. The name Ginkaku is not recorded in Yoshimasa’s time or for well over a century after it; it turns up in Edo-period guidebooks to Kyoto, among them the Rakuyō meishoshū of 1658, by which time the Golden Pavilion was the city’s most famous sight and its smaller, plainer cousin in the eastern hills needed a name to go with it.

Autochrome colour photograph of the Kannon-den and its pond at Ginkaku-ji taken by Roger Dumas for the Albert Kahn archive in 1926 or 1927
The Kannon-den in an autochrome, an early colour photograph, taken by Roger Dumas for the French banker Albert Kahn’s “Archives of the Planet” in 1926 or 1927. The walls are the dark, weathered wood you see today. The pond came almost to the foot of the building, and the rocks in the foreground are still there. Photo: Roger Dumas, CC BY-SA 4.0.

English-language accounts still usually tell you that Yoshimasa meant to cover the building in silver leaf and ran out of money, or died first. A second version has the silver applied and later peeled off; a third says the black lacquer on the walls gleamed silver in moonlight. Japanese reference works now treat the first two as folklore with no basis in the record, and a scientific survey reported in 2007 found no trace of silver on the building. What it did find was that the upper floor had originally been finished in black lacquer, inside and out.

Hand-coloured Meiji-era albumen photograph of rocks, pines and the pond garden at Ginkaku-ji, Kyoto, from a tourist album
The garden in a hand-coloured albumen print sold to foreign travellers in the late 19th century, from an album of fifty views now in the Rijksmuseum. The pavilion is half hidden in pines at the back, which is where Meiji photographers usually left it: the rocks and the old pines were what they came to sell, and nobody thought to colour anything silver.

That finding forced a decision. From February 2008 to March 2010 the pavilion had its first major repair since the Taishō period: the shingle roof was relaid, rotten pillars and wall panels replaced, earthquake bracing added and the inside of the upper floor recoated in black lacquer. Traces of red and blue painted flowers turned up under the eaves of the upper floor, and marks of a built-in Buddha altar on the ground floor. The prefectural board of education proposed going further and lacquering the outside black again, as Yoshimasa had left it.

The Kannon-den at Ginkaku-ji in September 2010, after the restoration of 2008 to 2010, with its new shingle roof and unlacquered walls
The Kannon-den in September 2010, a few months after the restoration. The new shingles are still pale, the pillars that were replaced are still lighter than their neighbours, and the outside walls are the plain weathered wood that the temple chose to keep. Photo: Laitr Keiows, CC BY-SA 3.0.

The temple, which owns the building, decided against it and kept the appearance everyone knew. The pavilion had been weathered brown wood for centuries, and it is brown in every photograph ever taken of it. The work cost about ¥140 million, and the abbot, Arima Raitei, held the rededication service on 12 April 2010. I think they were right, for a reason the restorers did not need to state: a black-lacquered Silver Pavilion would have been the most confusing building in Japan.

Black-and-white photograph by Ogawa Kazumasa of the Kannon-den reflected in the pond at Ginkaku-ji, published in 1893
The pavilion and its reflection in a photograph by Ogawa Kazumasa, published in 1893 in the architect Josiah Conder’s “Landscape Gardening in Japan”. Conder taught a generation of Japanese architects, and this book was one of the first serious studies of Japanese gardens in English. Not a speck of silver in the picture.

The name causes trouble in other ways. Strictly, Ginkaku is one building and the temple is Jishō-ji, and pedants will tell you that “Ginkaku-ji” is not the name of anything. I would accept both, and so does every bus in Kyoto.

Four and a half mats: the Tōgudō and the Dōjinsai

If the Kannon-den is the famous building, the Tōgudō (東求堂) is the important one. It was finished in 1486 as Yoshimasa’s private Buddhist chapel, a single-storey hall about 6.9 metres square under a hipped roof of cypress bark, and it is thought to have stood at first a little closer to the Kannon-den, roughly where the sand cone is now. It was modelled, like so much here, on a building at Saihō-ji, and it looked out over a lotus pond.

