Who Were the Samurai? Bowmen, Clerks and a Sword Ban

In 1842 the household of Inoyama Naoyuki, a samurai of the Kaga domain, owed roughly twice its annual income at fifteen to eighteen per cent a year, and about a third of everything it earned went on interest. In the seventh and eighth months of that year the family sold its clothes, its books and its tea utensils to pay the creditors down, and somebody started writing down every coin that came in or went out. They kept the ledger going for thirty-seven years, through the American warships, the fall of the shogunate, the end of their domain and the end of their class. In 2001 the historian Isoda Michifumi found the whole bundle in a secondhand bookshop in Jinbōchō, Tokyo.

The Inoyama were hereditary gosan’yōmono (御算用者), accountants to the Maeda lords of Kaga, the largest domain in Japan, and the instrument they handled most was the abacus. Their debts did not come from drink or gambling. They came from the gifts, ceremonies, servants and clothes that a samurai house of their rank was obliged to keep up, a cost Isoda calls the price of status. When the Restoration came, Naoyuki’s son Nariyuki was poached to keep the accounts of the new government’s army, and he retired in 1893 as a paymaster captain in the Imperial Navy.

I keep that ledger in mind whenever someone asks me who the samurai were, because the real answer looks a great deal more like the Inoyama than like the man on the film poster. The samurai existed as a recognisable class for about seven hundred years. For the first few centuries they were mounted archers who killed for a living; for the last two and a half they were mostly salaried officials, many of whom never drew a sword in earnest. What follows is both of them: the documented samurai, from the bowmen of the Heian court to the bond-holders of 1876, and the screen samurai, who arrived later and photographed better.

Woodblock book illustration of 1798 showing two-sworded samurai walking past townsmen fighting in an Edo street
The ninth month, from a book of Edo street life published in 1798 by Santō Kyōden and Kitao Shigemasa. Two samurai in formal dress walk past with their swords at their hips while a gang of townsmen brawls a few paces away, and neither of them so much as turns his head. That is closer to the everyday samurai than any battle scene. Image: Santō Kyōden and Kitao Shigemasa, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Servants with bows: what the words meant

Start with the two words, because they were never quite the same thing. Bushi (武士) is the older and more general term, a man of arms; it turns up in an official chronicle as early as 721, in an imperial edict that says literary men and warriors are what the state holds dear. Samurai (侍) began as something else entirely. It comes from the verb saburau, to wait upon or attend a superior, and in its oldest form, samorau, it meant to watch someone closely while you waited for an order.

In the Heian court a saburai was not necessarily a fighting man at all. The word covered officials of the sixth rank, and sometimes the fifth, who served the great noble houses as secretaries, stewards, bodyguards and constables, and legal scholars in that position were samurai just as much as archers were. Only gradually, as the men the nobles hired for protection came overwhelmingly from warrior families, did the servant’s word attach itself to the fighter. The sound shifted with it, from saburahi in the Heian period to saburai under the Kamakura and Ashikaga shoguns, and the form samurai appears only in the 16th century.

Printed page of the 1603 Jesuit Japanese-Portuguese dictionary Vocabulario da Lingoa de Iapam, Nagasaki
A page of the Vocabulario da Lingoa de Iapam, the Japanese-Portuguese dictionary the Jesuit press printed at Nagasaki in 1603. Its compilers translated bushi and mononofu plainly as soldier, but gave saburai as a nobleman or a person deserving respect. Even then, the two words did not mean quite the same thing.

The distinction never fully went away. Under the Tokugawa, the formal legal sense of samurai was narrower than the general one: in the shogun’s service it meant the bannermen with the right of audience, and in the domains it usually meant men of the rank of middle page and above, who rode horses and held fiefs or substantial stipends. Below them came the kachi, the foot samurai, and below them again the ashigaru, who were often not counted as samurai at all. In everyday speech, though, the word had long since become a synonym for the whole warrior class, and that is how I use it here.

Engraved Latin title frontispiece of Engelbert Kaempfer's History of Japan, London 1727, framed by Japanese crests
The frontispiece of Engelbert Kaempfer’s History of Japan, printed in London in 1727 from the German doctor’s notes on his years with the Dutch at Dejima. The word samurai is first attested in English in that same year. It took the better part of another century and a half before English readers met the people it described in any numbers.

Licensed killers: where the first samurai came from

Nobody agrees exactly how the warrior class began, and the Japanese debate is far livelier than the English textbooks suggest. The classic theory, worked out by Meiji historians who wanted Japan to have a feudal Middle Ages like Europe’s, made the first samurai armed frontier landowners defending their own fields. In recent decades a different school has argued that they came from the top down: from military families of the lower aristocracy, licensed by the court to do its fighting for it, who only later put down roots in the provinces. Most modern Japanese school textbooks now lean towards the second view, and most specialists think the truth is a mixture of both.

What the court needed in the 9th and 10th centuries was force it no longer had. The old conscript army of the ritsuryō state had withered away, provincial governors were squeezing the countryside hard, and armed raids on tax convoys and governors’ offices were routine. The men who answered the problem had learned their trade from the Emishi of the north, mounted archers who had fought the court’s armies for generations. They adapted those tactics, put on the heavy box-like ō-yoroi armour and the curved sword descended from the Emishi blade, and offered their bows to whoever would pay.

Red-laced o-yoroi armour with horned helmet from Kasuga Taisha in Nara
The red-laced ō-yoroi at Kasuga Taisha in Nara, a national treasure, photographed for a catalogue in 1952. Armour of this kind was built for a man shooting from the saddle: the big square shoulder plates swung to protect him as he drew. The sword at his hip was for the moment he lost his horse. My piece on samurai armour has the rest of its anatomy.