The Togudo, Ashikaga Yoshimasa's private Buddhist hall of 1486, with its cypress-bark roof, at Ginkaku-ji in Kyoto
The Tōgudō, seen from the pond. The front room behind the central panelled doors is the Buddha room, with a standing Amida; the Dōjinsai is in the back right-hand corner, behind the closed shutters. Both this and the Kannon-den are National Treasures, and they are the only buildings of Yoshimasa’s villa still standing. Photo: 掬茶, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The name tells you what kind of Buddhist Yoshimasa was. When he asked the Zen monk Ōsen Keisan for suggestions, he picked Tōgu, “seeking from the east”, from a line in a Chinese Zen text, the Platform Sutra, about a man of the east who chants the name of the Buddha in the hope of rebirth in the Western Paradise. It is an Amida hall, of the same family as the Phoenix Hall at Byōdō-in, built by a Zen-educated shogun who hedged his bets.

The room inside where Amida stands once had sliding doors painted with ten Zen monks by Kanō Masanobu. They are lost, and the doors are now covered in plain white paper.

Autochrome colour photograph of the Togudo seen across the pond at Ginkaku-ji, taken by Roger Dumas in 1926 or 1927
The Tōgudō across the water in Roger Dumas’s autochrome of 1926 or 1927. The building was taken apart and repaired in 1964 and 1965, when the carpenters found the inscription “the room with the hearth” on a timber of the Dōjinsai, and put back a bench recess on the west side that a 15th-century diary had described. Photo: Roger Dumas, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Behind the Buddha room, in the north-east corner, is the Dōjinsai (同仁斎), and this is the room I would cross Kyoto for. It is four and a half mats, about the size of a modern box room, floored wall to wall with tatami. On its north side are two built-in features side by side: a half-bay of staggered shelves, the chigaidana, and a full-bay desk set into a projecting window, the tsuke-shoin, with a paper screen to let in light for reading. The name, from the Tang writer Han Yu, means “equal benevolence”, the sage looking on all things alike.

Photograph published in 1929 of a seated wooden figure of Ashikaga Yoshimasa in Buddhist robes
A seated wooden figure of Yoshimasa in a monk’s robe, as photographed for the official historical compendium Dai Nihon shiryō in 1929. The temple counts its wooden statue of him among its most important treasures, and a figure of Yoshimasa as a monk sits in the Tōgudō’s Buddha room, which is the closest you will get to him on a visit here.

Those two features are the oldest surviving examples of their kind, and they are why the Dōjinsai is called the source of shoin-zukuri (書院造), the “study style” of building. Within a century the writing desk had migrated into a decorative window beside the alcove, the shelves had joined it, and the tokonoma, the alcove for a scroll and flowers, had settled into the arrangement that every formal Japanese room still has. Square posts, sliding fusuma doors, paper shōji, mats edge to edge, transoms like the ranma above the doors: this is the vocabulary of the Japanese house, and its oldest surviving sentence is in this corner of the Tōgudō.

Diagram from the Kundaikan sauchoki showing how objects were to be arranged on a tsuke-shoin writing alcove
How a desk alcove was meant to be dressed, from the Kundaikan sauchōki, the shogun’s manual of display: a hanging bell, a flower vase, an inkstone screen, brushes, a small knife, a water pot and a rolled scroll, each one named and put in its place. The same manual records the Dōjinsai’s own shelves set out with tea utensils. Image: Ktmchi, after the Kundaikan sauchōki, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Is it also the first tea room? Tea people have said so since the Edo period, and the architect Horiguchi Sutemi argued for it from the display manual’s description of tea equipment on the shelves; the 1960s inscription about a hearth gave his side more evidence. The architectural historian Nakamura Masao disagreed: there is no raised alcove, nowhere for host and guest to sit as the later tea room requires, and the tea may have been an offering, since the next room held two scrolls by Musō Soseki, whom Yoshimasa revered.

I think both are right in a way. The four-and-a-half-mat tea room of Sen no Rikyū descends from rooms like this one, but this one was a study where a man also made tea, which is not quite the same thing.

The men with -ami in their names

Historians call what grew up around Yoshimasa Higashiyama bunka, Higashiyama culture, after the hills where he built. The term is younger than you might think. It came into use among Japanese historians in the 1920s, partly because the Ashikaga were awkward subjects at the time: official history held that the Southern Court, the line of Emperor Go-Daigo, had been the legitimate one, which made the Ashikaga shoguns traitors, and scholars found it easier to discuss the shoguns’ culture than their politics.

Ink painting of the white-robed Kannon seated on a rock by the doboshu painter Noami
A white-robed Kannon by Nōami, the first of the three generations of dōbōshū who ran the shogun’s Chinese collection. Nōami took his compositions straight from the Chinese paintings he catalogued, which only he and a few others were allowed to handle. He died in 1471, eleven years before the villa was begun, so whatever he did for Yoshimasa, he did it in the palace in the city and not at Higashiyama-dono.

How awkward is worth a sentence. In the second month of 1863, pro-imperial activists broke into Tōji-in, the Ashikaga family temple in the north-west of the city, cut the heads off the wooden statues of the first three shoguns and displayed them on the riverbank at Sanjō like the heads of executed criminals. From the Meiji period until 1945 the hero of school history was Kusunoki Masashige, who died fighting for Go-Daigo, and the villain was Ashikaga Takauji, who founded the shogunate. A grandson’s tea and gardens were safer ground than his ancestors’ politics.

Today Japanese historians increasingly fold Higashiyama culture into a broader “Muromachi culture”, on the reasonable grounds that it did not begin or end with one man, and you can read the larger story in my piece on the Muromachi era.

The men who made it were, to a remarkable degree, men of no rank. The shogun’s household included the dōbōshū (同朋衆), “companions”, lay attendants in clerical dress who took names ending in -ami, a habit inherited from the Ji sect of wandering Buddhists who had followed warrior armies as chaplains and entertainers. They looked after the shogun’s Chinese paintings and ceramics, valued them, mounted them and arranged them for his guests. Three generations of one family, Nōami, Geiami and Sōami, did more than anyone to define what a cultivated Japanese room should contain.

Pair of folding screens with an ink landscape of the four seasons attributed to Soami, Metropolitan Museum of Art
A landscape of the four seasons on a pair of screens attributed to Sōami, the grandson, now in the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Sōami was a painter, a connoisseur who priced the shogun’s treasures, and the compiler of the display manuals; a Zen monk of his day called him “the master painter of the land”. Tradition also credits him with the Ginkaku-ji garden, which nobody can prove.

Sōami put their rules in writing. His version of the Kundaikan sauchōki, dated 1511, lists some 150 Chinese painters by rank and shows how scrolls, flower vases, incense burners and tea bowls were to be arranged in alcoves and on shelves; another manual of 1523 sets out the display of a whole house. The treasures themselves became known as Higashiyama gomotsu, “the Higashiyama collection”, though Japanese historians point out the irony that Yoshimasa’s reign was when the shogunate’s Chinese pieces leaked out onto the market, to be bought by merchants in Sakai and Kyoto who would found the next century’s taste.

Around them worked a crowd of specialists. Kanō Masanobu, the founder of the Kanō school of painters, which went on to decorate the castles and palaces of Japan’s rulers until the end of the shogunate, was painting walls at Higashiyama-dono from 1483 and lived to be ninety-seven by the Japanese count. Gotō Yūjō, a metalworker in Yoshimasa’s service, founded the family that made fittings for the swords of Japan’s rulers into the 19th century, and the lacquer families of Kōami and Igarashi trace themselves to the same years; my guide to Japan’s greatest crafts follows several of those trades to the present. Shino Sōshin, another of the companions, is honoured as the founder of a school of incense appreciation, and is said to have received from Yoshimasa a sliver of the most famous incense wood in Japan.

Hanging scroll by Kano Masanobu of the Chinese scholar Zhou Maoshu in a boat admiring lotuses beneath a willow
Kanō Masanobu’s “Zhou Maoshu Admiring Lotuses”, a National Treasure and the painting usually held up as his masterpiece: a Song-dynasty scholar in a boat under a willow, the top half of the scroll left almost empty. Masanobu’s clarity, every element easy to read, set the direction the Kanō school followed for centuries.

The most despised of them made the garden. Zen’ami was a kawaramono, literally a riverbank person, one of the outcast labourers who worked in trades the Buddhist establishment considered polluting, and he was also the most admired garden-maker of his age. A Shōkoku-ji monk who saw one of his hill gardens wrote that he could not look at it enough and forgot the way home. Yoshimasa sent him medicine when he was dying, at a great age, around 1482, and Japanese sources credit the Higashiyama garden to his sons and his grandson Matashirō.

And then there was tea. Tradition says that Nōami introduced Yoshimasa to a monk from Nara called Murata Jukō, and that Jukō taught him the drinking of tea in a small room with plain utensils, which became the wabi tea of the next century. The tea historian Kōzu Asao has argued that there is no reliable evidence Jukō ever met Yoshimasa, and that his style came from the humble hermitage tea of Nara, not from the shogun’s reception rooms. What Jukō did write, in a letter to a pupil, was that the important thing was to blur the line between Japanese and Chinese wares: a rough local pot alongside a fine Chinese one.