One summary in Japanese scholarship is that they were military subcontractors holding a licence from the state, and I find it the most useful phrase in the whole debate. A warrior family’s craft was handed from father to son like a scribe’s or a physician’s, and a man who was simply armed was not a bushi. The early ones are remembered for doing their job with a brutality the court found disgusting. When Taira no Masakado rose in the east in 939 and Fujiwara no Sumitomo raided the Inland Sea, the men who put them down were warriors too, and contemporaries were not always sure which side was worse.

The court tried to keep them on a leash and in sight. From the 890s a squad of guards called the takiguchi, after the spot beside the emperor’s residential hall where the palace drain fell away, kept the palace garden at night, and in 977 they were formally allowed to carry bows and arrows into the precinct, which no one but a regular military officer could otherwise do. Masakado himself is said to have served there as a young man in the household of the regent Fujiwara no Tadahira. Later the retired emperors raised their own guard, the warriors of the North Face, and that is where the word samurai was spending most of its time in the late 11th century: at the doors of the Fujiwara and the cloistered emperors, waiting.

Picture scroll of the Later Three Years' War showing mounted archers and a flock of geese breaking formation
A scene from the 1347 picture scroll of the Later Three Years’ War in the far north, fought in the 1080s. Minamoto no Yoshiie saw the geese break formation over a field, guessed that men were hiding in it and found the ambush. Every warrior in the picture fights with a bow, which is what a samurai of the age was for.

Their weapon was the bow. The phrase the war tales use for a warrior’s trade is kyūba no michi (弓馬の道), the way of the bow and the horse, and for several centuries the bow remained the ideal symbol of the class even after spears and guns had taken over the fighting. The idea that the sword was the soul of the samurai is, by one widely held Japanese view, largely a modern one. The sword mattered, and the curved tachi was a superb weapon, but in the Heian era it was what you used when something had gone wrong.

From hired swords to a government

The warriors became rulers in about thirty years, and the story is told elsewhere on this site, so I will only sketch it. In 1156 and again in 1159 the court’s factions brought warrior bands into the capital to settle their quarrels, and the Taira and Minamoto commanders discovered that the side they chose won. Taira no Kiyomori came out of the second round as the most powerful man in Japan, married his daughter to an emperor and put his grandson on the throne.

Heiji Monogatari picture scroll showing mounted warriors with bows crowding around an ox carriage
The night attack on the Sanjō palace in 1159, from a late 13th-century scroll now in Boston. Mounted archers crowd around the retired emperor’s ox carriage as he is carried off. The court had invited these men in to settle a political argument, and this is what settling it looked like.

The Genpei War of 1180–85 ended Taira rule, and the man who won it, Minamoto no Yoritomo, did something no warrior had done before: he set up a government of his own at Kamakura, far from the court, to manage the warriors themselves. His brother Yoshitsune won the battles, Yoritomo built the institutions, and by the time the court appointed him shogun in 1192 the provinces had military stewards and constables answering to him. The war tales also gave Japan its one famous woman warrior of the period, Tomoe Gozen, whom the documents never mention.

Hanging scroll portrait in black court robes traditionally identified as Minamoto no Yoritomo, Jingo-ji, Kyoto
The portrait at Jingo-ji in Kyoto that every Japanese schoolbook used to label Minamoto no Yoritomo. Since the 1990s a strong argument has been made that it actually shows Ashikaga Tadayoshi, brother of the first Ashikaga shogun, painted a century and a half later. It is still the face most Japanese people picture when they hear his name.

Under the Kamakura era regime, being a samurai first became a legal status with privileges attached. Kamakura law drew a hard line between the samurai and the bonge, the common people. A samurai could ride and go armed in the shogun’s city, was exempt from torture under questioning, and was usually punished by losing land rather than by flogging or branding. The shogunate’s own chronicle records that in 1247 the seating at a hearing was laid down by status: samurai in the guests’ seats, their retainers out on the veranda, and commoners down in the courtyard.

The relationship that held it together was a contract. A vassal, a gokenin, received protection and confirmation of his lands from the shogun, the go’on or favour, and owed armed service in return, the hōkō. It was reciprocal, and when Kamakura could no longer pay for service, as happened after the Mongol invasions of 1274 and 1281, the loyalty went with the money.

Detail of the Moko Shurai Ekotoba scroll showing the mounted warrior Takezaki Suenaga and his wounded horse
Takezaki Suenaga charging the Mongols at Hakata in 1274, his horse bleeding and an iron bomb bursting overhead, from the scroll he had painted to record his own deeds. Suenaga rode all the way to Kamakura the next year to complain that his part in the fighting had gone unrewarded. The scroll is a war record and a claim form at the same time.

If you ask whom the samurai actually fought, the answer for most of their history is each other. The Mongol invasions and Hideyoshi’s invasion of Korea in the 1590s, the Imjin War, were the great foreign exceptions. Everything else, from the Genpei War to the Boshin War of 1868–69, was Japanese against Japanese, and most of it was about land.

Everyone had a sword: the Sengoku blur

By the 15th century the line around the samurai had gone blurred, and for a hundred and fifty years it stayed that way. Under the Ashikaga shoguns the word samurai in its strict sense meant the higher vassals of the shogun, but the countryside was full of men who were half farmer and half warrior: jizamurai, village samurai, who managed the fields and rode out when a lord called. The Muromachi era also made a new kind of soldier famous, and not for anything good.

Detail of the 1524 Shinnyodo Engi picture scroll showing ashigaru foot soldiers during the Onin War in Kyoto
Ashigaru at work in the Shinnyodō Engi, a temple’s history scroll painted in 1524. During the Ōnin War these light infantry stripped the temple of everything they could carry. The monks who commissioned the scroll wanted posterity to know exactly who had done it.