Seated portrait of the monk and tea master Murata Juko in dark robes
Murata Jukō in a later portrait. He was born in Nara in 1423, entered a Pure Land temple at eleven and, contrary to a long tradition that he became a merchant, seems to have remained a monk all his life, since a diary of 1486 still calls him “the monk Jukō”. He died in 1502, aged eighty.

That idea is the bridge between the Dōjinsai and the thatched huts of the late 16th century. My piece on the tea ceremony follows it from here through Takeno Jōō to Rikyū, and the line runs straight. You do not need to believe that the shogun and the tea monk sat together in the four-and-a-half-mat room for the room to matter; it shows you exactly the kind of space in which Japanese taste was being rearranged, and Ginkaku-ji is where you can still stand next to it.

The garden that came after

Yoshimasa’s garden was meant to be a copy too. Its model, again, was Saihō-ji, which Musō Soseki had laid out in two tiers: a pond garden below for strolling, and a garden of stones on the hillside above for meditation, with a path climbing between them. Musō, who had died in 1351, was even named the founding abbot of Jishō-ji after Yoshimasa’s death, an honorary title for a man who had never seen the place. My history of Japanese gardens explains how Musō set the pattern for every Zen garden-maker who came after him.

The small Sengetsusen waterfall falling between mossy rocks into the Kinkyochi pond at Ginkaku-ji
The Sengetsusen, the “moon-washing spring”, a thin fall of water at the south-east corner of the pond that brings the stream down from the hillside into the lower garden. This is a quiet corner on the circuit; most people walk past it on their way up to the viewpoint, and it deserves a minute. Photo: そらみみ, CC BY-SA 3.0.

The lower garden centres on the Kinkyōchi (錦鏡池), the Brocade Mirror Pond, with the Kannon-den on its western shore and islands and named rocks in the water. The Japanese encyclopedias single out the stonework of the pond edges and islands for its clean, straight lines, and suggest that Zen’ami’s family laid it. It is the only garden Yoshimasa had a hand in that survives anywhere, and much of what you see has been reshaped since.

The Ouchi stone, a rock islet with a name post, in the Kinkyochi pond at Ginkaku-ji
The Ōuchi stone in the Kinkyōchi pond, with its name post. It carries the name of the Ōuchi, the great lords of western Japan whose army camped in Kyoto for ten years during the Ōnin War; I have found no reliable account of how the stone acquired it. Photo: 掬茶, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The upper garden had a more dramatic fate. It lay buried and forgotten on the hillside until 1931, when excavations uncovered a dry stone arrangement thought to keep something of the Muromachi design. Near the site of a pavilion called the Sōsen-tei there is a group of rocks set at angles that make it look as if it is in the middle of collapsing, which is apparently the idea.

Mossy hillside rock arrangement at the site of the Sosen-tei pavilion in the upper garden of Ginkaku-ji
The rock arrangement at the site of the Sōsen-tei in the upper garden, uncovered in the 1930s. The temple calls it unusual, with stones that look as if they are about to fall, and it is the closest you will get to Yoshimasa’s hillside garden. Below it the moss runs right down to the path. Photo: 掬茶, CC BY-SA 4.0.

What everybody photographs is neither of these. In front of the abbot’s hall lies the Ginshadan (銀沙灘), the “sea of silver sand”, a broad flat bed of white sand raised in a low step and raked into stripes, and beside it the Kōgetsudai (向月台), the “platform facing the moon”, a truncated cone about 1.8 metres high, both made of coarse white sand. Neither existed in Yoshimasa’s time.

The flat-topped Kogetsudai cone of white sand in front of pines at Ginkaku-ji
The Kōgetsudai from beside the path. The gardeners reshape it every four to six weeks, and it was much lower when it was first made. Guidebooks will tell you that it represents Mount Fuji, or that Yoshimasa sat on it to watch the moon rise over the hills; the temple itself, to its credit, calls the moon story a popular tale, and nobody has ever produced evidence for Fuji. Photo: そらみみ, CC BY-SA 3.0.

The temple’s own guide is refreshingly frank about them. It says that the two heaps cannot possibly go back to the Muromachi period, that they are an idea of the Edo period or later, and that the popular explanations, sand to reflect moonlight, a seat for waiting for the moon, are folk stories; and then it adds that nobody else has ever done anything like it. Japanese reference works put their present form in the late Edo period. My own guess, which is only a guess and not an original one, is that they began as the gardeners’ stockpile of fresh sand and grew into something too good to remove.

Engraved view of the pond garden and Kannon-den of Ginkaku-ji from Josiah Conder's Landscape Gardening in Japan, 1893
The garden as engraved for Josiah Conder’s book of 1893, looking across the pond towards the Kannon-den. Conder printed this and Ogawa Kazumasa’s photographs for readers who had never seen a Japanese garden. It is the view from roughly where the Tōgudō stands, and it is still recognisable.

The hillside has never been entirely tame. On 9 July 1967 trees on the slope came down roots and all, and parts of the garden were closed for a time. On 12 July 1972 heavy rain brought the hill behind the Tōgudō down on the garden, and more than half of it was buried in mud. What you walk through has been dug out, replanted and re-raked within living memory, which is another reason not to ask too much of the word “original” here.

Moss-covered slope and tree trunks in the garden of Ginkaku-ji, Kyoto
The moss on the slope between the lower and upper gardens, the part of Ginkaku-ji that most resembles its model at Saihō-ji today. If it has rained in the night, come early: the colour is at its best before the sun gets onto it. Photo: そらみみ, CC BY-SA 3.0.

The gardens of Ginkaku-ji are on everybody’s Kyoto list, and they are on mine in my guide to Japan’s greatest gardens. But I would not come for the sand alone. Come for the strange mixture of a 15th-century pond, a 1930s excavation, an Edo-period sculpture and a hillside of moss, all of it arranged around two small buildings that are the only things here Yoshimasa would recognise.

Five centuries of fire, villas and repairs

Yoshimasa never moved into his finished villa in the sense he had hoped. His son Yoshihisa died in the third month of 1489 in an army camp in Ōmi, aged twenty-five by the Japanese count, and the old man took up the government again. That summer he began a new main hall at Higashiyama-dono to serve as an office; in the eighth month he had a stroke, and in the tenth month another. He died on the 7th day of the first month of 1490, aged fifty-five by the Japanese count.

Stone grave marker of Ashikaga Yoshimasa with a carved post reading Ashikaga Yoshimasa no haka, Shokoku-ji, Kyoto
Yoshimasa’s grave at Shōkoku-ji, with a post reading “the grave of Ashikaga Yoshimasa”. He had asked to be buried under the floor of his meditation room at Higashiyama; Enryaku-ji objected to a shogun’s tomb on the land of a Tendai temple, and he ended up here instead, at Jishō-in, a sub-temple of the Ashikaga family monastery.

He left instructions that the villa should become a Zen temple, as his grandfather’s had. It was named Jishō-in from his own posthumous name and became Jishō-ji the following year, attached to Shōkoku-ji, which still runs it. His wish to be buried in his meditation room ran into the monks of Enryaku-ji on Mount Hiei, who had resented a shogun building over one of their temples all along and refused. So in the third month of 1491 a sub-temple of Shōkoku-ji was renamed Jishō-in instead, and his image and ashes went there.

There is a story about the Daimonji fire that the temple tells. In the summer of 1489, it says, Yoshimasa wanted to send off the spirit of his dead son at Obon, and Ōsen Keisan stood at the Tōgudō, looked up at the hill behind, and marked out the character for “great” on its slope, to be lit with bonfires on the 16th night of the seventh month. That is one of several origin stories for the Daimonji. Others credit Kūkai, the founder of Shingon Buddhism, or the courtier Konoe Nobutada at the start of the 17th century, and none of them can be proved.

Woodblock illustration from the Miyako meisho zue showing the character dai on Nyoigatake above figures in the fields
The Daimonji hill in the Miyako meisho zue, the illustrated guide to Kyoto first published in 1780; this copy is dated 1786. The character sits on the slope of Nyoigatake above townspeople strolling in the fields. By the Edo period the fire was already one of the sights that brought visitors to the city in summer.

The temple’s first century was poor and dangerous. Its second abbot was a fifteen-year-old brother of the tenth shogun; later abbots came from the great court families.

In 1549 the twelfth shogun, Ashikaga Yoshiharu, driven out of the city by the Miyoshi, began to build a castle called Nakao on the hill behind the temple, and when he died the following year his funeral was held in its halls. His son Yoshiteru held the castle against the Miyoshi through the summer of 1550, and in a skirmish at the foot of the hills in the seventh month a Miyoshi soldier was killed by a gunshot, which the courtier Yamashina Tokitsugu heard about and noted in his diary; it is often cited as the earliest record of a gun used in battle in Japan. Yoshiteru burned the castle himself and abandoned it on the 21st day of the eleventh month, and in the course of that year’s fighting the temple burned too, all except the Kannon-den and the Tōgudō.