The ashigaru, literally the light-footed, first appear in strength in the Ōnin War of 1467–77, when both sides hired gangs of them to raid and burn Kyoto. A Zen monk’s diary describes three hundred men of the eastern army who called themselves ashigaru and charged into the enemy with no helmets, no spears, nothing but a sword each. Other witnesses saw them in gaudy headgear, half naked in winter, and looting temples. They were not samurai, and nobody at the time thought they were.

Within a century they were the backbone of every army. The great lords of the Sengoku era turned the ashigaru into drilled companies of pikemen, archers and, after the 1540s, matchlock gunners, and the professional warrior on horseback became an officer commanding them. One Japanese estimate puts the servants and hired men in a late Sengoku army at 58 per cent of its strength, and the Jesuit Luís Frois observed in 1585 that whereas Europeans fought for land, towns and riches, wars in Japan were almost always fought to carry off wheat, rice and barley.

Edo-period folding screen of the Battle of Nagashino showing matchlock gunners behind a wooden palisade
The Tokugawa line behind its wooden palisade at Nagashino in 1575, from a folding screen painted more than a century later. The man in the antlered helmet on the far left is Honda Tadakatsu, and the gunners along the fence are the soldiers who decided the day. The painter has given them a great deal less space than the horsemen, which is history written by the officers.

The famous victory of Oda Nobunaga and Tokugawa Ieyasu at Nagashino in 1575 is remembered as the day guns beat horsemen, which is a simplification, but the guns in question were fired by ashigaru. The samurai who rode behind them, Honda Tadakatsu among them, won fame and fiefs. The men at the fence were paid off and went home, if they had a home to go to.

The other thing to understand about the Sengoku countryside is that it was armed to the teeth. In much of central and eastern Japan a village boy received his short sword at the age of fifteen in a coming-of-age rite called katana-sashi, wearing the sword, and Frois noted that everyone, farmers included, wore a long and a short sword once he reached a certain age. Villages hunted down defeated warriors fleeing from battles for their armour and their weapons, and settled quarrels with neighbouring villages over water and woodland by force. Into this world came Toyotomi Hideyoshi, who intended to draw a line through it.

Drawing the line: the sword hunt and the edict of 1591

The order went out on the 8th day of the seventh month of Tenshō 16, which Japanese reference works convert to 29 August 1588 by the Western calendar, and it had three articles.

Farmers were strictly forbidden to keep swords, short swords, bows, spears or guns. The confiscated weapons would be melted down for the nails and clamps of the Great Buddha that Hideyoshi was building at Hōkō-ji in Kyoto, so that the farmers would be saved in the next world as well as this one. And a farmer who kept to his tools and his fields would prosper, along with his descendants, because his lord cared for him.

Portrait of Toyotomi Hideyoshi seated in white court robes, Kodai-ji temple, Kyoto, around 1598
Hideyoshi in the portrait at Kōdai-ji, the temple his widow founded in Kyoto, painted around the time of his death in 1598 and attributed to Kanō Mitsunobu. The man who took the swords away from the farmers had been born a farmer’s son himself, which may be why he understood exactly what a sword meant to one.

That is the text. The practice was messier, and the leading Japanese historian of the subject, Fujiki Hisashi, spent much of his career arguing that the sword hunt was never meant to disarm the countryside. Villages were often allowed to hand in a token, one long and one short sword per household, and to keep their spears, their bows and the guns they used against wild boar. In Hizen, according to Frois, swordsmiths went round first posing as buyers, recorded every good blade and its owner, and some hundred officials then came back and collected sixteen thousand swords.

Perspective print by Maruyama Okyo of the Great Buddha Hall of Hoko-ji in Kyoto
The Great Buddha hall at Hōkō-ji in a perspective print by the young Maruyama Ōkyo, drawn in the 18th century, long after Hideyoshi’s original statue had been wrecked by the great earthquake of 1596. The rebuilt hall in this picture burned after a lightning strike in 1798. Whether a single nail of either came from a farmer’s sword, nobody can say.

What the sword hunt did do, Fujiki argued, was turn the wearing of swords into a privilege that the authorities granted rather than a right that every grown man assumed. A farmer might still own a blade, and plenty did; what he could no longer do was wear it every day as a sign of who he was. That was the line. Japanese households still held around five million swords before the Pacific War, which tells you how complete the disarmament was.

Three years later came the order usually called the status edict, dated the 21st day of the eighth month of 1591. It banned samurai and military servants from becoming farmers or townsmen, banned farmers from leaving their fields for trade or day labour, and forbade anyone to hire a servant who had left his master without permission, on pain of death. For most of the 20th century textbooks presented it as the law that froze Japanese society into four classes.

Japanese scholarship has since taken that reading apart. The historian Takagi Shōsaku showed that the “samurai” in the text means wakatō, the lowest grade of military retainer, and that the whole order was an emergency measure to stop soldiers and porters deserting while Hideyoshi prepared to invade Korea. Several Japanese reference works now say flatly that calling it a status edict is a mistake. English-language accounts mostly have not caught up.

Two swords as a badge

The longer process the Japanese call heinō bunri, the separation of warriors from farmers, took the rest of the century and was never quite finished. Most domains moved their samurai off the land and into castle towns, where they lived on stipends paid out of the lord’s granaries.

Some did not. Tosa kept its gōshi, country samurai who farmed, which is the class Sakamoto Ryōma came from. Satsuma kept its warriors spread across 113 fortified districts, and in 1871 about a quarter of the domain’s whole population was of samurai rank.

The badge that marked them was the pair of swords. A samurai wore the long and the short sword together, the daishō, and English-language histories commonly date the rule requiring them on official duty to 1629. For townsmen the line hardened slowly: in Edo they were still allowed to wear two swords on journeys, at fires and at funerals until 1683, when the shogunate banned it. After that a village headman or a rich merchant could still be granted the right to a surname and a sword as a reward, which tells you how much the right was worth.