Hasegawa Sadanobu woodblock print of the lit character dai on Nyoigatake under a full moon, with people on a road below
The Daimonji burning under a full moon in a print by Hasegawa Sadanobu, published in Osaka in the 1850s. The hill is Nyoigatake, directly behind Ginkaku-ji, and the castle of 1550 stood on one of its spurs. On 16 August each year you can see the fire from the bridge at the foot of the temple’s lane.

A few weeks after the burning of Nakao, early in 1551, the Jesuit Francis Xavier reached Kyoto hoping to meet the emperor and found a ruined city where nobody could arrange it. That was the world the temple had to survive in. Late in the 16th century it served as the private villa of Konoe Sakihisa, a former imperial regent whose brother was abbot, and whose Buddhist name after his death was, fittingly, Tōgu-in.

In 1569 Oda Nobunaga, building a palace for the last Ashikaga shogun, Yoshiaki, had the garden’s most famous stone, the Kusen-hakkai, hauled away to decorate it. That palace was not the Nijō Castle you can visit today, which the Tokugawa built in 1603, though it was the same idea.

The revival came in 1615, when Miyagi Toyomori, a former retainer of Toyotomi Hideyoshi who had gone over to Tokugawa Ieyasu, supervised a thorough restoration. Japanese sources agree that the temple’s present layout owes more to this work than to anything else, and that the garden was reshaped in the taste of a Zen temple rather than a shogun’s villa. The abbot’s hall dates from 1624 by most accounts (the temple’s own guide calls it mid-Edo), and it later acquired sliding doors painted by Yosa Buson and Ike no Taiga, the two great Kyoto painters of the 18th century.

The long approach between the clipped Ginkakuji-gaki hedges at Ginkaku-ji after snow
The approach between the hedges, the Ginkakuji-gaki, after snow. It runs about fifty metres from the outer gate to the inner, a bamboo fence below and clipped camellia above, and the temple describes it as a prologue that wipes the street from your mind. On a winter morning it does exactly that. Photo: Moja, CC BY-SA 3.0.

The Meiji government’s seizure of temple lands took the wooded hill behind Ginkaku-ji in the 1870s, and it is still state forest, protected as the backdrop to the garden. In 1914 the Kannon-den was taken apart and repaired, with concrete footings slipped beneath its foundation stones. The garden was designated a Special Historic Site and Special Place of Scenic Beauty in 1952, and in 1994 the temple became part of the World Heritage listing of historic Kyoto.

Where to see Ginkaku-ji today

Ginkaku-ji is at the north end of the eastern hills, at the top of a lane of souvenir shops that climbs east from the canal. It is open every day of the year: from 8:30 to 17:00 between March and November, and from 9:00 to 16:30 from December to February, with everyone expected to be out by twenty minutes after closing. Admission went up on 1 April 2026 for the first time in thirty-two years, to ¥1,000 for adults and high-school students and ¥500 for primary and junior-high pupils; you can pay in cash or by the temple’s cashless app. Check the temple’s page on the Shōkoku-ji website for changes before you go.

View from the hillside viewpoint over the roofs of Ginkaku-ji, the Kannon-den and the Togudo towards Kyoto under sunbeams
The view from the hillside viewpoint, the highest point on the circuit: the roofs of the abbot’s hall and the Tōgudō, the Kannon-den half hidden in pines on the left, and the whole of northern Kyoto beyond. In Yoshimasa’s day the city below was largely ash. Photo: Basile Morin, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The circuit

The route is one way and the temple reckons on thirty minutes, which is about right if you do not stop. You pass the hedges and the inner gate, come out beside the abbot’s hall with the sand garden in front of you and the Kannon-den beyond, and then walk round the pond past the Tōgudō to the Sengetsusen. From there the path climbs the hillside through the moss to the viewpoint, and comes down past the Ochanoi to the exit.

The Ochanoi spring with its wooden sign and bamboo railing on the hillside at Ginkaku-ji
The Ochanoi, the “tea well”, a spring on the hillside that the sign describes as the water Yoshimasa used for his tea. Whether he did is beyond proof, but the spring still runs, and the rocks around it are among the oldest-looking in the garden. The steps up to it, like the viewpoint, are not wheelchair-accessible. Photo: そらみみ, CC BY-SA 3.0.

You cannot enter the Kannon-den at any time, and the Tōgudō and abbot’s hall are closed except during the special openings. The hillside stops (the viewpoint, a shrine to Benzaiten, the Sōsen-tei site and the Ochanoi) are reached by steps; if you are in a wheelchair, turn off before the Sengetsusen and the rest of the circuit is manageable. There is no parking for visitors.

The best time is 8:30 sharp, before the school parties arrive, or the last hour of the day in winter. The lane up from the canal is jammed from mid-morning, and by eleven the railing in front of the sand garden is three deep. Early December, after the autumn colours and before the New Year crowds, is the quietest month I know here. Snow is rare and lasts a morning; if you see it in the forecast, go.

The special openings

Twice a year, in spring and autumn, the temple opens the abbot’s hall, the Tōgudō and the Rōseitei, a pavilion rebuilt in 1895 for the appreciation of incense. In 2026 the autumn opening runs from 1 November to 5 December. Visits are guided, in Japanese only, at 10:00, 11:00, 12:00, 13:30, 14:30 and 15:30, for about twenty people at a time and about thirty minutes each.

You put your name on a sheet in front of the main hall, which goes out about an hour before each session; come back ten minutes before the start. The fee is ¥2,000 on top of normal admission, with a paper-cut souvenir of the Tōgudō, and groups of seven or more are refused. Photographs, recordings, notes and sketches are forbidden, and so, explicitly, is using a translation app or interpreting for someone during the tour.

If you have any interest in Japanese architecture, this is the best ¥2,000 you can spend in Kyoto. The Tōgudō visit takes in the Buddha room, with its Amida and the statue of Yoshimasa as a monk, and the Dōjinsai, where you can see the shelves and the desk window close up.

The abbot’s hall has reproductions of the Buson and Taiga doors; the Rōseitei, a room for incense with doors painted by Okuda Gensō, is the model for every incense room since. The guide’s Japanese is fast. Read up beforehand.

Getting there

Kyoto City Bus routes 5, 7, 32, 102, 203 and 204 all stop at Ginkakuji-michi, about ten minutes’ walk from the gate, and the EX100 express and route 105 stop at Ginkakuji-mae, about six minutes away. From Kyoto Station, the 5 runs direct and the EX100 express is quicker. From Kinkaku-ji, the 102 and 204 run across the north of the city to Ginkakuji-michi, which makes the two pavilions an easy day together. From Shōkoku-ji, take the 102 or 203 from Dōshisha-mae.

Shōkoku-ji and Yoshimasa’s grave

Ginkaku-ji and Kinkaku-ji both belong to Shōkoku-ji, the Zen monastery Yoshimitsu founded beside his palace, and its Jōtenkaku Museum shows the treasures of all three temples in rotating exhibitions. Yoshimasa’s grave is in its sub-temple Jishō-in, just east of the Karasuma-Imadegawa crossing. As far as I know the sub-temple is not generally open to the public, so check before you make a special trip; the museum is the reason to go.

The Philosopher’s Path

From the bridge at the bottom of Ginkaku-ji’s lane, a footpath runs south beside a branch of the Lake Biwa Canal for about 1.5 kilometres to Nyakuōji Bridge near Eikandō. It began as a maintenance track when the canal opened in 1890; the philosopher Nishida Kitarō liked to walk it while he was thinking, as did his colleague Tanabe Hajime, and in 1972 local residents settled on the name Tetsugaku no michi, the Philosopher’s Path. Many of the paving stones came from Kyoto’s tramlines after they closed in 1978.

Cherry trees in blossom over the canal and a stone bridge on the Philosopher's Path, Kyoto
The Philosopher’s Path in early April. The cherries are called Kansetsu-zakura, after the painter Hashimoto Kansetsu and his wife Yone, who gave the city 300 saplings in 1921; the originals have nearly all been replaced, but the name stays. Walk it on a weekday morning or not at all in blossom season.

There are around 420 cherry trees, and in early April the path is about as quiet as a station concourse. In November and in summer, when the canal is shaded and fireflies are about in June, it is one of the most pleasant walks in the city. Hashimoto Kansetsu’s own house and studio, the Hakusasonsō, now a museum with a garden, is a few minutes from the northern end.