Desk jobs and debts: the Edo samurai

When Tokugawa Ieyasu won the civil wars, he inherited several hundred thousand hereditary fighting men and almost no fighting for them to do. The Edo era that followed gave Japan two and a half centuries without a civil war, broken by one large rising, the Shimabara Rebellion of the 1630s. The samurai stayed. What changed was their work.

How many were there? The first national register, compiled in 1872 with the old categories still in force, counted 1,282,167 people of shizoku rank, 3.9 per cent of the population, plus 659,074 of the lower sotsu rank who had been foot samurai and ashigaru, another 2.0 per cent. Together they make the figure of about six per cent you usually see. Sources variously give anything from five to ten per cent, depending on whether they count the rear vassals and military servants the register left out, and the proportion varied enormously by domain, from a few per cent in the commercial heartland to Satsuma’s quarter.

Folding screen of 1847 showing crowds of samurai and retainers waiting outside Edo Castle gates
A folding screen of 1847 showing a day when the lords attended Edo Castle. Most of the men crowding the open ground in front of the gates never went inside: the lords’ retainers waited outside, sometimes for hours, holding the spears, boxes and palanquins of their masters. Being in attendance was the whole job.

The shogun’s own direct retainers were split into the hatamoto, bannermen with the right to an audience with the shogun at Edo Castle, some five thousand three hundred households at the end of the 18th century, and the more numerous gokenin below them, who had no such right. The old brag about “the eighty thousand horsemen of the bannermen” only works if you count the vassals the bannermen were supposed to maintain. Bannermen with no post were not simply idle: they were grouped into formal categories of the unemployed, the yoriai and the kobushin, and paid a levy in lieu of service.

Every domain repeated the pattern in miniature, with its own ladder of grades: Chōshū recognised about forty. Edo practice divided the samurai into two kinds of service, the bankata, guards and military duty, and the yakukata, administration, and the second steadily swallowed the first. A samurai in Edo-period Japan collected taxes, audited accounts, ran the courts, policed the towns, surveyed the roads, managed forests and copper mines, taught in the domain school and escorted his lord’s procession to Edo and back under sankin-kōtai. My pieces on the daimyo and the Tokugawa shogunate show the machinery he worked inside.

Rice, brokers and the price of being a samurai

Most samurai were paid in rice, measured in koku, about 180 litres, and by the 18th century few of them still drew it from villages of their own. The ordinary mounted samurai of a domain typically held around a hundred koku, and a great many lesser men drew stipends of a few dozen bales. Rice had to be turned into money, and in Edo that was the business of the fudasashi of Kuramae, beside the shogun’s granaries on the Sumida River.

Edo cut-map of 1853 showing the shogunate rice granaries at Asakusa Okura and the Kuramae district on the Sumida River
An Edo street map of 1853 showing the Asakusa granaries, the comb of inlets along the Sumida where barges unloaded the shogun’s rice, and the district of Kuramae beside them. This is where the bannermen’s stipends were paid out, and where the brokers who lent against them grew rich. The granaries are gone, and Kuramae is now a district of small workshops and cafés.

The brokers started as agents who collected a bannerman’s rice and sold it for a small fee. Since they held the vouchers in advance, they began lending against them, and in 1724 the shogunate licensed 109 of them as a guild with a monopoly on lending to its own retainers, at around eighteen per cent a year. By the 1780s the brokers were the flashiest men in Edo and the bannermen were drowning. In 1789 the shogunate simply cancelled more than 1.18 million ryō of the debts its retainers owed them, which helped for about a generation.

The poorer houses took in work. Gokenin families in Edo were known for making umbrellas, bamboo goods and paper lanterns and for growing potted plants for sale, and the domains had their own versions. The proverb bushi wa kuwanedo takayōji sums up the attitude: a samurai who has not eaten still picks his teeth, so that nobody will know. The Inoyama ledger shows you the arithmetic behind the toothpick.

The class was more open at the bottom than its rules suggested. From the middle of the Edo period a rich farmer or merchant could buy his way in by paying an impoverished gokenin family to adopt his son; Japanese sources give prices such as a thousand ryō for a constable’s post and five hundred for a foot samurai’s. Katsu Kaishū, who negotiated the surrender of Edo in 1868, was the great-grandson of a blind moneylender from Echigo whose fortune bought his sons a bannerman’s status, by most accounts in 1769. Movement went the other way too: the novelist Takizawa Bakin left samurai service to work for a publisher and became a townsman.

Mathew Brady photograph of the 1860 Japanese embassy samurai with US naval officers at the Washington Navy Yard
The embassy the shogunate sent to ratify the American treaty, photographed by Mathew Brady at the Washington Navy Yard in 1860. The seated Japanese are the embassy’s officers, and they were civil servants to a man: envoys, inspectors and their staff. Washington society found their swords exotic. Their hosts would have recognised the paperwork.
Antonio Beato photograph of samurai of the 1864 Japanese mission to Europe standing before the Great Sphinx of Giza
Antonio Beato’s photograph of the shogunate’s 1864 mission to Europe at the Sphinx, on their way to Paris to negotiate the closing of Yokohama. The French refused, the envoys signed an agreement that went the other way, and they came home to be punished for it. The samurai abroad were diplomats, and diplomacy was as dangerous as anything at home.

What kirisute-gomen really allowed

The privilege everyone has heard of is kirisute-gomen (切捨御免), the samurai’s licence to cut down a commoner who insulted him. It was real, and it was narrower than the films make it. The phrase itself is a later coinage; Edo documents say teuchi or uchisute. The shogunate’s legal code of 1742, the Kujikata Osadamegaki, recorded the principle in an addendum to its article on killing: a samurai, even an ashigaru, who had no choice but to cut down a townsman or farmer guilty of an outrageous insult would not be held criminally liable.