Boulder carved with a poem by the philosopher Nishida Kitaro beside the Philosopher's Path, Kyoto
The stone carved in 1981 with Nishida Kitarō’s poem about going his own way, which stands beside the path not far from Hōnen-in. It is the only monument on the path to the man it is named after, and almost everybody walks past it. Photo: Yanajin33, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Hōnen-in

Ten minutes south of Ginkaku-ji, up a short lane to the left of the path, is Hōnen-in, a Pure Land temple restored in 1680 on a site linked to the monk Hōnen. Its grounds are free and open from early morning, and the thatched gate and moss are as fine as anything at Ginkaku-ji with a tenth of the people. The main buildings open only for a week in early April and a week in November; in spring 2026 the fee was ¥800 for adults.

The two raked white-sand Byakusadan mounds either side of the path inside the gate of Honen-in, Kyoto
The Byakusadan, two raised beds of white sand inside the gate of Hōnen-in, raked with a new design according to the season. Walking between them is meant to purify you on your way in. They are clearly cousins of Ginkaku-ji’s Ginshadan, and you can stand right beside them. Photo: Eric Salard, CC BY-SA 2.0.

Up the hill behind the temple is its cemetery. The novelist Tanizaki Jun’ichirō is buried there, under two stones carved with the characters for “stillness” and “emptiness”, and so is Naitō Konan, the historian who said that to understand modern Japan you hardly needed history earlier than the Ōnin War. I find it hard to think of a better neighbour for Yoshimasa’s villa.

Nanzen-ji

At the southern end of the path is Nanzen-ji, the great Zen monastery whose sub-temple was Yoshimasa’s first choice of site in 1465, and which burned in the fighting of 1467. Its two-storey Sanmon gate of 1628 and the abbot’s garden both charge their own small fees; the grounds are free. Behind them stands the Suirokaku, a red-brick aqueduct of 1890 that carries the Lake Biwa Canal through the temple, and somehow looks as if it has always been there.

The brick arches of the Suirokaku aqueduct of the Lake Biwa Canal in the grounds of Nanzen-ji, Kyoto, with autumn maples
The Suirokaku aqueduct at Nanzen-ji in November. The canal it carries is the same water that runs beside the Philosopher’s Path, so you can follow it from Ginkaku-ji all the way here. The Meiji engineers built it in brick straight through the grounds of a 13th-century Zen monastery, and the monastery has long since absorbed it into the view.

The Daimonji

If you are fit, the hill behind Ginkaku-ji is a walk in its own right. A path starts just north of the temple gate and climbs for forty minutes or so to the fire beds of the Daimonji, the character “great” cut into the slope of Nyoigatake, from where you look down on the whole of Kyoto. On the night of 16 August the character is lit at 20:00 as the first of the five Gozan no Okuribi fires that send the spirits of the dead back after Obon; walkers are kept off the mountain that day, so watch from the banks of the Kamo river or the canal at the foot of the temple’s lane.

The character dai burning on the hillside of Nyoigatake during the Gozan no Okuribi on the night of 16 August, Kyoto
The Daimonji alight on 16 August, seen from a road along the canal in the north-east of the city. Each stroke is a line of bonfires laid on fixed stone hearths, which you can walk among on any other day of the year. The Ginkaku-ji tradition says Ōsen Keisan laid it out from the Tōgudō, and if you stand in the temple lane you can see why someone would have wanted to believe it. Photo: Takeshi Kuboki, CC BY 2.0.

Further afield, if you can get a reservation, go to Saihō-ji, the moss temple in the west of the city whose garden both Ashikaga pavilions copied. Visits must be booked in advance and include copying a sutra, which keeps numbers down and the moss in good order. Then go to Kinkaku-ji and look at the three styles stacked one on top of another, and you will have seen the whole family: the original, the grand copy and the quiet one. For the longer story of the age that produced them, start with Japan through the ages and the century of war that followed in the Sengoku era.

When you are back in front of the sand garden, before you leave, look past the Kōgetsudai to the Kannon-den and remember what it cost. The stones in this garden were taken from Tō-ji and Tōji-in, from the lands of the Golden Pavilion’s temple and very nearly from Kōfuku-ji, by a gardener nobody would have invited to dinner, for a shogun who had stopped trying to rule. I do not know a better example in Japan of a bad government producing a good room. Then go and find the Dōjinsai, if the doors are open, and stand for a moment at the edge of the four and a half mats.

Scroll to Top