Every condition in that sentence mattered. The insult had to be grave and public, there had to be witnesses, the killing had to be reported at once to the authorities, and there would be an inquiry. A samurai who could not prove his case was treated as a common murderer, and the custom grew up of not finishing off the man you had struck. A samurai who let himself be insulted in front of a crowd and did nothing could be punished for cowardice, so the privilege was also an obligation, and the sensible man avoided the situation altogether.

Meiji woodblock print showing Satsuma retainers attacking British riders at Namamugi in 1862
The Namamugi Incident of 1862 as a woodblock artist imagined it fifteen years later. Retainers of Shimazu Hisamitsu cut down the English merchant Charles Richardson on the Tōkaidō for riding into the lord’s procession. In Satsuma’s eyes it was a lawful case of punishing disrespect; Britain shelled Kagoshima the next year.

The records suggest it happened far less often than you would think. One study of Tokushima domain counted eleven such killings of commoners in roughly ninety years of the early and middle Edo period, against seventeen of a samurai’s own servants.

Japanese accounts of a case in Owari in 1697 tell of a retainer who bumped into a townsman in the rain, offered him a short sword so that they could fight fairly, watched him run off with it bragging that he had beaten a samurai, and ended up killing the man’s whole family and then himself. The domain abolished his house. That was the privilege in practice: a minefield.

By the late Edo period theatres and bathhouses kept racks where samurai left their swords at the door, and processions in Edo left gaps so that townspeople could cross the street; doctors and midwives on call were allowed to pass through. The new government quietly omitted the right from its criminal code and confirmed its abolition in 1871.

Women of the samurai houses

The women of the class are the half of the story the films leave out, and they ran a great deal of it. A samurai’s wife managed the household and very often its money while her husband served at the castle or in Edo, and by the end of the Edo period almost every woman of samurai rank could read. Girls of good houses were taught the naginata, the long-bladed polearm, as a household art, and divorce, though harder for a wife than for a husband, was not unknown.

Portrait of Nakano Takeko, the Aizu woman who fought in the Boshin War
The portrait usually reproduced as Nakano Takeko, daughter of an Aizu domain accountant posted to Edo, who led a group of women with naginata against the government army outside Aizu-Wakamatsu in the eighth month of 1868. She was killed by a bullet. By the usual account her sister cut off her head so that the enemy would not take it, and buried it at a temple outside the town.

Women who actually fought were exceptions, and the most famous of them, Tomoe Gozen, lives only in the war tales. The best documented are the women of Aizu in 1868, when Nakano Takeko and her companions fought outside the walls and Yamamoto Yaeko fought from inside Tsuruga Castle with a repeating rifle. The answer to the question of whether there were female samurai is that there were women of samurai rank, and a few of them went to war.

A code written down late

The other thing the films take for granted is a code. There was no single written code that all samurai lived by, and the word bushidō was rare until the 1890s. Edo samurai read Confucian ethics in the domain schools and called their ideal shidō, the way of the gentleman-official, and the books now thought of as samurai philosophy were mostly written by men who had never seen a battle, for readers who never would.

The great set pieces of samurai conduct that everyone knows, the vendetta of the 47 Rōnin in 1703, ritual seppuku, the duels of Miyamoto Musashi, were exceptional enough to be famous at the time. The Shinsengumi of the 1860s, whose first rule was not to depart from the way of the samurai, were led largely by farmers’ sons who had made themselves samurai with a sword and a uniform. That is a story about how desirable the status was, not about how most samurai behaved. The modern martial arts, kendō among them, inherited the vocabulary of the way of the warrior, but that is a Meiji story too.

Abolished in eight years

The samurai class was dismantled between 1869 and 1877, and the remarkable thing is how little it resisted. The Meiji Restoration was largely made by samurai, of Satsuma, Chōshū, Tosa and Hizen, and the men who abolished the class were nearly all members of it. They knew better than anyone what it cost.

Hand-coloured 1860s Felice Beato photograph of a group of samurai studying a map
Felice Beato’s hand-coloured photograph of samurai poring over a map in the 1860s. It has been catalogued both as Satsuma men and as Chōshū men, and since the two domains were enemies until 1866 and allies afterwards, the mix-up is almost appropriate. Some wear Western coats over their kimono; within a decade the swords would go as well.

The sequence went like this. In 1869 the lords handed their domains to the throne, and on the 25th day of the sixth month of that year, 2 August 1869 by the Western calendar, the government ruled that their retainers from the senior kinsmen down to ordinary samurai would now be called shizoku (士族), gentry, and before the year was out the lowest-paid had been separated off as sotsu. In 1871 the domains were abolished outright and the government took over the paying of every stipend in Japan. The same year a decree made it optional to cut the topknot and to go out without swords, and commoners had already been forbidden to wear them.

Portrait photograph of Yamagata Aritomo in dress uniform with decorations
Yamagata Aritomo, born into one of the lowest grades of Chōshū’s retainers, who studied military systems in Europe and came home to build a conscript army. His proposal of December 1875, which became the sword ban, asked the government to sweep away the empty title of warrior and the lingering habit of killing. He lived to be a field marshal, a prince and the most powerful man in Japan.

Conscription came into force on 10 January 1873, and with it the samurai lost the job that justified their existence. Every man of twenty was now liable in principle to serve, farmers’ sons included, and the government’s army filled up with exactly the kind of men the sword hunt had disarmed. Meanwhile the stipends were swallowing about a third of the national budget, paid to men most of whom held no post at all.

The sword ban of 28 March 1876

The order that ended the two swords was a Grand Council proclamation of 28 March 1876, number 38, which had no title of its own and has been known ever since as the haitōrei (廃刀令), the sword abolition edict. It forbade the wearing of swords except by those in full court dress and by soldiers, police and officials in uniform. Mori Arinori had proposed something similar in 1869, when the assembly voted him down for trying to sap the spirit of the nation and he lost his post. Seven years later nobody could stop it.

It banned the wearing of swords, not owning them, and the samurai noticed. Japanese accounts describe men who carried their swords about in cloth bags, or slung them over their shoulders on the grounds that a sword not worn at the hip was not being worn. The ban also caught commoners, who had kept the custom of wearing a short sword on journeys, at New Year calls, at weddings and at funerals, and the newspapers of 1876 reported a steady stream of arrests among farmers and townsmen who had not got used to the idea.

Tsukioka Yoshitoshi woodblock triptych of the 1876 Shinpuren Rebellion in Kumamoto
Tsukioka Yoshitoshi’s triptych of the Shinpūren rising in Kumamoto, rushed into print in 1876. About 170 men attacked the garrison at night with swords and spears, refusing firearms by their own choice. The army surgeon who treated the survivors made a set of drawings recording the sword wounds, which may be the last careful record of a Japanese sword fight made on purpose.

The money went the same year. In 1873 the government had offered samurai a lump sum, half in cash and half in bonds, for surrendering their stipends voluntarily, and about a third of them took it. In 1875 the stipends were converted from rice to fixed cash amounts. Then on 5 August 1876 the remaining stipends were abolished outright and replaced with government bonds worth between five and fourteen years’ payments, with interest at five to ten per cent, the higher rates for the smaller holders.

The arithmetic was brutal at the bottom. One Japanese estimate is that the former lords received bonds averaging over sixty thousand yen each, while the lesser samurai averaged around four hundred and ten, enough to bring in about twenty-nine yen a year, and the daily interest on a typical lower samurai’s bond came to about a third of a Tokyo labourer’s minimum wage. Most sold their bonds. A Tottori prefecture report of 1882 found that nine in ten of its shizoku had already done so.

Utagawa Yoshitora woodblock print of 1877 satirising former samurai running a shop
Shizoku no shōhō, “samurai in trade”, a print of 1877 by Utagawa Yoshitora mocking former samurai as shopkeepers. Their sweets carry punning names for the politics of the day, among them fuhei-tō, malcontents’ candy. The phrase became a proverb for any business started by someone too proud to run it.

“Samurai in trade”, shizoku no shōhō, became a byword, and the trades the newly penniless chose were sweet-bean soup stalls, dumpling shops, charcoal dealing and, above all, second-hand shops in which a family sold off its own heirlooms, often with a haughtiness that made customers laugh. Some did well: men of samurai families went into the bureaucracy, the army, the police, teaching and banking, and in 1881 about two-thirds of all government officials were shizoku. The future prime minister Hara Takashi, born to a senior Morioka family, split off his own household at twenty and was registered as a commoner, because heads of households were exempt from conscription. That is a fair measure of what the status was now worth.

The last risings

Not everyone went quietly. Etō Shinpei led a rising in Saga in 1874; the Shinpūren struck in Kumamoto on 24 October 1876, and samurai in Akizuki and Hagi followed within days. In 1877 Satsuma rose under Saigō Takamori, the most loved man of the Restoration, in what became the Satsuma Rebellion, the last and largest civil war in Japanese history. It ended on 24 September 1877 on the hill of Shiroyama above Kagoshima, where the last few hundred rebels were overrun by a conscript army of commoners.

Woodblock print of 1877 by Nagashima Mosai showing government troops storming Shiroyama in Kagoshima
The storming of Shiroyama, published in the same year by Nagashima Mōsai. The government troops in the foreground carry rifles under the rising-sun flag, and for most of the war so did Saigō’s. The rebellion was samurai against the state, not swords against guns, whatever the posters say.

After that the shizoku survived only as a word on a family register. It conferred no legal privileges whatever, though people put it on gravestones and on their curricula vitae, and it vanished from the registers only when a new family registration law took effect on 1 January 1948. The Meiji era had turned seven hundred years of warriors into a footnote in a civil-service form. The image of them, by then, had already gone off in another direction.

The screen samurai

The first samurai made for foreign consumption were photographs. From the 1860s studios in Yokohama sold albums of costumed figures to foreign travellers, and many of the warriors in them, armoured, sword drawn, glaring at the lens, were posed for the camera with props from the studio. They are real men in real armour, but they are performing a role for paying customers. In that sense the screen samurai are older than the screen.

Felice Beato studio photograph of the 1860s showing a shaven-headed samurai with a drawn sword
A samurai in Felice Beato’s Yokohama studio around 1864, sword drawn and fan in hand. The pose is pure theatre and the sitter may well have been a hired model; the albums sold to tourists and naval officers at high prices. This is where the global image of the samurai begins, not on a battlefield but in a rented room.

At home the samurai of legend came from the stage. The puppet play Kanadehon Chūshingura, first performed at Osaka in the eighth month of 1748, turned the 47 Rōnin into one of the most performed stories in Japanese theatre, with a cast of loyal retainers whose virtues were invented with great skill. The rōnin Akahane Genzō became “Akagaki Genzō” and acquired a famous scene in which, on the eve of the raid, he drinks a farewell to his absent elder brother by toasting the brother’s coat. The real man had no elder brother and was, by some accounts, a teetotaller.

Film still of Bando Tsumasaburo kneeling with a sake cup in the 1938 film Akagaki Genzo
Bandō Tsumasaburō as Akagaki Genzō in 1938, saying farewell over the sake that, if the story about the real rōnin is right, he never drank. Bandō was the great star of the sword-fighting films of the 1920s and 1930s, and he built his own studio at Uzumasa in Kyoto, then a district of bamboo groves.

The cinema took the theatre’s samurai and made them fight. The Japanese name for the sword-fight film, chanbara, comes from the clashing noise of blades, chan-chan bara-bara, and in the 1920s actors such as Bandō replaced the stylised kabuki fights of the earliest films with fast, violent choreography that audiences had never seen. Jidaigeki, period drama, became the backbone of Japanese film and later of television, and its streets were built in Kyoto, where you can still walk them.

View over the Edo-period street sets of Toei Kyoto Studio Park in Uzumasa, Kyoto
The Edo street sets of Toei Kyoto Studio Park at Uzumasa, where period dramas have been filmed for decades. You can walk down a samurai street that has hosted more sword fights than any real street in Japanese history. That is not a complaint; it is half the reason the real ones are remembered. Photo: Maksym Grinenko, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Abroad, the samurai arrived in two waves. The first was Nitobe Inazō’s book Bushido: The Soul of Japan, written in English in California and published in Philadelphia with 1900 on its title page, which presented the samurai as a Victorian gentleman’s moral code in armour. The second was Akira Kurosawa. His Seven Samurai of 1954 is set in 1586, two years before the sword hunt, and its rōnin hired by farmers became Hollywood’s The Magnificent Seven.

Toshiro Mifune as Kikuchiyo in Akira Kurosawa's Seven Samurai, 1954
Mifune Toshirō as Kikuchiyo in Seven Samurai, the farmer’s son pretending to be a samurai. His great scene comes when the others find the armour and spears the villagers have stripped from wounded and fleeing warriors over the years, and he rounds on them: who made the farmers like this? You did. It is the most historically acute moment in samurai cinema.

Kurosawa knew his history, and the best of his films are full of it. The trouble began when everyone else copied the swordplay and dropped the history. The Last Samurai of 2003 is the clearest case: its rebel lord is loosely modelled on Saigō, but Saigō had been the only full general in the government’s army and his men fought with rifles and artillery, and its American hero is loosely based on the French officer Jules Brunet, who fought for the shogunate in an entirely different war. It was shot largely in New Zealand, with its temple scenes filmed at Engyō-ji above Himeji.

The Daikodo and Jikido halls of Engyo-ji on Mount Shosha in Himeji
The lecture hall and dining hall of Engyō-ji on Mount Shosha, the Tendai temple outside Himeji where the Japanese temple scenes of The Last Samurai were filmed. The halls are centuries older than any of the samurai in the film, which never troubled anyone in the audience. Photo: 663highland, CC BY 2.5.

The television Shōgun of 2024, from James Clavell’s novel about an Englishman modelled on William Adams, did better with costume and language than any Western production before it, and it is still a novel. The screen also gave the world the black-clad ninja, the wandering masterless rōnin as a free spirit rather than an unemployed man with debts, and the question of whether Yasuke was really a samurai, which the evidence answers more cautiously than the internet does.

Put the screen and the record side by side, and the differences come down to a handful of things.

The weapon of the samurai was the bow for most of his history and then the spear and the gun, not the sword. Battles were fought by masses of foot soldiers, not by duels. There was no universal code, most samurai were administrators, they were a small minority of the population, and they took heads for the reward. And a great many of them were poor.

Where to meet the samurai today

The documented samurai left two kinds of thing behind: the streets they lived on and the objects they owned. There are no battlefields in this list; few of them are worth the trip. For the great warriors one by one, start with my ranked field guide to Japan’s greatest samurai, and for how the whole story fits together, Japan through the ages.

Kanazawa: Nagamachi, the Nomura house and the foot soldiers

If you see one samurai district, make it Nagamachi in Kanazawa, because it is the one place where a city of the class still feels lived in. The Maeda lords’ middle and upper-ranking retainers had their houses here, along the Ōnoshō canal, and the lanes of earthen walls and stone paving survive behind the busy Kōrinbō district. Most houses are still private homes, and in winter the walls are wrapped in straw mats against the snow, which is the best time to come. It is five or six minutes’ walk from the Kōrinbō bus stop, a short ride from Kanazawa Station.

Stone-paved lane between earthen walls in the Nagamachi samurai district of Kanazawa
A lane in Nagamachi between earthen walls capped with tile. The walls were built thick and plastered with clay against fire and snow, and keeping them that way is a constant job. Come early; by mid-morning the tour groups have found it too. Photo: Kanazawa City, CC BY 2.1 JP.

The Nomura house, home of a family of Maeda retainers, is the one to pay for. Its rooms are fine, but the reason people come is the small garden squeezed between the house and the wall, a pond, a stream and stepping stones in a space you could cross in ten paces. It opens 8:30–17:30, closing at 16:30 from October to March, and is closed only on 26–27 December and 1–2 January. Admission is ¥550, rising to ¥750 from 1 April 2027.

Garden of the Nomura samurai house in Nagamachi, Kanazawa, seen from the veranda
The Nomura garden from the veranda: water, stone lanterns and stepping stones in a strip of ground a few metres deep. An American garden journal ranks it among the best in Japan, which brings the crowds. The trick is to sit on the veranda and let them pass. Photo: Motokoka, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Then walk a few minutes further to the Ashigaru Museum, which is the antidote. It is two small houses of Kaga foot soldiers, the Shimizu and the Takanishi, moved here from the old ashigaru quarter in the 1990s, where people were still living in them until they were dismantled. They are plain and small, the homes of men who lived on a few dozen bales of rice a year. Admission is free and it opens 9:30–17:00.

Spend as long here as at the Nomura house, and remember the Inoyama were somewhere in between. Kanazawa Castle is ten minutes’ walk away.

The Kanazawa Ashigaru Museum, a relocated foot soldier's house in Nagamachi
The Ashigaru Museum in Nagamachi, a foot soldier’s house moved here from across the city with its little garden. People were living in it until it was dismantled, which is why it feels like a home rather than an exhibit. Photo: Kanazawa City, CC BY 2.1 JP.

Kakunodate: the samurai street of the north

Kakunodate in Akita is the most photographed samurai district in Japan, and in late April, when the weeping cherries over the black fences of its main street are in flower, it is also the most crowded. The town was laid out in 1620, with the samurai quarter on one side of a firebreak and the merchants on the other, and the wide main street of the samurai side still runs between gates and fences much as it did. It is about three hours ten minutes from Tokyo on the Akita Shinkansen, and the samurai street is fifteen minutes’ walk from Kakunodate Station.

Bukeyashiki-dori in Kakunodate, Akita, with weeping cherries in bloom and black fences
Kakunodate’s samurai street at the end of April, when the cherries and the crowds peak together. Come in autumn instead, when the maples turn and you can see the fences. Photo: 掬茶, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The Aoyagi house is the best known of the houses open to the public, the seat of a family that served the Satake lords until the Restoration. Its gate, of a type permitted only to upper samurai, was granted in 1860 as a reward for service to the domain, and the main house is about two hundred years old. The family was connected by marriage to Odano Naotake, a lower samurai of Kakunodate who drew the illustrations for the anatomy book Kaitai Shinsho in 1774, and the house has a gallery on him that is the best thing in it. Admission is ¥500; it opens 9:00–17:00 (to 16:30 from December to March), every day of the year.

The gate of the Aoyagi samurai house in Kakunodate under autumn maples
The Aoyagi gate in November. Inside, the complex has grown into half a dozen small museums and a costume photo corner, and you can safely skip the helmet try-on. Do not skip the anatomy-plate gallery: a provincial samurai teaching Japan to draw a human body from the inside is the samurai the films forgot. Photo: 掬茶, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Sakura: samurai houses and the national history museum

Sakura in Chiba is the place I send people with half a day before a flight from Narita, sixteen minutes away by train. The castle town of the Hotta lords keeps a street of samurai houses on Miyakoji-machi, three of them open to the public, small, thatched and set behind hedges; admission is ¥250, they close on Mondays (the following day when Monday is a holiday), and Sakura city’s culture section posts current opening hours.

Gate of the former Kawara family samurai house in Sakura, Chiba
The gate of the former Kawara family house, one of Sakura’s three open samurai houses. The hedge-and-earthwork frontage is typical of a mid-ranking retainer’s plot in a small castle town: enough land for a vegetable garden, not enough for pretension.

On the castle hill above stands the National Museum of Japanese History, Rekihaku, the best single museum in the country for seeing how the samurai fitted into everything else. Its galleries run from prehistory to the 20th century, and the medieval and early modern rooms are full of the documents, models and scrolls this article has been describing.

It opens 9:30–17:00 from March to September and 9:30–16:30 from October to February, with last entry thirty minutes before closing, and is closed on Mondays. Admission is ¥900. Walk fifteen minutes from Keisei Sakura Station, about fifty-five minutes by limited express from Keisei Ueno, or take the bus.

The National Museum of Japanese History in Sakura, Chiba, seen across its front garden
Rekihaku from its front garden. It is a large building on a quiet hill, and on a weekday you may have the early modern galleries almost to yourself. Leave at least three hours.

Tokyo National Museum, Ueno

For the things the samurai owned, the Tokyo National Museum in Ueno has no rival, and its Honkan, the main Japanese gallery, always has armour and swords on show in rotating displays. My guide to samurai armour covers what to look for. The museum opens 9:30–17:00, with later opening on some evenings, is closed on Mondays, and charges ¥1,000 for the collection galleries. It is about ten minutes’ walk from the park exit of JR Ueno Station.

The Honkan of the Tokyo National Museum in Ueno reflected in its front pool
The Honkan of the Tokyo National Museum, built in 1937 in the so-called Imperial Crown style, a concrete box wearing a tiled roof. Check the rotation before you go; the swords on show change every few weeks, and the national treasures come out only for short spells. Photo: Wiiii, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Chiran: Satsuma’s soldiers on the land

Chiran, south of Kagoshima, is the other end of the story from Kanazawa: one of Satsuma’s 113 outer districts, where the domain’s warriors lived in the country as soldier-farmers instead of in a castle town. The village kept its street of samurai houses with stone walls and clipped hedges, and seven of the gardens behind them, most of them dry gardens of stone and clipped shrubs with the mountain Hahagatake borrowed as a backdrop, are open on a single ticket. Admission is ¥530 and the gardens open 9:00–17:00, every day. The bus from Kagoshima-Chūō Station takes about an hour and twenty minutes to the Bukeyashiki-iriguchi stop.

Clipped azalea hedges and borrowed mountain view in a samurai residence garden at Chiran, Kagoshima
One of the Chiran gardens, clipped azaleas imitating hills and the real hills behind. These were the houses of men who were samurai by rank and farmers by habit, the sort the sword hunt was supposed to have abolished; Satsuma simply never did. Photo: Casey Yee, CC BY-SA 2.0.

Satsuma is also where the samurai ended. The Shiroyama hill and the rest of the 1877 sites are in Kagoshima itself, and I have written about them in the piece on the Satsuma Rebellion.

If you go to Nagamachi, look at the Nomura garden, by all means. Then go and stand in the ashigaru houses for a while, and think about the Inoyama, somewhere in the same city and a few rungs up the ladder, at a low table with an abacus, writing down what a funeral present cost and how much was left. That is what most samurai did for most of their history. The swords were for the gate.

Scroll to Top